Live data from Hacker News

Collection of letters by Alan Turing found in filing cabinet

theguardian.com

1–10 of 29 posts

Re: Collection of letters by Alan Turing found in filing cabinet

#4
It's rather sad that the only thing a trained journalist can find in 150 letters written by a hero of the first order is “I would not like the journey, and I detest America.” - a remark made once by him.

I'd like these letters to be analysed by people who could make some real sense of them and put them into a decent context. Finding a throwaway remark that many have made on the spur of the moment and headlining it is a bit crass.

Re: Collection of letters by Alan Turing found in filing cabinet

#5
post #4

It's rather sad that the only thing a trained journalist can find in 150 letters written by a hero of the first order is “I would not like the journey, and I detest America.” - a remark made once by him. I'd like these letters to be analysed by people who could make some real sense of them and put them into a decent context. Finding a throwaway remark that many have made on the spur of the moment and headlining it is…

As someone who thinks America gets wide wide berth for all the pain and suffering it inflicts upon the world, I'm kinda happy to find important historical figures were fellow travelers.

Re: Collection of letters by Alan Turing found in filing cabinet

#6
post #4

It's rather sad that the only thing a trained journalist can find in 150 letters written by a hero of the first order is “I would not like the journey, and I detest America.” - a remark made once by him. I'd like these letters to be analysed by people who could make some real sense of them and put them into a decent context. Finding a throwaway remark that many have made on the spur of the moment and headlining it is…

You can analyze them if you want: https://archiveshub.jisc.ac.uk/search/archives/4f6c3f0c-9a70...

This article is written for a general audience, and there's probably not much else of general interest in them if they're mostly about academics.

Re: Collection of letters by Alan Turing found in filing cabinet

#8
post #6
post #4

It's rather sad that the only thing a trained journalist can find in 150 letters written by a hero of the first order is “I would not like the journey, and I detest America.” - a remark made once by him. I'd like these letters to be analysed by people who could make some real sense of them and put them into a decent context. Finding a throwaway remark that many have made on the spur of the moment and headlining it is…

You can analyze them if you want: https://archiveshub.jisc.ac.uk/search/archives/4f6c3f0c-9a70... This article is written for a general audience, and there's probably not much else of general interest in them if they're mostly about academics.

this is goddam wonderful, so much better than reading the usual praises around Turing; you get to see who he was talking to and the subject. Makes his passing even more sad.

Re: Collection of letters by Alan Turing found in filing cabinet

#9
post #2

> I despise America Sadly it was his own State that killed him in the end.

"detest", not "despise". Small thing I know but accuracy is important.

Fortunately those two words are synonyms, so readers have not been terribly misled.

Re: Collection of letters by Alan Turing found in filing cabinet

#10
post #2

> I despise America Sadly it was his own State that killed him in the end.

Why is this downvoted? It's true.

The site guidelines ask

> Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

I don't have any insight as to why this particular comment was down voted. (Edit to add: I suspect it was down voted because it misquotes the source material.) If it's something you're really interested in looking into more in general, I suggest searching HN for other discussions on votes and taking some more time to think about what might cause someone to down vote, whether you agree with the possible reason or not.

As an aside, just because a comment is true doesn't mean it's somehow immune to down votes. Comments in general should be civil and constructive.

Post reply on HN