Live data from Hacker News

Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

ipadtest.wordpress.com

41–50 of 132 posts

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#41
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a competitor even if it addresses a subset of the iPad functionality. This one has e-book reading, something many people buy the iPad for. Different people weight different features differently (sory - had to do it) and this thingie may end up with a better value than an iPad for a lot of people. Me included, BTW. I could buy one of these and a Nook for less than what an iPad costs. For me, it's a winner. It's a…

Yes, it is a competitor, but is it a "real competitor"? Real is the operative word. When you suggest that this product is a "real competitor", I expect it to have real potential to sell more than a million devices. The reason why I am dismissive of this device is that the headline of the OTA is a little bit linkbaitish considering that the device is made by a little known Asian manufacturer who is going to spend next…

> I expect it to have real potential to sell more than a million devices

Is the iPad a real competitor to netbooks? This specific product is not a huge risk for Apple - it's easily clonable by other manufacturers and, by itself, it will never have a huge market share. The combined power of just about every Chinese manufacturer is a very real threat to Apple.

Steve must remember the Apple II.

Hardware makers for this class of devices will not - and need not to - spend a ton of money on marketing. They will have this thingie sitting on aisles of major supermarkets.

And that's a killer move in the lower-end. Nobody will remember their brand next week. But, in the meantime, they will sell lots of units.

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your points may not matter so much for the hobbyist/tinkerer. The $200 price point is workable for that crowd.

Your post sort of proves the point. Hobbyists/tinkerers probably wouldn't consider an iPad because of who they are. That puts this device in a different market segment. Despite the fact that this device has similar features and form factor to the iPad, this device and the iPad aren't really competing for the same customers .

Actually, that is the point I'm trying to make!

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#43
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're looking for a tablet you probably already know which one you're going to buy before you set foot in a physical store.

What if you are not looking for a tablet? Few people were looking for a tablet before the iPad launch.

True, but that's irrelevant.

My point is that few people buy electronics on impulse, without research, before walking into a store.

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#45

2) It’s not a very bright screen, like the iPad. But if you intend to do a lot of reading, this is a plus. No, it's not. On the iPad you can adjust the brightness of the screen directly in the iBooks app if you want. But when you want a brighter screen for anything else, you can have it.

[deleted]

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#46

2) It’s not a very bright screen, like the iPad. But if you intend to do a lot of reading, this is a plus. No, it's not. On the iPad you can adjust the brightness of the screen directly in the iBooks app if you want. But when you want a brighter screen for anything else, you can have it.

yes it is. most users will end up not adjusting brightness thus hurting their eyes

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#47
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love it when the faithful think that features and price are not competitive.

They're really not. My dad knows what an iPad is. Unless this device lays golden eggs he'll probably never hear of it. Also, there are unmentioned features in the iPad's favor, most notably an App Store with 200k titles in it.

App Store with 200k titles is a plus? Are you serious? How will your dad be able to find anything useful there?

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#48
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a competitor even if it addresses a subset of the iPad functionality. This one has e-book reading, something many people buy the iPad for. Different people weight different features differently (sory - had to do it) and this thingie may end up with a better value than an iPad for a lot of people. Me included, BTW. I could buy one of these and a Nook for less than what an iPad costs. For me, it's a winner. It's a…

Do you really think people buy the iPad for reading ebooks? I find it to be not significantly better than reading on a monitor. The iPad is great for some things for sure (Plants vs Zombies being first and foremost in my experience) but I think if I wanted to read books I'd get a Kindle or some eink device.

> I find it to be not significantly better than reading on a monitor.

Nielsen's tests very emphatically disagree

http://www.useit.com/alertbox/ipad-kindle-reading.html

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you really think people buy the iPad for reading ebooks? I find it to be not significantly better than reading on a monitor. The iPad is great for some things for sure (Plants vs Zombies being first and foremost in my experience) but I think if I wanted to read books I'd get a Kindle or some eink device.

> I find it to be not significantly better than reading on a monitor. Nielsen's tests very emphatically disagree http://www.useit.com/alertbox/ipad-kindle-reading.html

Neilsen tested only speed. It's eyestrain that bothers me and is why ebook readers typically use e-ink.

Re: Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor

#50
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a competitor even if it addresses a subset of the iPad functionality. This one has e-book reading, something many people buy the iPad for. Different people weight different features differently (sory - had to do it) and this thingie may end up with a better value than an iPad for a lot of people. Me included, BTW. I could buy one of these and a Nook for less than what an iPad costs. For me, it's a winner. It's a…

Do you really think people buy the iPad for reading ebooks? I find it to be not significantly better than reading on a monitor. The iPad is great for some things for sure (Plants vs Zombies being first and foremost in my experience) but I think if I wanted to read books I'd get a Kindle or some eink device.

Yes, I've bought an iPad for reading books. And I'm using it all the time as an e-book reader.
Post reply on HN