Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 99 posts

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#71

I just tried to signup with a Hotmail email address and I got this error message: This email cannot be used to create an account. It might be due to your email domain name. I realize Hotmail isn't the sexiest email provider these days but it's one of the more commonly used. Do you have a list of email domains you allow?

We accept hotmail. It might be because of some special characters. Do you use + ?

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#72
post #70
post #68

When I try test my digital voice, after clicking "Generate," I get this error after about 10 seconds: Something went wrong. Please try again! I've tried about 5 times. EDIT: I went to back to the page a few minutes later, and the recordings were all there. So it looks like it works, but is giving a false error message.

Can you refresh and try again? Let me know if it works.

It's working now. Thanks. Very cool.

Small issue: Would be nice if you could delete recordings.

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#74
post #73
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's working now. Thanks. Very cool. Small issue: Would be nice if you could delete recordings.

You can!

Sorry, I meant the test recordings, not the originals of my voice.

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#75
post #71

I just tried to signup with a Hotmail email address and I got this error message: This email cannot be used to create an account. It might be due to your email domain name. I realize Hotmail isn't the sexiest email provider these days but it's one of the more commonly used. Do you have a list of email domains you allow?

We accept hotmail. It might be because of some special characters. Do you use + ?

Nope. Just letters and numbers. Same with my password.

I tried with my Gmail address and it worked fine. That address has no numbers in it. I used the same password. If you aren't prohibiting Hotmail addresses then it must be the numbers in the email address that are triggering some validation.

Regardless, I have access now. Looking forward to trying your product!

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#76
post #71

I just tried to signup with a Hotmail email address and I got this error message: This email cannot be used to create an account. It might be due to your email domain name. I realize Hotmail isn't the sexiest email provider these days but it's one of the more commonly used. Do you have a list of email domains you allow?

We accept hotmail. It might be because of some special characters. Do you use + ?

Even if they did use '+', that should still definitely be allowed. I immediately get turned off when a service actively disallows a '+' because then I start to wonder why they don't want me to be able to filter their messages in my inbox.

It's the only sane and easy (but obviously not bullet-proof) way of catching spammers out.

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#77
post #5

Sounds amazing! Just to add a usecase - for many people, creating a decent voiceover is one of the big sticking points for producing youtube videos or educational courses. If I could write a script, and have software generate a decent enough voiceover, it would be amazing. It's not even necessary to copy anyone's voice, as long as there's a selection of the most comprehensible and human-sounding ones. Then, you could…

I made a joke video for work, featuring clips of Sir David Attenborough narrating a fake nature documentary I cut together from video I took at work. It would have been an order of magnitude better if I could just generate arbitrary phrases in his voice. (Or maybe not; maybe the constraint made the video better.)

I think the constraint makes the video funnier, take for example dinoflask's edits of Blizzard's Jeff Kaplan

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXTrrTX7YuY

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#78

While it's good that you have an ethics page: https://lyrebird.ai/ethics/ , it only has two ethical guidelines: * Spread awareness of this technology * Your digital voice remains yours I would feel a lot better about this if you also had explicit ethical boundaries, for example disallowing users impersonating someone else, e.g. Donald Trump, Barack Obama. "Your digital voice remains yours" sort of sounds like you won…

To build on that a bit. My bank uses voice recognition as a security measure and to authenticate me when I call in. Throw a bad actor in the mix and that becomes a security issue.

Reminds me of the classic "My voice is my passport. Verify me." Hopefully that is not the only second-factor option they provide?

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#79
Their ethics don't seem to be something they take seriously as the video they use to promote their own site is an impersonation itself.

Seems from right out of the gate, they are breaking their own ethical guidelines as a cheap promotional tactic. If they care that little about themselves and a former president of the United States, what do they care about your likeness.

It also doesn't help that you give them a universal perpetual license to do whatever they want (including selling your likeness for someone else's use) by uploading.

This just seems like a slimy team that put up an ethics page as a CYA.

I'm willing to eat my words if they had Barak Obama's consent to use his digitized voice for this but, it's highly doubtful since there's also the coat and seal of the President of the United States on the flag in the background which would be a massive ethical breach of a former President just to promote a silly little startup.

Re: Launch HN: Lyrebird (YC S17) – Create a digital copy of your voice

#80
post #5

Sounds amazing! Just to add a usecase - for many people, creating a decent voiceover is one of the big sticking points for producing youtube videos or educational courses. If I could write a script, and have software generate a decent enough voiceover, it would be amazing. It's not even necessary to copy anyone's voice, as long as there's a selection of the most comprehensible and human-sounding ones. Then, you could…

Sounds like the 100 speakers they used were Irish or Scottish.
Post reply on HN