Live data from Hacker News

Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

spectrum.ieee.org

11–20 of 191 posts

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#11
post #8
post #4

>will give the next generation of smartphones 30-centimeter accuracy instead of today’s 5-meters Didn't the US scramble the civilian signals specifically so it wouldn't be too accurate? And they're just okay with civilians having access to ultra accurate GPS receivers?

There's usually restrictions that kick in at certain altitudes and/or hardware restrictions if you're going over a certain speed. Depending on the source of signals used, the military can also just change the precision for civilian bands. But in times of peace / low threat levels, there's not a particular need to do so.

But that's client side right? What's preventing someone from implementing a GPS receiver using a SDR that doesn't have those restrictions?

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#12

As an avid hiker and runner I'm more excited to see what this will do for things like Garmin smart watches. I run through downtown Boston a few times a week and the accuracy is very bad at times making you look like you run much farther than you do.

Do you run the same path frequently? When I do, I keep the path the same, as I pre-calculate the distance, and can keep a watch to track my time. Thus I have no need for path tracking.

A GPS unit is useful for assisting dynamically changing routes (e.g. driving) or to track unknown paths (e.g. plotting your hike in snow/darkness). May I ask what you'd need a fine-accuracy GPS unit for during a run?

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#13
post #6

As an avid hiker and runner I'm more excited to see what this will do for things like Garmin smart watches. I run through downtown Boston a few times a week and the accuracy is very bad at times making you look like you run much farther than you do.

You could probably trade accuracy of route position for accuracy of distance by averaging samples.

You can see how off the trace can be here: https://i.imgur.com/eHJI8FH.jpg . You could probably do some smoothing to help fit some of this to a street but I've been on runs where I zig zag down streets just to add distance or to do hills.

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#14
I may just be a super-cynical ad-tech exile, but I see this as a path to getting shown more ridiculously well-targeted ads based on the places and stores I've been in. Beacons haven't taken off and I'm glad they haven't. I'd really prefer a GPS in my phone with a similar granularity to the one I have now. Google's notifications that I should review places I've been are creepy enough.

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#15
post #8
post #4

>will give the next generation of smartphones 30-centimeter accuracy instead of today’s 5-meters Didn't the US scramble the civilian signals specifically so it wouldn't be too accurate? And they're just okay with civilians having access to ultra accurate GPS receivers?

There's usually restrictions that kick in at certain altitudes and/or hardware restrictions if you're going over a certain speed. Depending on the source of signals used, the military can also just change the precision for civilian bands. But in times of peace / low threat levels, there's not a particular need to do so.

The restrictions are just from the manufacturer and can be disabled on request. We have to do this for our high-altitude balloon experiment.

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#16

As an avid hiker and runner I'm more excited to see what this will do for things like Garmin smart watches. I run through downtown Boston a few times a week and the accuracy is very bad at times making you look like you run much farther than you do.

The multipath in urban environments probably limits the accuracy, unfortunately.

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#17

As an avid hiker and runner I'm more excited to see what this will do for things like Garmin smart watches. I run through downtown Boston a few times a week and the accuracy is very bad at times making you look like you run much farther than you do.

Do you run the same path frequently? When I do, I keep the path the same, as I pre-calculate the distance, and can keep a watch to track my time. Thus I have no need for path tracking. A GPS unit is useful for assisting dynamically changing routes (e.g. driving) or to track unknown paths (e.g. plotting your hike in snow/darkness). May I ask what you'd need a fine-accuracy GPS unit for during a run?

For runs it's mostly just for fun. I use Strava so it has sections they identify along your run that they rank you against your friends and strangers. I do end up running very similar routes most of the time.

I mostly find the GPS invaluable in hiking. It can be a great thing to have on the top of a mountain in the winter with low visibility. If you get up to a summit and the weather turns, you can have the watch send you back down the way you came. Nice and safe.

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#18
post #14

I may just be a super-cynical ad-tech exile, but I see this as a path to getting shown more ridiculously well-targeted ads based on the places and stores I've been in. Beacons haven't taken off and I'm glad they haven't. I'd really prefer a GPS in my phone with a similar granularity to the one I have now. Google's notifications that I should review places I've been are creepy enough.

It's almost as though using a phone whose operating system is created and maintained by an advertising company isn't the best idea if you want to keep things like your location private.

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#19
post #14

I may just be a super-cynical ad-tech exile, but I see this as a path to getting shown more ridiculously well-targeted ads based on the places and stores I've been in. Beacons haven't taken off and I'm glad they haven't. I'd really prefer a GPS in my phone with a similar granularity to the one I have now. Google's notifications that I should review places I've been are creepy enough.

It's almost as though using a phone whose operating system is created and maintained by an advertising company isn't the best idea if you want to keep things like your location private.

What? Shudders...

Re: Super-Accurate GPS Chips Coming to Smartphones in 2018

#20
post #11
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's usually restrictions that kick in at certain altitudes and/or hardware restrictions if you're going over a certain speed. Depending on the source of signals used, the military can also just change the precision for civilian bands. But in times of peace / low threat levels, there's not a particular need to do so.

But that's client side right? What's preventing someone from implementing a GPS receiver using a SDR that doesn't have those restrictions?

Nothing at all: http://www.aholme.co.uk/GPS/Main.htm
Post reply on HN