Live data from Hacker News

Riak and the demise of Basho

lists.basho.com

21–30 of 102 posts

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#22
I haven't been following this, but from what I can gather:

- They raised $60mil (the last round being a Series G for $25mil!)

- They're being sold for what I can only this is a pittance / acquihire by Bet365

- Bet365 is buying them because they're heavily invested in Riak internally

- They're open sourcing the code (likely because they need help)

I'm not trying to disparage anyone here, but this makes my blood run cold.

Is Riak so critical to Bet365 that the right move was to _buy the company_ versus switching to a different storage system?

Is there a NoSQL vendor that's doing well out there?

Should we all just be using Postgres anyway?

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#23
post #18

Today bet365 have signed the agreement to purchase all Basho IP. We expect the agreement to be ratified in the US courts next week. Once cleared, our intention is to open source all code, help rebuild the community and collaboratively take the development of RIAK forward. In the coming weeks we will hopefully answer the questions people have and will be calling on the community to help forge the initial RIAK Roadmap.…

Like BSD or MIT licenses? That would be great.

Apache 2 is probably the best choice here to avoid potential future issues related to patents.

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#24

I haven't been following this, but from what I can gather: - They raised $60mil (the last round being a Series G for $25mil!) - They're being sold for what I can only this is a pittance / acquihire by Bet365 - Bet365 is buying them because they're heavily invested in Riak internally - They're open sourcing the code (likely because they need help) I'm not trying to disparage anyone here, but this makes my blood run co…

This is not an acquihire. A lot of developers were already let go quite some time ago from Basho.

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#25
post #6

I think Riak properly materialized the NoSQL promise of fully scale-out architectures. Have not seen an open source product that delivers on this (no Mongo does not cut it for me). Sad to see they did not manage to make a business out of it... The bet takers may be a good patron to the project, but ideally it is governed by an independent shop that focuses on further development and marketing.

RethinkDB was good from a distributed systems perspective, but a nightmare to maintain in production. Backups and restores would take 12+ hours on ten gigabytes or so and slow queries would grind the whole system to a halt, which isn't possible in Erlang based systems like Riak due to the preemptive scheduling of the BEAM.

Are those times for real? You could snapshot the underlying disks and copy them byte for byte orders of magnitude faster than that.

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#26
post #6

I think Riak properly materialized the NoSQL promise of fully scale-out architectures. Have not seen an open source product that delivers on this (no Mongo does not cut it for me). Sad to see they did not manage to make a business out of it... The bet takers may be a good patron to the project, but ideally it is governed by an independent shop that focuses on further development and marketing.

RethinkDB was good from a distributed systems perspective, but a nightmare to maintain in production. Backups and restores would take 12+ hours on ten gigabytes or so and slow queries would grind the whole system to a halt, which isn't possible in Erlang based systems like Riak due to the preemptive scheduling of the BEAM.

Riak builds on theoretical foundation, laid out in Amazon's Dynamo paper. The other NoSQLs did not have this theoretical underpinning, and so they just offer a "best effort".

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#27

I haven't been following this, but from what I can gather: - They raised $60mil (the last round being a Series G for $25mil!) - They're being sold for what I can only this is a pittance / acquihire by Bet365 - Bet365 is buying them because they're heavily invested in Riak internally - They're open sourcing the code (likely because they need help) I'm not trying to disparage anyone here, but this makes my blood run co…

How much does it cost to move to Postgres? How much does it cost to buy the assets?

How much of a halo do you get from writing a nice post about moving to Postgres? How much of a halo do you get from buying and open sourcing something cool?

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#28
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

RethinkDB was good from a distributed systems perspective, but a nightmare to maintain in production. Backups and restores would take 12+ hours on ten gigabytes or so and slow queries would grind the whole system to a halt, which isn't possible in Erlang based systems like Riak due to the preemptive scheduling of the BEAM.

Are those times for real? You could snapshot the underlying disks and copy them byte for byte orders of magnitude faster than that.

The problem was replication across the cluster and getting them to coordinate their values. We eventually did what you suggested in our dev environments so that we didn't lose our sanity. .

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#29
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

RethinkDB was good from a distributed systems perspective, but a nightmare to maintain in production. Backups and restores would take 12+ hours on ten gigabytes or so and slow queries would grind the whole system to a halt, which isn't possible in Erlang based systems like Riak due to the preemptive scheduling of the BEAM.

Riak builds on theoretical foundation, laid out in Amazon's Dynamo paper. The other NoSQLs did not have this theoretical underpinning, and so they just offer a "best effort".

Sure, but that said, no other DB Jepsen tested til that point necessitated the kind of gymnastics he had to do to get it to fail. It's pretty solid CS, and it's a shame the project had the end of life that it did.

[0] https://aphyr.com/posts/330-jepsen-rethinkdb-2-2-3-reconfigu...

Re: Riak and the demise of Basho

#30

I haven't been following this, but from what I can gather: - They raised $60mil (the last round being a Series G for $25mil!) - They're being sold for what I can only this is a pittance / acquihire by Bet365 - Bet365 is buying them because they're heavily invested in Riak internally - They're open sourcing the code (likely because they need help) I'm not trying to disparage anyone here, but this makes my blood run co…

This is not an acquihire. A lot of developers were already let go quite some time ago from Basho.

Then what was it? Genuinely curious what happened here...
Post reply on HN