Live data from Hacker News

CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

go.theregister.com

191–200 of 220 posts

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or a browser that offers a first-class mining API. Then we'll see every device come with a specialized mining chip. As long as you meet the required number of hashes you get the add-free experience.

Sounds like an abomination.

It might force devs to optimize code more, since there will never be any more spare cycles muhahaha

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#192
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The cost to the viewer is ultimately a few cents of electricity And the cost to the society is few cents of electricity minus fraction of a cent the site gets, paid in fuel being wasted on producing that electricity. Crypto mining is a disaster. If I were an evil mastermind who wanted to deepen the energy and climate problems of the world, cryptocurrencies is what I would push for.

Why do you think that minor cryptocurrencies mining operations are worse in regards of wasted fuel than playing computer games, watching mindless YouTube videos, scrolling Facebook, leaving devices on when not used, lighting places 24/7 where nobody goes at night anyway etc.? We, as society, waste an enormous amount of resources anyway, I don't see how mining in browser would even dent that. Sure, these mega cryptocu…

Cryptocurrencies in the browser are[0] irrelevant. But they're a part of larger ecosystem of cryptocurrency mining, and that ecosystem is a huge problem.

> playing computer games, watching mindless YouTube videos, scrolling Facebook, leaving devices on when not used, lighting places 24/7 where nobody goes at night anyway etc.?

We do. But all those examples are the case where energy use gives us something (fun, convenience) and where the waste is bounded (there're only so many devices I can leave powered, and also I have to pay for the power they use). Crypto mining literally pays you for wasting power, so the more electricity you can burn, the more money you get. And the more people join in, the more you have to burn to keep up. So there's almost no ceiling to how much personally you get to waste, and a strong incentive to waste as much as you can.

And what's all of that for? To replace a system that works fine and does not have a greed-powered feedback loop of waste? That's just dumb.

--

[0] - Currently. Hopefully they'll always stay that way, but there's an off chance this becomes so popular that all new computers will come equipped with additional hardware and drivers to mine crypto for micropayments.

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#193
post #185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mining in a browser is going to consume my battery and bandwidth and you shouldn't be surprised that people aren't happy about that.

"Mining in a browser is going to consume my battery and bandwidth" You mean just like ads do? Of course, in a perfect world we wouldn't have either, but I just don't see clear distinction between mining in browser or ads or other useless/annoying things (from the user perspective).

In ads, waste of electricity is a bug. The more lean you can make them, the better (even if only because you can then put more of them). In cryptocurrencies, waste is a feature. The more power you burn, the more money you get.

One of those disincentivizes waste (howewer weakly). The other incentivizes it.

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#194
post #140
post #103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would they block miner.pr0gramm.com, which is only used in one specific place (the pr0gramm site itself) where you need to explicitly press a start button to mine?

"More than $BIGNUM entries? These guys know what they're doing!"

My point is that it's clear that you mine when you use their miner. You get premium points on the website as a reward. How is that shady? I think it's a perfect use case of where a web miner makes sense as an alternative monetization method.

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#195
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think that minor cryptocurrencies mining operations are worse in regards of wasted fuel than playing computer games, watching mindless YouTube videos, scrolling Facebook, leaving devices on when not used, lighting places 24/7 where nobody goes at night anyway etc.? We, as society, waste an enormous amount of resources anyway, I don't see how mining in browser would even dent that. Sure, these mega cryptocu…

Cryptocurrencies in the browser are[0] irrelevant. But they're a part of larger ecosystem of cryptocurrency mining, and that ecosystem is a huge problem. > playing computer games, watching mindless YouTube videos, scrolling Facebook, leaving devices on when not used, lighting places 24/7 where nobody goes at night anyway etc.? We do. But all those examples are the case where energy use gives us something (fun, conven…

"Crypto mining literally pays you for wasting power, so the more electricity you can burn, the more money you get."

Well, you (or somebody else) still has to pay for power consumption used for mining, so it just converts money you pay for energy bill to micropayments (though in very unfavorable rate as of yet). Don't get me wrong, I don't advocate such shady behavior in any way, just wanted to point out that this "wasted power" point is a bit of a stretch.

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#196
post #121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is that mining through the browser is very inefficient. I don't have numbers but it'd probably cost an order of magnitude more, at least, to mine on the browser. And I'm talking about CPU cryptos, forget about bitcoin.

That may be true for Ethereum or Bitcoin, but not for Monero. The Coinhive Monero miner is about 65% as fast as a native miner would be, at least in Browsers that support WASM. Disclaimer: I wrote the Coinhive Monero miner.

Only 65%? That’s an opportunity for a 50% speedup by writing in native code. And running on the GPU would be even faster, no? What’s the protection against that?

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#197
post #121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is that mining through the browser is very inefficient. I don't have numbers but it'd probably cost an order of magnitude more, at least, to mine on the browser. And I'm talking about CPU cryptos, forget about bitcoin.

That may be true for Ethereum or Bitcoin, but not for Monero. The Coinhive Monero miner is about 65% as fast as a native miner would be, at least in Browsers that support WASM. Disclaimer: I wrote the Coinhive Monero miner.

You get a lot of hate. But I think what you did was really cool!

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If it's worth it depends on the site, your target audience and the ads you'd be allowed to show based on your content. At this point, we (Coinhive) have paid out 992 XMR (about $89.000) to our users. We started this service 11 days ago.

$89.000 or $89,000?

992 XMR is about $88000 ( https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/monero/ ), so the 2nd one

Re: CBS's Showtime caught mining crypto-coins in viewers' web browsers

#200
post #72
post #31

I’ve been running a miner via coin-hive.com. The earnings are ridiculously low. With 5 ad slots, I make around $6 RPM. With coin-hive/monero, it's not even equivalent to $0.5. Unless you are a website with the page open for hours and you have millions of views, this does not even make sense. Or maybe I am not doing this right.

Yes this is what I calculated as well. Regular ads are still way more profitable - even if you somehow convince all your visitors to keep your page open 24/7. Even coinhive admit that you can't use this to make real money.

Who says you have to do only one?
Post reply on HN