Live data from Hacker News

Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

11–20 of 203 posts

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#11

Three plausible reasons off the top of my head on why open offices would experience less reported sick days. One: the same reason as experienced by garbage men or sewer guys; greater exposure causing improved immune systems. Two: being in an open office increases the top-down butts-in-seat observability, causing employees to come into the office even while sick to keep up a better work image. Three: (what happens at…

Mate, the results are the opposite. More sick days in open offices.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#12

Three plausible reasons off the top of my head on why open offices would experience less reported sick days. One: the same reason as experienced by garbage men or sewer guys; greater exposure causing improved immune systems. Two: being in an open office increases the top-down butts-in-seat observability, causing employees to come into the office even while sick to keep up a better work image. Three: (what happens at…

The findings were that open-plan offices lead to more sick days (62% compared to cellular offices)

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#13

Three plausible reasons off the top of my head on why open offices would experience less reported sick days. One: the same reason as experienced by garbage men or sewer guys; greater exposure causing improved immune systems. Two: being in an open office increases the top-down butts-in-seat observability, causing employees to come into the office even while sick to keep up a better work image. Three: (what happens at…

The finding is that open/shared offices increase, not decrease, sickness absences.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#14
post #9

Do they determine that people just take more sick days because they need some level of privacy while they work or because they are actually are getting sick more often? I would think its the former, tbh

I know it's a stretch, but the former could be analyzed in terms of sickness.

The paper actually refers to analysis of how background noise raises stress levels (with the resulting effect on absence) so it’s not so big a stretch.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#15

Do they determine that people just take more sick days because they need some level of privacy while they work or because they are actually are getting sick more often? I would think its the former, tbh

Office design's impact on sick leave rates (2014) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24460745 investigated this question.

"Sick leaves were self-reported ... as number of short and long (medically certified) sick leaves... A significant excess risk for sickness absence was found only in terms of short sick leaves." Which supports your hypothesis.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#16

Noise, permanent distraction, regular interruption, no privacy, and people spreading germs all over the place. No wonder that people get sick! I would rather be poor than work in a shared office one more time. (I have experienced both, so I know what I'm talking about.)

So have I. I wouldn't.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#17

Do they determine that people just take more sick days because they need some level of privacy while they work or because they are actually are getting sick more often? I would think its the former, tbh

> Do they determine that people just take more sick days because they need some level of privacy

Yeah, I too think this could explain it better. Say a work day is 8 hours, ideally, you cannot work on the same thing for 8 hours. But an open-plan office forces you to do this, or pretend to, because you are being "watched"...and this can be exhausting.

A cellular office plan, gives you the privacy to relax, and maybe do something else, then say when you feel refreshed, you get back to working.

An open-office plan encourages collaboration, but that's based on the assumption that we all work the same way.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#18

Do they determine that people just take more sick days because they need some level of privacy while they work or because they are actually are getting sick more often? I would think its the former, tbh

Could also be politeness. Maybe I feel okay about sneezing a lot in my own cube, but not on other people. So I take sick days I might not have if I were more isolated.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#19
post #10

Table 2: median days of sickness in single person offices in last year: 1.0. Median days of sickness in 6+ person offices: 2.0. Respective means are 4.9 and 8.1.

What's your point? Simply comparing the median is not really going to tell you much, especially since you need to adjust for confounding factors.

Re: Sickness absence associated with shared and open-plan offices (2011)

#20
post #15

Do they determine that people just take more sick days because they need some level of privacy while they work or because they are actually are getting sick more often? I would think its the former, tbh

Office design's impact on sick leave rates (2014) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24460745 investigated this question. "Sick leaves were self-reported ... as number of short and long (medically certified) sick leaves... A significant excess risk for sickness absence was found only in terms of short sick leaves." Which supports your hypothesis.

How does that support the hypothesis? One might conclude that the non-open plans mitigate the spread of short term sickness (e.g. colds) instead.
Post reply on HN