Live data from Hacker News

A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

blog.mozilla.org

1–10 of 44 posts

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#3
post #2

I'm sorry, but an article like this should contain quotes or at least links to the actual text under discussion. Like this, it's only an opinion piece.

Mozilla is biased (towards open internet, liberalism, etc) so evidently this is an opinion piece--they are asking us to stop something they don't agree with!

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#4
post #2

I'm sorry, but an article like this should contain quotes or at least links to the actual text under discussion. Like this, it's only an opinion piece.

Mozilla is biased (towards open internet, liberalism, etc) so evidently this is an opinion piece--they are asking us to stop something they don't agree with!

what/where is the something?

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#5
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mozilla is biased (towards open internet, liberalism, etc) so evidently this is an opinion piece--they are asking us to stop something they don't agree with!

what/where is the something?

They explain it in TFA: https://changecopyright.org/en-US/

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#6
Very bad reform. Among the other things, it makes any site directly responsible for every copyright violation of its users.

For a change, this is as bad for big and small companies.

Not even Facebook can policy all the posts of their users for words, pictures, sounds and videos. FB won't get a takedown notice, it could be sued directly.

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#7
post #2

I'm sorry, but an article like this should contain quotes or at least links to the actual text under discussion. Like this, it's only an opinion piece.

I might be wrong, but I think that they haven't posted any actual text because the document(s) got leaked.

If you're looking for a proper discussion about this and the actual text, EDRi (something like EU's EFF) is probably what you're looking for. They did an extensive coverage of this in the last couple of days and have published the leaked documents.

Some links:

https://edri.org/leaked-document-eu-presidency-calls-for-mas...

https://edri.org/estonia-loves-digital-why-is-it-supporting-...

https://edri.org/six-states-raise-concerns-about-legality-of...

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#8
post #2

I'm sorry, but an article like this should contain quotes or at least links to the actual text under discussion. Like this, it's only an opinion piece.

I think this is the directice in question: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELE...

Summary: https://iplens.org/tag/proposal-for-a-directive-on-copyright...

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#9
post #2

I'm sorry, but an article like this should contain quotes or at least links to the actual text under discussion. Like this, it's only an opinion piece.

I think this is the directice in question: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELE... Summary: https://iplens.org/tag/proposal-for-a-directive-on-copyright...

More info:

http://www.europarl.europa.eu/oeil/popups/ficheprocedure.do?...

Re: A Copyright Vote That Could Change the EU’s Internet

#10
post #2

I'm sorry, but an article like this should contain quotes or at least links to the actual text under discussion. Like this, it's only an opinion piece.

I found this[0] (PDF) to be a good summarized critique of the proposal.

This one[1] as well, although it's a bit longer.

[0]: https://www.communia-association.org/wp-content/uploads/2016...

[1]: http://copyright4creativity.eu/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/DC...

Post reply on HN