Live data from Hacker News

China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

bbc.co.uk

31–40 of 233 posts

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#31
post #6
post #2

Right now, I like anything that helps normalize the white-hot hype of cryptocurrencies. There's some real utility in this technology, and we won't get to see it until companies are forced to make sustainable business cases and serve real customers. However, > A website set up by the Chinese central bank warned that cryptocurrencies are "increasingly used as a tool in criminal activities such as money laundering, drug…

The sustainable business case is permissionless nature of Bitcoin. Everything else comes down to it. This talk of blockchain technology being somewhat of a new wonderful invention that's supposed to magically make companies more profitable...? Not so. The reason why Bitcoin exists is because governments want control over money. Bitcoin gives people freedom. Period. Everything else is noise.

> governments want control over money

Of course. And for a good reason. People utter this line as if governments wanting control over money was somehow bad.

Money, within all human societies that exist or existed, is pretty much synonymous with power. It is the tool that allows an individual to incent, compel and coordinate other people to do what said individual wants. With $1 you can make someone cook you a hot dog. With $1K you can get someone to give you pretty advanced tech. With $1M you literally make other people build you a house.

State by its design is supposed to have monopoly on ultimate power. Since money is synonymous with power, the state needs to control money in order to fulfill its function (and to secure its ability to fulfill that function). So it's obvious that the state may not be happy about technologies that prevent them from controlling the money. It's threatening the state's ability to enforce rules. And despite the popular dystopian rhetoric, state being able to enforce rules is almost always a good thing for the society.

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#32

Bitcoin and for that matter all crypto currency is a libertarian ideal. Libertarian ideals do not fit in communist societies. Regulation was always coming, as even liberal societies regulate. But regulation is only there to keep the established order. The established order is very afraid of crypto right now in the same way the music industry freaked out over MP3. I can't help it, but I get annoyed when crypto is bran…

The US takes active efforts to prevent USD being used in illegal activities. That's not to say that it isn't, but there are legal red flags if you try to haul a big pile of bills through customs. Cryptocurrency's entire use case so far has focused around illegal activity. Whether said activity is immoral is up for debate (you can certainly deem breaking the laws of some countries to be moral), but illegal? Absolutely.

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#34
post #18
post #15

As soon as I read this, two words came to mind: Capital flight. A growing number of Chinese nationals has been using Bitcoin to siphon money out of China over the past several years.[1][2] Not surprisingly, the Chinese government is cracking down on this innovative form of capital flight. [1] http://www.theepochtimes.com/n3/1891021-how-chinese-use-bitc... [2] http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/markets/chinese-i…

I used it to transfer money between countries with an exchange rate better than any other available. Surely this is not illegal?

Yes, unfortunately, that is indeed illegal.

That's exactly what capital flight is (one of its forms), and what most thrid-world countries try to avoid by these banning practices. They (we) have shitty unstable currencies and broken banking systems that the people have no trust in, so they use their savings to buy USD (hard to do in these countries) or Bitcoin to maintain value. Note that money doesn't even need to leave the country for it to be a form of capital flight; just the fact alone that you're buying foreign currency or Bitcoin in a black market.

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#35
post #10
post #3

But.. but.. an 'analyst' for CoinDesk said this was normal and the exchanges will just need to get a license and China welcome them back with open arms. The bullshit artists that already 'invested' in this scheme will now tell you that China did not matter and the people under them will parrot it. Anybody that disagrees simply doesn't understand Bitcoin or just mad that they could not get on the choo-choo train at th…

>The bullshit artists that already 'invested' in this scheme will now tell you that China did not matter and the people under them will parrot it. If you're so sure that it's bullshit you're free to put your money where your mouth is and short it.

I know you can short as an institutional investor on GDAX, but is it possible for the average person to do a BitCoin short?

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#36
post #20
post #3

But.. but.. an 'analyst' for CoinDesk said this was normal and the exchanges will just need to get a license and China welcome them back with open arms. The bullshit artists that already 'invested' in this scheme will now tell you that China did not matter and the people under them will parrot it. Anybody that disagrees simply doesn't understand Bitcoin or just mad that they could not get on the choo-choo train at th…

Some of us who have been holding since Bitcoin was worth $2 are laughing at you.

> Some of us who have been holding since Bitcoin was worth $2 are laughing at you.

You are unquestionably better than ignorant humans with liquid assets.

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#38
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The sustainable business case is permissionless nature of Bitcoin. Everything else comes down to it. This talk of blockchain technology being somewhat of a new wonderful invention that's supposed to magically make companies more profitable...? Not so. The reason why Bitcoin exists is because governments want control over money. Bitcoin gives people freedom. Period. Everything else is noise.

> governments want control over money Of course. And for a good reason. People utter this line as if governments wanting control over money was somehow bad . Money, within all human societies that exist or existed, is pretty much synonymous with power. It is the tool that allows an individual to incent, compel and coordinate other people to do what said individual wants. With $1 you can make someone cook you a hot do…

You think it's for good reason. Many people think it's for bad reason. Those people invented and developed Bitcoin. Now the people who think state has no business messing with money and private lives of people have an actual tool upon their hands.

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#39

Bitcoin and for that matter all crypto currency is a libertarian ideal. Libertarian ideals do not fit in communist societies. Regulation was always coming, as even liberal societies regulate. But regulation is only there to keep the established order. The established order is very afraid of crypto right now in the same way the music industry freaked out over MP3. I can't help it, but I get annoyed when crypto is bran…

Cash is the original anonymous "crypto"-currency. Still the preferred tool of money launderers, drug dealers, pimps, black marketeers, and other neerdowells everywhere. Also, offers real anonymity with no blockchain records.

Re: China orders Bitcoin exchanges in capital city to close

#40
post #8

I think this is a really good sign that it's a good idea to get out of crypto currencies. China is actually pretty good at making decisions to defend it's country from negative outside influence. Anywhere that hosts a bitcoin exchange is also hosting criminal activity. Consequently, Bitcoin exchanges are going to make areas more dangerous to live. It's just a bad business decision to allow it to exist in your country…

This is a really good point. I live Downtown near a BitCoin ATM. The neighborhood was really posh when I moved in.

Since the the BitCoin ATM was installed, home prices are down 25%, crime is WAY UP, and the transient population has exploded. People are talking about moving to Detroit to get away from the general rot and decay of the BitCoin defiled inner city. /s

Post reply on HN