Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Best Place to run a UI Design contest ?

news.ycombinator.com

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: Ask HN: Best Place to run a UI Design contest ?

#21
post #15
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the problem is not with designers (or developers, or producers, sound engineers, etc.) it's that the companies that run the "contests" don't have a real budget, don't understand the work that goes into creating the work and want the "best bang for the buck" by just saying "give me something". Also, because design work is such a creative/customer specific product, most design "contests" are work that can't rea…

>the companies that run the "contests" don't have a real budget, don't understand the work that goes into creating the work and want the "best bang for the buck" by just saying "give me something" I hate this market, and as a designer I choose not to work with it. But it's there, and it should be served. Designers need to stop acting like 99designs takes food out of their mouths. It's just a different market. If you…

Absolutely, I look at it as creating a new segment of the market, much like crowdsourcing did for stock photography.

99designs main customers are small businesses that wouldn't otherwise have been able to justify what they view as a risky spend on design.

Re: Ask HN: Best Place to run a UI Design contest ?

#22
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do designers typically feel about crowdspring.com as opposed to what 99designs is doing? They both seem to have similar models.

There are some similarities, but frankly, more differences. crowdSPRING projects are, on average, much higher in value. There are typically many more $1000+ projects, for example, and often, $5000+ projects on crowdSPRING. crowdSPRING offers graphic and web design projects (99designs does too). But crowdSPRING also offers industrial design (products and product packaging) and copywriting projects. More info about dif…

Although there are far fewer contests overall.

Our top designers tell us they tend to avoid the higher prize contests in favour of the mid-ranged ones where there is less competition and simpler requirements.

Post reply on HN