Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Angular vs. React vs. Vue

medium.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

61–70 of 77 posts

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#61

Post by ranit »

atoko wrote: post #30
ranit wrote: post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This started after recent Facebook decision to change React license.

Can you expand on that?

What I meant was: Since facebook new licence was posted

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15050841

numerous articles appeared on HN front page, like

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15052691

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15147462

also some about other alternatives. Which is a good thing, all together.

BTW, for what it is worth, I don't have stake in any of these platforms, just wanted to point a possible reason to the GP's comment "I'm just really glad Vue is now included in every "X vs Y" framework, or "choosing a js framework", almost every article for the past two years have only been for Angular or React."

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#63

Post by pbreit »

alexssung wrote: post #60

I'm disappointed to see RiotJS not getting much attention lately. I've been using it for a B2B SaaS application and it has been intuitive and elegant to use, and easy to pick up for any Javascript developers. I tried learning Angular but found it to be too monolithic, and I'm currently using React Native to develop the mobile apps. If React Native is any indicator of how React web works, I don't think it compares to…

You should try Vue.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#64

Post by tmp489889 »

wiradikusuma wrote: post #9

I recently used both Angular 2 and React (the latter more recent) in some small projects. While I enjoyed working with React, I think Angular is more suited for me, a one-man startup. A lot of decisions are already made and I just follow them. In React, every time I need something not built-in (which is very often), I have to do some research, and even after deciding one, I have this "what if I'm wrong" guilt at the…

Angular its what you get when a bunch of java programmers with bad taste do what hey want. React-redux is really simple i don't understand why people have a problem understanding it. Please just make a little effort and use react. Angular is horrible and dead and if you use it some poor soul its going to have to maintain that legacy java weird mess.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#65

Post by yuskii »

tmp489889 wrote: post #64
wiradikusuma wrote: post #9

I recently used both Angular 2 and React (the latter more recent) in some small projects. While I enjoyed working with React, I think Angular is more suited for me, a one-man startup. A lot of decisions are already made and I just follow them. In React, every time I need something not built-in (which is very often), I have to do some research, and even after deciding one, I have this "what if I'm wrong" guilt at the…

Angular its what you get when a bunch of java programmers with bad taste do what hey want. React-redux is really simple i don't understand why people have a problem understanding it. Please just make a little effort and use react. Angular is horrible and dead and if you use it some poor soul its going to have to maintain that legacy java weird mess.

>React-redux is really simple i don't understand why people have a problem understanding it.

I keep experiencing this. JS developers that should have no problem understanding redux's approach, throwing it away because they are unwilling to simply read redux's docs. It's disheartening.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#66

Post by yuskii »

hateful wrote: post #23

"If you love TypeScript: Angular" I would add an "(or Vue)" to this. When I first started out with Vue a month ago, there were some weird idiosyncrasies with typescript (IMHO). But the latest updates to "vue-class-component" and "vue-property-decorator" have fixed most of them. tip: I believe they're still working on a good option in the current CLI ( https://github.com/vuejs/vue-cli/issues/263 ) but one of the templ…

I would also add React to this as well. Having built 2 react/redux/typescript apps, I can say that the TS ecosystem for react is quite excellent.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#67

Post by evilduck »

seattle_spring wrote: post #53
okket wrote: post #2

Ember is so good, it does not need comparisons any more :) https://medium.com/@alvincrespo/ember-your-best-bet-b5cd7275...

One of the big reasons I avoid Ember is exactly this attitude. I have worked with people who, in a complete serious manner, think that Ember is so much better than everything else for everything. They won't STFU about it. It reminds me a lot of Rails bootcamp graduates.

People evangelize what works well and Ember works well. Hell, Rails works well. The thing about Ember though is that there' aren't code camps teaching it afaik.

Ember has been an "island of stability" in the front end craziness of the last 5 years. They've navigated the trends pretty well and have a complete and competitive offering.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#68

Post by davidjnelson »

usaphp wrote: post #34
mudbutt wrote: post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would argue that it is by far the worst Framework one could possibly choose.

Can you explain why?

Composing components is not easy in ember. The component model in general is much less sophisticated than react or angular.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#69

Post by davidjnelson »

mudbutt wrote: post #29

It drives me crazy when I hear things like Angular4+ is better for "Large Ambitious Applications with large teams" when in reality Angular4 suffers from the same slow down/performance problems as Angular 1.x. https://github.com/angular/angular/issues/14041 https://www.airpair.com/angularjs/posts/angularjs-performanc... I mean it's like they ignored all of the lessons and knowledge the industry has learned and produce…

I prefer react but angular 2 and 4 are quite good. When used with ChangeDetectionStrategy.OnPush and ngrx/store, it's great to work with. String dsl based templates are annoying after jsx though, but angular's very nice mostly batteries included approach offsets this mostly. I also feel it's much harder to get hot reloading working as there is no virtual dom in angular. It can be done, it's just more complicated.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#70

Post by harrygeez »

wiradikusuma wrote: post #9

I recently used both Angular 2 and React (the latter more recent) in some small projects. While I enjoyed working with React, I think Angular is more suited for me, a one-man startup. A lot of decisions are already made and I just follow them. In React, every time I need something not built-in (which is very often), I have to do some research, and even after deciding one, I have this "what if I'm wrong" guilt at the…

I prefer having them decoupled because I can swap things out easily if I don't like them. Never touch Angular though but I imagine it should be possible to use other than the built in ones
Post reply on HN