Live data from Hacker News

My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 10 posts

My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#1
I want to build a peer-to-peer search platform on the blockchain.

The experience would flow something like this: I type in a search query. I hit enter. I see a loading view that says 'Finding the right person.' In the background, the server is matching the search request against all of the profiles it finds relevant. Once a match is found, I'm taken to a chat view, where I'm able to message the other person in real-time. I can then ask more follow-up questions, and they can ask questions back to understand my context. Once the conversation is over, I see a rating view where I can rate the other person from 1-5 stars, and they do the same for me.

Whenever I tell a family member or close friend that I want to build this, they look at me, their eyes squint, and they say either, 'What? Why?' or 'Doesn't Google do search?'

Am I crazy? Or do they not see how powerful this could be?

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#2
What is the point of the service? Who gets paid and by who? There is already a Q and A site built on ethereum where people can answer questions and the highest upvoted answer gets a ETH reward.

Sounds like quora or stack overflow with cryptocurrencies

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#4
I want to build a peer-to-peer search platform on the blockchain.

How does the blockchain figure in? How are you not doing ______ "but now, with blockchain!!!"

Why would an expert (presumably) sign up to answer questions from strangers? What makes your pellets delicious?

http://dilbert.com/strip/1995-01-25

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#5
Personally I would not use this type of service.

When I search I either want close-to-instant knowledge that I need (for simple info), or an archived discussion (for more complex).

The problem I see with this service is the speed of it. In the time it would take me to ask a question, get matched with someone, start a conversation, answer follow up questions, and (maybe) reach an answer - I could have searched multiple pages of Google/stackoverflow/quora results.

Also there is no guarantee that the person who is answering is knowledgeable and not trolling. At least with standard search you have a wealth of information (results) to compare against.

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#6

What do you mean by "peer-to-peer" search platform. Are the people asking each other questions, instead of using a search engine? Or is it just a platform to chat with random people?

Each topic, say cryptocurrency, would be a network of knowledgeable, skilled and experienced people. Each of these people would accept incoming search requests to answer questions, explain information, come up with solutions, etc. Because each request isn't static anymore, but dynamic-- the tool's utility can grow from being only information to being collaborative as well.

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#7
post #4

I want to build a peer-to-peer search platform on the blockchain. How does the blockchain figure in? How are you not doing ______ "but now, with blockchain!!! " Why would an expert (presumably) sign up to answer questions from strangers? What makes your pellets delicious? http://dilbert.com/strip/1995-01-25

At first, we would use the blockchain to build an 'inflationary model.' See here for a deeper explanation: https://medium.com/@intenex/stream-101-making-content-creati...

Essentially, as the platform grows we mint new tokens. The more you contribute to the growth of the platform through doing an awesome job fulfilling search requests, the more of these tokens you earn.

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#8
post #4

I want to build a peer-to-peer search platform on the blockchain. How does the blockchain figure in? How are you not doing ______ "but now, with blockchain!!! " Why would an expert (presumably) sign up to answer questions from strangers? What makes your pellets delicious? http://dilbert.com/strip/1995-01-25

Stream will be using this model. Steem.it is currently using it too.

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#9

Personally I would not use this type of service. When I search I either want close-to-instant knowledge that I need (for simple info), or an archived discussion (for more complex). The problem I see with this service is the speed of it. In the time it would take me to ask a question, get matched with someone, start a conversation, answer follow up questions, and (maybe) reach an answer - I could have searched multipl…

Valid points.

To the speed point, we would have an incentive structure that would facilitate the fastest possible responses.

And to the trolling point, to become a 'partner' on the platform it wouldn't just be a simple sign-up form-- there would be a peer-to-peer interviewing system. Say you were an expert on ketogenic diets and wanted to join the platform. In order to do so, you would have to be interviewed by someone already on the platform as a keto partner.

Re: My friends and family think my idea is crazy. Want to gather more opinions

#10
post #4

I want to build a peer-to-peer search platform on the blockchain. How does the blockchain figure in? How are you not doing ______ "but now, with blockchain!!! " Why would an expert (presumably) sign up to answer questions from strangers? What makes your pellets delicious? http://dilbert.com/strip/1995-01-25

At first, we would use the blockchain to build an 'inflationary model.' See here for a deeper explanation: https://medium.com/@intenex/stream-101-making-content-creati... Essentially, as the platform grows we mint new tokens. The more you contribute to the growth of the platform through doing an awesome job fulfilling search requests, the more of these tokens you earn.

What gives the tokens value? They're worthless until there are enough users to answer questions on most subjects. However, it's very difficult to create networks that rely on users to gain users. As others have mentioned, convincing users to use your service over stackoverflow/quora will be very difficult at first. You'll need to get a critical mass of guaranteed users before the site goes live in order to succeed.