Live data from Hacker News

Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

techcrunch.com

261–268 of 268 posts

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#261
post #222

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "Thousands of years? Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's really only been put into a constitution a smigeon more than 200 years ago." 'Origins of freedom of speech and expression' section found here suggests otherwise (unless you want to be particular about the term 'constitution', rather than what it represents): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech

399BC - Socrates speaks to jury at his trial: 'If you offered to let me off this time on condition I am not any longer to speak my mind... I should say to you, "Men of Athens, I shall obey the Gods rather than you."' Socrates was sentenced to death for "corrupting the youth" - an act of speech. Considered by some to be a final nail for ancient athens - who had adored free speech before so much as to name a warship af…

that's my point! freedom of speech has been a still birth from the start.

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#262
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, are you critiquing Snopes based on the personal lives of the people who run it, based on an article about them in a tabloid? Are you trolling?

If you were applying for a security clearance and the government discovered you had massive amounts of debt and lots of questionable history that's ripe for blackmail, you would likely be denied. That's because those things could be used as leverage against you to make you act immorally. So yes, I'm quite interested in the personal lives of the people running a company about to be ordained as "the objective truth" by…

The thing is, fact checkers like Snopes and Politifact don't just give an opaque true or false proclamation, they explain how they arrived at that conclusion, which I think is the key bit. You're free to check the evidence for yourself and decide if their reasoning holds up. The people behind it aren't asking you to take their word on reputation alone.

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#263
post #251

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People don't like this. Please respond and tell me why. Can you defend Trump? As near as I can tell he doesn't have any actual stances. He contradicts himself constantly. He acts like a child instead either a politician or a statesman. He turns down expert briefings. He appears to be embezzling money by having his security stay at his properties. He takes far too much vacation. He has a curiously large amoutn of ties…

I think many people are having to face what their "side" has become, in a bit more clarity than they are comfortable with. The Republicans traditionally kept the fascism and racism hidden to some degree, but Trump simply isn't capable of that. So they retreat into philosophical arguments about how you can't deny Nazi's free speech, because that's unamerican and a slippery slope. While Republicans continue their decad…

I think you are correct in several things, perhaps all things.

I am cool with nazis voting and I even think nazis should have freedom of speech. What is not OK is calls to violence and any other form of speech that directly hurts people (doxing, revenge porn, etc...). This is already illegal in this country and is in no way a slippery slope. We just need to enforce existing rules and laws.

You demand that we "kill all XXX" go to jail, end of story. That is not censorship, that is how you build a society.

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#264
post #220
post #170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That was less than 100 years ago, after the invention of radio and newsreels; I'm not shire how it proves the point of unfettered free speech either. I'd love to see examples of unfettered free speech from the 1600s or much MUCH easier.

Ancient Athenians adored freedom of speech. Naming a warship after the very concept. 399BC - Socrates speaks to jury at his trial: 'If you offered to let me off this time on condition I am not any longer to speak my mind... I should say to you, "Men of Athens, I shall obey the Gods rather than you."' 1516 - The Education of a Christian Prince by Erasmus. 'In a free state, tongues too should be free.' In the 1600s, Ga…

Galileo was executed?

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#265
post #215
post #54

So how does Facebook really know if something is fake? You can't trust user reports. They will say a story is fake when they don't like it. You can't trust some worker in Bangladesh to determine this either just as easily as you can determine if something is NSFW. You still can't trust AI. So how? It hires specialists in each field to determine what is real and what is not?

"The company has already been working with outside fact-checkers like Snopes and the AP to flag inaccurate news stories. (These aren’t supposed to be stories that are disputed for reasons of opinion or partisanship, but rather outright hoaxes and lies.) It also says that when a story is marked as disputed, the link can can no longer be promoted through Facebook ads." If Snopes/AP tells me something is false, I'm perf…

Honestly, the fact that you think snopes is unbiased is pretty shocking to me, and gives me little hope that Facebook would ever be able to properly determine what is "fake news".

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#266
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like there is an untapped market segment. By the next US election, someone will have figured out what kind of content gets Democrats riled up, and makes a ton selling headlines to the highest bidder.

Er, that's easy. It's done already by large corporate news sources. Just go browse The Guardian or The Independent (both UK outlets) to find a constant series of clickbait stories designed to maximally upset people with Clinton-style views. Random Macedonians can't make money doing it because those advertising dollars are already sucked up by much larger and better known brands. There may also be a structural issue (…

Having swung right in recent years, I'm now dealing with this very problem. It takes a ton of effort to get the full picture on a given story. The more controversial it is, the more google's search results will be dominated by rags like Vox, Slate, and HuffPo.

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#267
post #252

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're correct. People cannot spot BS and learn from it, including you and I. We'll put much effort into mastering a certain area of reality and truth, and find other horizons clouding over by the day: we cannot, as humans, reality-check everything we're confronted with, because it's too much. We're not shepherds or subsistence farmers anymore, with a world tightly constrained and comprehensible. Our world expanded,…

We live in a single objective reality. There are ways to get at the truth. Some of those ways are even easy. Can the claims be tested, sometimes this can shortcut you strait to the truth. Knowing how to check sources gets you one step closer. Knowing how to assess the quality of sources, helps. Knowing how to understand the original source material is crucial. Checking that a multitude of sources agree. Determining i…

What makes you so certain we live in a world of objective reality?

Re: Facebook says Pages that regularly share false news won’t be able to buy ads

#268
post #220

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ancient Athenians adored freedom of speech. Naming a warship after the very concept. 399BC - Socrates speaks to jury at his trial: 'If you offered to let me off this time on condition I am not any longer to speak my mind... I should say to you, "Men of Athens, I shall obey the Gods rather than you."' 1516 - The Education of a Christian Prince by Erasmus. 'In a free state, tongues too should be free.' In the 1600s, Ga…

Galileo was executed ?

Oops, sorry. Hoouse arrest for life and all texts burned. Here are a few executions & persecutions for speech: https://www.wired.com/2012/06/famous-persecuted-scientists/
Post reply on HN