Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 109 posts

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#71
post #8

I did: http://www.publicstatic.net/2009/01/sure-change-jobs/ The biggest adjustment for me was money. I'd gotten so used to buying whatever I wanted (not large things) that I had some money trouble early on. But I'm back to programming now. I love it.

It's a great story, inspiring even, why don't you do an HN post ?

Thanks! But it's an old post. :-)

I should probably clean it up, too. Some of the formatting got butchered in a server move.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#72
post #60
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

a bit of everything

:\ really no focus? even something general like, "web development" (as opposed to "game development", "financial software"). i'm curious because i wonder what fields it's easy to find work in again after a year off.

At the time it was python, databases, C, unix and java. A mixture of sys admin and development for online medical records. Part of the reason I left was because I found that I could not cope with how boring my job was. I do not compartmentalize very well. When I returned, I worked for a place that made a music player.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#73

Go back and do a PhD? +'s - When you finish, you should be pretty marketable Pick up a whole new set of research skills Support group shouldn't be a problem in a university environment Potential for coding if you want to. Someone with industry experience will tend to have a good idea of what will work in reality -'s You will take a hit money wise until you qualify You could perhaps look at doing a masters as an inter…

Do - not - listen - to - him !!!

PhD is a long and uncertain education path... that leads to an even longer and more uncertain career path.

Oh, and you will be 5+ years older that everybody else.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#74
post #53
post #49

“Oh, you hate your job? Why didn't you say so? There's a support group for that. It's called EVERYBODY, and they meet at the bar.”" -George Carlin

This is just a joke, I wouldn't take it seriously. Do you really think Carlin hated his job?

Yes, I bet there were times that he did. Especially before he was "George Carlin, world famous comedian" and was just some guy trying to land enough gigs to feed himself.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#75
Same story. Different direction.

Worked on Wall Street for almost 20 years. Did everything from quant finance to selling bonds to managing technology project. Left in 2004 (yes, deferred comp was left on the table), moved to Australia to study machine learning and collected a doctorate. Started a biofuel company (long story).

Now, six years later, I'm founding a quant marketing startup. Net result: less salary, more upside, more psychic benefits. Make sure your spouse is up for it and they are willing to grow. If so, you'll be closer otherwise the inevitable stresses may take their toll. Mine ended up getting an MFA and a new career of her own.

Turns out my neighbor in Australia was a senior product developer at Microsoft before he decided to move to an atoll in the Pacific and then get a biology degree. He used to jokingly accuse me of copying him. (Typical Microsoftie.)

I think the bottom line is that mastery is not enough for some people. The 21st century midlife crisis cannot be cured with a new Porsche. You need another mountain to climb.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#76
post #59

Go back and do a PhD? +'s - When you finish, you should be pretty marketable Pick up a whole new set of research skills Support group shouldn't be a problem in a university environment Potential for coding if you want to. Someone with industry experience will tend to have a good idea of what will work in reality -'s You will take a hit money wise until you qualify You could perhaps look at doing a masters as an inter…

Are there attractive, single members of the opposite sex involved with this? If so, just let me know which colleges I should apply to.

Depends what you do your PhD in.

Biology probably has the best balance between "attractive" and "sane" you're going to find.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#77
post #51
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Funny, but not as funny as if it were true. PP is when you're competent and get promoted to something you suck at; Peter's suggestion is the other way around. Sorry to nitpick.

But isn't it true? If someone is succeeding as a programmer, that says nothing about how they'll do as a manager. Therefore pushing for that promotion is a good way to wind up getting promoted to something you such at. Which is the Peter Principle at work.

But the OP's contention is that he isn't a very good programmer, while some of the qualities he says he has sound like they'd be good for somebody in an oversight role.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#78
post #21

I'm going to make an analogy to love. In the beginning, you're attracted to someone mostly because of looks. Then you get to know all the good things (s)he has shared with you. Eventually, the passion flame wanes and you're now able to see her/his ticks and vices. The flaws. Getting into software development is similar. At first you get excited by your first "hello world", then you find all sorts of cool things that…

Your comment made me think in a different direction.

I had originally gotten in programming, as you said because of the excitement of hacking, "hello world"; it was an intrinsic joy that I had that I derived although extrinsic rewards (striking it rich) was in the back of my head. But it wasn't the extrinsic demands that was driving me day-to-day, otherwise I would have gone into accounting instead of programming.

But it was all of these extrinsic demands that pushed me to climb the corporate ladder, deal with maintenance & management etc. In so doing, I was telling myself that I had to plough through these minutiae to get to my big external validation of climbing the ladder, becoming rich, etc - when in fact, it was my intrinsic motivation that got me to where I was from the get-go. And if getting to the and staying at the top means sacrificing the internal joy for external validations, then it's not worth it.

I used to think that dropping your obligations to the ladder is counterproductive to your career. But not anymore when I spend more rationalizing and calming myself down from all of the angst of writing TPS reports and posturing/covering my ass during meetings. I don't even have anymore energy/time to actually write code. And that's pretty damn counter-productive.

I always have taken a broad definition of hacking and I see this pattern everywhere. You could see playing guitar as having fun creating music & expressing yourself, or memorizing sets & rehearse & network to get your band signed to a huge label. You could see making friends and picking up women as having fun meeting people & expressing yourself, or memorizing sets & rehearse & network to up your social worth, etc.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#79
post #14

I'm really just a mediocre programmer with really good domain knowledge Your problem is that you have no problem. Let me explain... I believe that the "quality" of a programmer is not how much you know, but what you can do with it. So it you have "really good domain knowledge", then you probably aren't a mediocre programmer at all, you're probably a good programmer or even better. Like many other hn'ers, I love to co…

great advice (as usual), edw519 ... have you thought about starting a blog with an FAQ mined from your responses from "Ask HN" questions? an easy hack that someone else could even do would be to troll through "Ask HN" threads, extract the ones where your answer was highest-ranked, and slap them together on a webpage somewhere. then that could be manually filtered and curated. i think that this would be a helpful page…

Thanks for the kind words, pgbovine.

Yes I have thought about starting a blog for some time, but I was always afraid it would take time away from my programming.

Oh, what the heck...

http://edw519.posterous.com/

I have updated my hn profile.

Now I have a weekend project.

Re: Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software dev behind?

#80
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is just a joke, I wouldn't take it seriously. Do you really think Carlin hated his job?

Yes, I bet there were times that he did. Especially before he was "George Carlin, world famous comedian" and was just some guy trying to land enough gigs to feed himself.

Maybe. It's just as possible he always loved being a comedian, even when it was hard to find work. The point is that he found a job he loved. No one should live under the assumption that everyone hates their job because of a joke.
Post reply on HN