Live data from Hacker News

GitHub Desktop 1.0

github.com

51–60 of 110 posts

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#51
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I still think git-cola is one of my favourite Git Ui's. Anyone know any other good ones?

GitKraken is the best GitUI I've ever used. I highly recommend it. I use it for personal projects and at work. Professional License is really reasonable.

Ugh, that pricing model though. $50/yr for something as 'simple' as a frontend for git when so many comparable alternatives exist for free.

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#53
post #25
post #23

They've gone to all the trouble of building an app using web technologies, but don't offer a Linux version? I develop on Linux because I deploy on Linux. I don't need a virtual assistant or animated emojis. I would quite like a nice Git UI however.

I still think git-cola is one of my favourite Git Ui's. Anyone know any other good ones?

https://github.com/magit/magit

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#54

Let me fix the marketing for you: GitHub desktop is designed for our non Linux users. We felt like you weren't comfortable with a command line so we targeted you. Minimum system requirements quad core CPU and 32GB of ram.

Making Git more accessible to non-developers (or people not comfortable with a command line) isn't some horrible thing like you're making it out to be.

Serious question...what use is git to a non-developer? I don't think I've ever used it for anything but code. You're not supposed to use it with huge files, so that kind of eliminates the one case I was thinking of (graphic design versioning).

Also if someone is a developer, they're only hurting themselves by not making an effort to get comfortable with the command line. Like half of my workflow wouldn't be possible without a familiarity with it.

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#55
post #50

Let me fix the marketing for you: GitHub desktop is designed for our non Linux users. We felt like you weren't comfortable with a command line so we targeted you. Minimum system requirements quad core CPU and 32GB of ram.

Out of curiosity I've downloaded the app and tried it, because everyone seemed to hate it. Bloated, slow, eats RAM like crazy they said. Everybody says it so it must be true, right? No. I was expecting a disaster and instead I got a nice little Git client (not really feature packed, but the advertised features worked as expected). It starts quite quickly (compared to GitKraken for instance which takes ~10 seconds on…

A lot of people HAVE tried the app. It's extremely noticeable and inferior in regards to UI performance. The 4GB comment also isn't an exaggeration if an electron app is left on for all day (slack, etc)

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#56
post #25
post #23

They've gone to all the trouble of building an app using web technologies, but don't offer a Linux version? I develop on Linux because I deploy on Linux. I don't need a virtual assistant or animated emojis. I would quite like a nice Git UI however.

I still think git-cola is one of my favourite Git Ui's. Anyone know any other good ones?

SmartGit - It's cross-platform and written in Java. Unlike most Java GUIs, this one looks professional, well thought out and has been quite stable as a daily driver. There is a commercial license, but the free version is quite sufficient for individual use.

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#57
Hey guys thanks for the work on this, I've been really impressed with the interaction and performance on the new Github Desktop. I have been using the Github Desktop since Github for Mac was in early versions.

It took a little getting used to, but the new version is much smoother and faster.

Two additions I would love to see ported over from github.com

* A toggle between inline and split diffs * A summary view with all changes on the current branch, not just per file changes

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#58
am i using the same clients as everyone here or do people just like complaining about electron at every opportunity?

the new client is actually much faster for me, it starts up faster (1.5s to show the gui fully loaded vs 4s to show the gui and another 3s to finish loading what's on the screen) and there's no lag when using it (unlike with the old client)

i also prefer the new ui, i find it to be clearer than the old one

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#59
post #3

I really like the old version better. I really dislike this "cross platform" crap that runs terrible. It's like using a javascript app. Not only that, they don't even have it for Linux, so what's the point of doing a cross platform interface...

Yeah, I'll be sticking to the old Mac desktop app too. Visual bugs with the commit timeline notwithstanding, it's solid and smooth. The electron replacement is comparatively janky. If they ever EoL the old true native Github Desktop, I'll probably switch full time to Fork, which is native Cocoa and generally great. I already use it a lot, but there are times when Github Desktop does things a little better. https://gi…

Thanks a lot for this link!

I've been using either the command line or GitKraken, but it's always nice to see a new tool :)

Re: GitHub Desktop 1.0

#60
post #3

I really like the old version better. I really dislike this "cross platform" crap that runs terrible. It's like using a javascript app. Not only that, they don't even have it for Linux, so what's the point of doing a cross platform interface...

Yeah, I'll be sticking to the old Mac desktop app too. Visual bugs with the commit timeline notwithstanding, it's solid and smooth. The electron replacement is comparatively janky. If they ever EoL the old true native Github Desktop, I'll probably switch full time to Fork, which is native Cocoa and generally great. I already use it a lot, but there are times when Github Desktop does things a little better. https://gi…

Fork developer here. Could you share what features you miss so I could implement them? You can use the feedback button on the toolbar in Fork or contact me directly by email: support at git-fork.com.
Post reply on HN