Live data from Hacker News

Video is Coming to Reddit

redditblog.com

71–80 of 119 posts

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#71
post #11

A couple months ago I found that Reddit submissions using Reddit's native image hosting, a year after its implementation, surpassed those of its main competitor, Imgur (HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14595212 ) I'm not entirely sure the same will happen with video. Not only are the videos typically posted on Reddit's largest video subreddits are from the YouTube community (and intended for the Yo…

Image hosting is easy, if you don't care about losing money. As long as you provide direct links to images, you're better than everybody else. Video hosting? You need a good player (nothing will ever top YouTube's) and a good CDN. That's a tough nut to crack. Especially for a company with no money.

> Especially for a company with no money.

Reddit doesn't exactly have "no money": https://techcrunch.com/2017/07/31/reddit-just-raised-a-new-r...

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#72

I still prefer clicking on an embedded imgur link rather than their own reddit image hosting version.

Especially on mobile. Every imgur image displays properly on my phone. Every time I click on an i.reddit image, it's 1000px wide so to see the entire thing I have to scroll vertically and horizontally.

I've just stopped clicking on any image links from i.reddit.

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#73
post #41
post #36

> If you’ve spent any time on r/HighQualityGifs, r/mealtimevideos, or just about any other Reddit community, you know that videos and gifs represent a major proportion of the content shared on our site. But prior to this launch, content creators had to go through a time-consuming, circuitous process to post videos, using third-party hosting platforms, copying URLs, and sharing them as link posts. This inhibited many…

I think it's pretty simple and I always wondered why they didn't do it sooner. Reddit is already one of the most popular sites on the Internet - but since it was just an aggregator it constantly took users off their site. Now they're owning more and more of the content and keeping users there longer. Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't h…

> I think it's pretty simple and I always wondered why they didn't do it sooner. Reddit is already one of the most popular sites on the Internet - but since it was just an aggregator it constantly took users off their site. Now they're owning more and more of the content and keeping users there longer. Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't host.

They are going to start getting hit with more and more DMCAs, etc. The compliance cost for video and/or audio goes up alot in my experience. Also more likely to be sued (a la Youtube).

For the most part, still pictures, its rare to get any kind of DMCA notice and you basically never get sued.

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Looks like i'll have to remove reddit from whitelisted sites on my ad-blocker. Sigh.

Why? They're hosting content you want to see? Can't you just watch their ads?

Some of us just genuinely hate autoplay ads.

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I don't get what they're plan is. "This launch is a giant step forward in our efforts to bring rich content to Reddit, following last year’s release of native image hosting and our introduction of native video ads earlier this year." Which means having to watch a 30 second ad before a 15second video clip.

"Which means having to watch a 30 second ad before a 15second video clip." Hopefully you'll be able to just use youtube-dl or a similar app to download the video and skip the ads, just as you can for videos that are on youtube.

Even simpler, Ad Block Plus or UBlock Origin block adverts on YouTube. I'm not sure which it is because I've got both, but I definitely notice the annoying difference when I watch YouTube on another browser!

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#76
post #41
post #36

> If you’ve spent any time on r/HighQualityGifs, r/mealtimevideos, or just about any other Reddit community, you know that videos and gifs represent a major proportion of the content shared on our site. But prior to this launch, content creators had to go through a time-consuming, circuitous process to post videos, using third-party hosting platforms, copying URLs, and sharing them as link posts. This inhibited many…

I think it's pretty simple and I always wondered why they didn't do it sooner. Reddit is already one of the most popular sites on the Internet - but since it was just an aggregator it constantly took users off their site. Now they're owning more and more of the content and keeping users there longer. Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't h…

I don't think people leave their site for videos, usually I just open in new window and return to reddit when i'm done

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#77
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Which means having to watch a 30 second ad before a 15second video clip." Hopefully you'll be able to just use youtube-dl or a similar app to download the video and skip the ads, just as you can for videos that are on youtube.

Even simpler, Ad Block Plus or UBlock Origin block adverts on YouTube. I'm not sure which it is because I've got both, but I definitely notice the annoying difference when I watch YouTube on another browser!

uBlock Origin definitely does. I thought there might have been a downside to using multiple adblockers...is that not the case?

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#78
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it's pretty simple and I always wondered why they didn't do it sooner. Reddit is already one of the most popular sites on the Internet - but since it was just an aggregator it constantly took users off their site. Now they're owning more and more of the content and keeping users there longer. Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't h…

I don't think people leave their site for videos, usually I just open in new window and return to reddit when i'm done

If, as you wrote, you "return to reddit" when you are done, doesn't that kind of imply that you left reddit to watch the video?

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#79
post #41
post #36

> If you’ve spent any time on r/HighQualityGifs, r/mealtimevideos, or just about any other Reddit community, you know that videos and gifs represent a major proportion of the content shared on our site. But prior to this launch, content creators had to go through a time-consuming, circuitous process to post videos, using third-party hosting platforms, copying URLs, and sharing them as link posts. This inhibited many…

I think it's pretty simple and I always wondered why they didn't do it sooner. Reddit is already one of the most popular sites on the Internet - but since it was just an aggregator it constantly took users off their site. Now they're owning more and more of the content and keeping users there longer. Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't h…

> Sure, video is expensive

Relatively. CDN costs have plummeted over the years. It now costs $5/TB to serve videos, and under $3/TB if you're in petabyte ranges (BunnyCDN, BelugaCDN).

Re: Video is Coming to Reddit

#80
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it's pretty simple and I always wondered why they didn't do it sooner. Reddit is already one of the most popular sites on the Internet - but since it was just an aggregator it constantly took users off their site. Now they're owning more and more of the content and keeping users there longer. Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't h…

> Sure, video is expensive, but now they have a much bigger revenue opportunity. They can't monetize videos they don't host. I totally see your point but shouldn't they monetize what they have now before go on to tackle other revenue venture? Or is it better to tackle all possible revenue venture at the same time? I feel like it's stretches them thin no?

Users might feel like adding a monetizing strategy to existing "free" is Reddit selling out. Whereas if you just add a "new" feature and monetize that, people are less likely to rebel
Post reply on HN