Live data from Hacker News

I created a bookmarking service you can love.

historio.us

21–30 of 110 posts

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#21
post #14

Nice work. Signed up. I agree with @thejash - Any chance we can import bookmarks from Delicious etc?

Importing from delicious exists (click "historify site" on the top right) and will be re-enabled as soon as we finish testing the new, faster backend. Please stay tuned (and follow us at @historrific), we're sciencing as fast as we can!

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#22
post #7

Okay, quick feedback. The first thing I looked for is the answer to "Public or private?" Privacy policy has this: > We will also never share the content of your historified pages with anyone, although we might use the URLs of pages to compile anonymized lists of popular or new links. We will, however, never share any information about which pages you, personally, have historified. I think that might be a mistake. You…

First of all, thanks very much for your feedback! To address your points, there are no plans for your bookmarks to be public, or have an option to show a page with them, either. The nature of the site doesn't lend itself to public bookmarks at all, as there is no list of bookmarks to publicise in the first place. To make it public we would have to add a search box for people to search in your bookmarks, which may or…

I am pretty sure this is a case of users not knowing the difference.

I wonder if you asked them if they wanted to be able to share with others?

One last thing.

You won't get anything out of asking users.

What you will get something out of is asking customers.

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#23

Fast site. What environment are you using? Also, on the page with the instructions I think the instructions should be at the top. People are less concerned with the other stuff.

You mean the screen you see the first time you log in? That's just a short preamble to tell you how to use historious (many people aren't very technically minded and don't immediately see how to use the service). Hopefully it's not too much to read quickly, though!

Thanks for your feedback!

EDIT: Sorry, I didn't answer your first question: We use a Linode in Georgia, so if you're near there it should be pretty fast (their servers are quite fast too).

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#24
As others have mentioned, Delicious import would be handy. Even better, however, would be to take it a step further and automatically import on an on-going basis. This would achieve the following workflow:

1. In my Historious settings, add my Delicious feed URL

2. Find a cool link and add it via the Delicious bookmarklet

3. Historious polls the feed, picks up the new link, and grabs the page

Now I have the best of both worlds:

1. If I want to see a list of my URLs, I can browse them via Delicious.

2. If I want to search the saved page data, I can do so via Historious.

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#25
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

First of all, thanks very much for your feedback! To address your points, there are no plans for your bookmarks to be public, or have an option to show a page with them, either. The nature of the site doesn't lend itself to public bookmarks at all, as there is no list of bookmarks to publicise in the first place. To make it public we would have to add a search box for people to search in your bookmarks, which may or…

I am pretty sure this is a case of users not knowing the difference. I wonder if you asked them if they wanted to be able to share with others? One last thing. You won't get anything out of asking users. What you will get something out of is asking customers.

I never thought of it that way, but you are absolutely right. Thank you for that perspective.

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#26

As others have mentioned, Delicious import would be handy. Even better, however, would be to take it a step further and automatically import on an on-going basis. This would achieve the following workflow: 1. In my Historious settings, add my Delicious feed URL 2. Find a cool link and add it via the Delicious bookmarklet 3. Historious polls the feed, picks up the new link, and grabs the page Now I have the best of bo…

As I mentioned below, there is a delicious importing feature but it has been disabled while we test the new, faster backend. The workflow you propose would be very handy, but it would have to support more sites... Luckily, we have an API anyone can use to write their own tools to add sites to historious!

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you for your feedback, it is much appreciated! The point of the site is to not have lists of bookmarks, though, so you can add many many sites and then find them easily. I find that, if I have a list, I tend to either try and keep it tidy or, if I don't, I just get frustrated and never look at it. We wanted historious to never show you the extent of your bookmarks, and to just give you the info you want transpa…

Ok, I like the idea of a private service. It makes sense. However: * Convince me that this will remain private, forever. * Assure me that this will remain in business. You can do this in two ways: 1) Charge me $10 a year. 2) Provide an export function from the get go.

Oh, I bet you'll like http://historio.us/export/, but you can still pay us $10/yr if you want!

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#29
This looks like a useful service, but just wanted to point out that having a JS embedded button might not be the best way of going about it, or at least in it's current form with the historious_key as the only means of authentication. If a site is expecting historious users, it can have a simple javascript polling loop that wait until the historious bookmark is activated to jack the key.

Re: I created a bookmarking service you can love.

#30
I'm using Delicious and perhaps I'm missing something, what do you guys do differently? I use Gnome search extension to search my Delicious history and have a FF plugin to bookmark pages: what am I missing?

I'm sure there' something unique about your service, I'd highlight it more right there on the front page, specifically for Delicious users, since it's proven that they like this type of service and you need to concentrate on converting them.

Post reply on HN