Live data from Hacker News

72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

exstreamist.com

71–80 of 138 posts

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#71
post #55

100% of the remaining people don't know what net neutrality is. Pick two of them at random and their definitions will not line up. It's just a blank slate for people to project their political biases on.

Zero collisions for a birthday problem? I don't think people waste that much space on wrong definitions of net neutrality.

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#72
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This won't help you if your ISP decides to penalize all VPN traffic or all traffic that doesn't pay protection money. Also, you're throwing normal people under the bus; the point of net neutrality is to fix the Internet for everyone, not just geeks.

Secure your own face-mask before securing the face-mask of those sitting around you. A couple situations where it will help you: The justice department issues a subpoena for your IP address because you visited a website about a protest, your ISP wants to sell your internet history to the highest bidder. I am fully cognizant that we need to be working on NN at a collective level but individual protection is incredibly…

[deleted]

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#74
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't think of a hot name, but net neutrality is fundamentally about preserving a free market of information.

You have to be careful about that, because there's nothing in net neutrality that prevents restricted data silos, censorship, takedowns; it's really only about forbidding a specific network management practice that allows ISPs to impose a time cost on sites and services they disapprove of.

While accurate, it's a little misleading to phrase it like this.

Imposing a significant time cost makes certain types of applications unusable.

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or it's just more Government regulation that is trying to control the internet and prevent free market competition.

I think the counter one liner to that is something like: Net Neutrality keeps big companies from controlling what you can access on the internet. But not totally comfortable with that because "access" is overstating.

I would also counter with: The ISPs are where they are because they in the opposite of a free market.

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#76

My hypothesis is it has to do with the name chosen for it. If it had a more 'consumer-friendly' name it would be more widely known. Something like 'Internet Freedom' or 'Free Internet' would have more appeal...

That's actually probably a worse name. There are a lot of people who think it has to do with regulating online content (in a political viewpoint sense). "Internet Freedom" would only make that worse.

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#77

My hypothesis is it has to do with the name chosen for it. If it had a more 'consumer-friendly' name it would be more widely known. Something like 'Internet Freedom' or 'Free Internet' would have more appeal...

Well, since the Bill was named "Restoring Internet Freedom" (and in a time where it feels like every third bill is named something with "freedom") I doubt that would have made things more transparent to the average consumer.

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#78
If you can't define it on a bumper sticker, most Americans won't "know what it is".

As for the FCC, Ajit Pai, and Net Neutrality, I'm much more open-minded to the current FCC policy after having listened to him on the latest Recode/Decode podcast. His speaking patterns make him sound like he's an energetic jerk, but I don't disagree with lots of the policy agenda he mentioned. I detest the games they played with the citizen comment submission system and the "cyberattack" they claimed happened, but that seems only tangentially related.

I'm not sure that the FCC is the right instrument to enact net neutrality -- I feel like demolishing arbitration and allowing consumers to sue the crap out of ISPs for unfair competition actions would go further. The FCC has only been good at restricting speech, not protecting it.

Re: 72% of Consumers Don't Know What Net Neutrality Is

#80

28% know what it is? That's more surprising to me actually.

I wonder what percent think they know what it is, but don't. Looks like the question was simply, "Do you know what net neutrality is?"

Riveting questionnaire, really.
Post reply on HN