Live data from Hacker News

China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

globalvoices.org

101–110 of 170 posts

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The USA doesn't have freedom of speech in any meaningful sense. You only have to look at the way peaceful protestors are treated to see that. The Occupy Wall Street protesters were treated horrifically. As more and more formerly public places are privatised and the veneration of private property as an ideal above all others continues, the USA is simply running out of places where you're even allowed to protest. And t…

Blocking a road is not free speech. Preventing people from going into a building is not free speech. This is just private citizens attempting to restrict the right of movement of other private citizens. The right to publish any media, no matter how obscene or political, is free speech. And the US has the closest to free speech of any major country.

> no matter how obscene

Not true: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Diana

> or political

Also not true: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treason_laws_in_the_United_Sta...

I'd recommend reading up on these:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comics_Code_Authority

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Picture_Association_of_...

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_blacklist

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_of_broadcasting_in_...

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_Act

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comstock_laws

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_the_United_State...

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#102

BUT,WE Chinese live a way far more free. There are laws but we don't care, we live as we wish and we don't need other's permission. However when it come to a group, or a company, you are right, there are laws just right for you.

How typical on HN for a Chinese perspective to be downvoted to the bottom of the thread while everyone else flagellates themselves for how "free" the USA is.

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#103
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's really interesting about this is how unstable it makes the country. Clamp down and eventually you end up in a USSR situation where the government suddenly disintegrates with little real warning because there is no feedback loop to maintain stability. Things seem ok because everyone ends up walking around pretending things are good even the people enforcing the rules. Untill you get a little spark and suddenly…

Chinese government is panicking over its crashing economy, and it shows in its actions. As of this year, it - banned soft cheese - banned all korean music and entertainment - (got rid of) Liu Xiaobo, the Nobel Laureate, and prevented his wife from leaving China - banned ICO - banned a bitcoin exchange - prevented its companies from investing overseas (Wanda, etc) - (rumored) prevented the richest person from leaving…

crashing economy? come on, can't wait for that, I have been hearing this for 25 years, please deliver it.

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#104
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm no expert on China, but this fits the pattern of them making extreme laws (ie death penalty for corruption) and then selectively enforcing them. Laws are tools for the party to use when it feels it might benefit, not universal rules.

What's really interesting about this is how unstable it makes the country. Clamp down and eventually you end up in a USSR situation where the government suddenly disintegrates with little real warning because there is no feedback loop to maintain stability. Things seem ok because everyone ends up walking around pretending things are good even the people enforcing the rules. Untill you get a little spark and suddenly…

Eh... I see the opposite.

China knows better than the west what powers can be exercised on the net.

They've been testing it for a long while and all the old assumptions "the net treats censorship as damage and routes around iT" etc. have been found wanting in China.

As the power of the nation state returns to ascendancy, now with IT firmly under its yoke, I suspect that China will do much better and succeed.

Instead - I think the west is going to end up following China in some format or the other.

Edit - as analogy: the market can remain irrational longmer than you can remain liquid.

Govt can suppress and succeed longer than you expect.

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#105
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's really interesting about this is how unstable it makes the country. Clamp down and eventually you end up in a USSR situation where the government suddenly disintegrates with little real warning because there is no feedback loop to maintain stability. Things seem ok because everyone ends up walking around pretending things are good even the people enforcing the rules. Untill you get a little spark and suddenly…

Chinese government is panicking over its crashing economy, and it shows in its actions. As of this year, it - banned soft cheese - banned all korean music and entertainment - (got rid of) Liu Xiaobo, the Nobel Laureate, and prevented his wife from leaving China - banned ICO - banned a bitcoin exchange - prevented its companies from investing overseas (Wanda, etc) - (rumored) prevented the richest person from leaving…

Thanks to Allah the almighty Jihad is still an allowed surname in the EU.

I guess it is a sign of the health of the economy of the EU.

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#107
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because so far every communist state has been created by violent revolutionaries side stepping the democratic process. The type of people who join a party that wants to shove the beliefs of 10% down the throats of the 90% are inherently authoritarian. Its no wonder they never become real democracies once they have total power.

I'm not sure this argument works -- many democratic states (including the US) were also created by violent revolutionaries.

I mean, it doesn't exactly help that the US happily destabilizes any budding, non-capitalist state and installs a puppet of their own...

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#109
post #10

The regulations also demand that all chat room users in mainland China verify their real identity... Effective 8 October, the following types of content will be prohibited in chat groups on China-based messaging platforms: 1. Sensitive political content 2. Rumors 3... Holy shit. What is this going to do to the Chinese tech scene? The liability being created here is crazy to consider. Lets all hope these practices are…

It is not only in China:

https://www.theverge.com/2017/6/30/15898386/germany-facebook...

Re: China Makes Chat Group Administrators Criminally Liable for Unlawful Messages

#110
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because so far every communist state has been created by violent revolutionaries side stepping the democratic process. The type of people who join a party that wants to shove the beliefs of 10% down the throats of the 90% are inherently authoritarian. Its no wonder they never become real democracies once they have total power.

I'm not sure this argument works -- many democratic states (including the US) were also created by violent revolutionaries.

The american colonies were not democratic, they needed a violent revolution to create a democracy. There was no peaceful mechanism for them to take power.

Russia and China were already democracies before the authoritarian parties took over. They could have peacefully taken control in elections if they were able to convince the voters. But instead they disbanded the legislatures and stopped having elections.

Post reply on HN