Live data from Hacker News

GIMP 2.9.6 Released

gimp.org

21–30 of 87 posts

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#21
post #4

I curious as to who is using GIMP for serious work. I have tried it numerous time in the past but always end up going back to PS. As of late I been making a switch to Affinity Photo but have always been pulling for GIMP.

This is the first I've heard of Affinity Photo. The feature list looks very complete, for what I use on a regular basis. Are you a long-time Photoshop user? How does it compare?

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#22
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have always advocated for Gimp but people esp designers want to stick to photoshop. Hope they understand the power of this open source

Can GIMP load psd files correctly? I seem to remember that there was some trouble loading psd files, but I don't remember exactly what. Edit to add: I ask because if GIMP cannot handle the de facto standard image file type without too much fiddling, people won't touch it. It is the same problem LibreOffice has, actually.

The notes OP linked to indicate that there are more fixes included in this version. It is likely what importing a .doc in open office was 10 years ago. It proably works 99% of the time but that 1% will be right before an important deadline or something.

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#23
post #4

I curious as to who is using GIMP for serious work. I have tried it numerous time in the past but always end up going back to PS. As of late I been making a switch to Affinity Photo but have always been pulling for GIMP.

I have used GIMP and only GIMP for all my raster work for the last 12 years. Including photos for several cases of book publication. Nothing all that fancy. Cleaning, color corrections, repair, etc. I have yet to encounter a job it isn't up to.

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#24
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have always advocated for Gimp but people esp designers want to stick to photoshop. Hope they understand the power of this open source

Can GIMP load psd files correctly? I seem to remember that there was some trouble loading psd files, but I don't remember exactly what. Edit to add: I ask because if GIMP cannot handle the de facto standard image file type without too much fiddling, people won't touch it. It is the same problem LibreOffice has, actually.

You can't expect a non-proprietary tool to handle a proprietary file format 100% correctly. People who have no need for file formats that only work with Adobe software can use GIMP just fine.

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#25
Occasionally using it on a Mac. Most of the time I force quit it, though, because it loads fonts forever. It's not a "quickly open and edit a file" tool for me.

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#26

I've been very impressed with Gimp lately - there was a time that it was clunky and crashy, Windows builds were difficult to find, and usually out of date, and I often felt like I was only persevering with it on principle. In recent years though, it's been wholly solid. Was there a change in project leadership, or something - maybe just a new development workflow? I've known plenty of seemingly-moribund projects spri…

I've been using Gimp for ages (15 to 20 years) and it was always solid for me. Maybe I was just using the more stable features? But I've mostly used it on Linux. My major gripe was the Save / Export fiasco [0] but even that is OK now thanks to Saver plugin [1].

[0] http://www.gimpusers.com/forums/gimp-user/14339-hate-the-new...

[1] http://shallowsky.com/blog/gimp/saver.html

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#27
post #6

As a casual user on a Mac, I've long since abandoned GIMP for Pixelmator + Imagemagick. Has GIMP improved in usability in the past few years?

Pixelmator is great, but it misses extremely useful feature: move canvas view ouside the border.

Feature request filled back in 2012 and still not implemented: http://support.pixelmator.com/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=8336

Without it working in areas near the edges is very stressful and painful.

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#28
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can GIMP load psd files correctly? I seem to remember that there was some trouble loading psd files, but I don't remember exactly what. Edit to add: I ask because if GIMP cannot handle the de facto standard image file type without too much fiddling, people won't touch it. It is the same problem LibreOffice has, actually.

The notes OP linked to indicate that there are more fixes included in this version. It is likely what importing a .doc in open office was 10 years ago. It proably works 99% of the time but that 1% will be right before an important deadline or something.

>It proably works 99% of the time but that 1% will be right before an important deadline or something.

Are you a terrorist

i loved to make this joke and it hurts me that you're downvoting me friends

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#29
post #25

Occasionally using it on a Mac. Most of the time I force quit it, though, because it loads fonts forever. It's not a "quickly open and edit a file" tool for me.

Not sure where this is stored on Mac, but on Windows, clear the fontconfig directory in the AppData folder.

Re: GIMP 2.9.6 Released

#30
post #25

Occasionally using it on a Mac. Most of the time I force quit it, though, because it loads fonts forever. It's not a "quickly open and edit a file" tool for me.

Starting it from the command line seems to fix that for a while, at least it does here.
Post reply on HN