Live data from Hacker News

It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

adamharkus.com

31–40 of 239 posts

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#31

I tried picking up a guitar this past week, and was overwhelmed. Just playing a basic chord was a struggle. How do you get your figure to press down just right on the string and not interfere with another. Amazed by people who can play effortlessly. The post encouraged me to try again. 15 min a day sounds like a reasonable practicing goal.

Find someone (or a YouTube video) that can teach you three or four basic chords that sound good together. Nothing too complex, maybe look up C, G, A minor, and E minor. Play them very slowly at first, not worrying about any kind of melody. It won't take very long before you can differentiate between the strings and hold a basic rhythm. Believe me, everyone starts out feeling like you did!

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#32
post #21

I'm 29 and have been playing guitar for at least half my life at this point. It's a great stress reliever and just fun in general. I'm not good by any stretch of the imagination, but that doesn't stop me from enjoying myself. These are some of my personal recommendations for starting out: - Use an acoustic, you don't want to have to carry an amp around with you. - Learn to sing while you play early on. I think it's h…

So I agree, except that I think starting out on an acoustic teaches a lot of bad habits, and can also be frustrating for beginners, because acoustics are simply more difficult to play.

Can you elaborate on the bad habits starting out on an acoustic teaches?

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#33

If I ever win the lottery, I'd love to learn to play the guitar, learn a few foreign languages, contribute to open source software, make a bonsai tree, read all the books I have in my apartment that are collecting dust, [a long list of other stuff I'd like to do]. I don't want a big house or an expensive car or "bling". I just wish I had the money to buy time.

I'm in the same boat as you. Playing guitar was all I did in school. These days my guitar hangs on the wall like an ornament. I think I play it maybe once a year. Just to busy with live and no time.

I'm in the same boat, played since I was 14, absolutely love the instrument, but just don't have the time to practice any more.

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#35
Here's something I wish I'd realized when I first started playing. If you know the right set of chords you can play them in basically any order and they'll sound nice.

If you take scale like C major, there's a chord that goes with every note of the scale. On a piano this would be mean playing three note chords on the white keys only, all the way up. So for the key of C that gives you

C_major D_minor E_minor F_major G_major A_minor B_diminished C_major

Now here is the cool part: you can play those chords in virtually any order and they are going to sound good (although probably better to skip the B diminished chord, and also helps to start or end on C). It also works in the relative minor key, in this case A minor (still just white keys on the piano, essentially):

A_minor B_diminished C_major D_minor E_minor F_major G_major A_minor

Those chords are all easy to play on a guitar. It would also be easy to do this in the key of G major (E minor) on the guitar. They key doesn't actually matter, but those are easy for beginners. You can just number the chords 1 to 7, then pick any sequence of numbers, eg. 145623, or 4545261, and play it, and it will sound good, and you can make up a melody or a finger-picking pattern to go with it. For some sequences you might need to get a bit creative and vary the timing (eg. some chords will work better if you move through them faster than average, some you can linger on for longer than average), but you could make lots of good music from that alone.

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#36

Warning! If you're middle-aged and thinking of picking up the guitar, you should realize that the public image of guitarists has shifted from "sexy gods" to "annoying hobos" sometime in the last two decades. If you are at least partly motivated by popularity (and who isn't), maybe pick another hobby that actually helps people be popular now, not in your imagined past. So in a sense, yes, it is sometimes too late :-(

If you're middle-aged, and still all that "motivated by popularity", then you're not doing middle-age right. A 50-year old playing guitar is 1,000x cooler than a 50-year old mixing EDM tracks on Ableton, because he thinks it'll help him score 20-year old chicks or impress HN. No matter what age you are, "adulthood" is pretty much another word for finally having enough self-confidence to do your own thing. It's pretty…

Agreed. My dad (70) says he's too old to be "young at heart" any more. He says he's going to try "immature at heart" for a bit.

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#37
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So I agree, except that I think starting out on an acoustic teaches a lot of bad habits, and can also be frustrating for beginners, because acoustics are simply more difficult to play.

I think the trick is to start with a good acoustic. One with good action and one that stays in tune. Like a decent acoustic-electric from Ovation or something like that.

I'd recommend starting on acoustic too. It's the quickest and cheapest route to entry.

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#38

I tried picking up a guitar this past week, and was overwhelmed. Just playing a basic chord was a struggle. How do you get your figure to press down just right on the string and not interfere with another. Amazed by people who can play effortlessly. The post encouraged me to try again. 15 min a day sounds like a reasonable practicing goal.

You can play a ton of songs with like 5-6 open chords. Find a song you don't hate that just uses G, C, and D majors, and drill the hell out of it until it's easy to transition between those. Way more fun to practice with a real song. You may pick up A-minor or something on the bridge of that song, which is nice. Pick up open A and E majors and E minor on top of that base and you can play rhythm on like 50+% of all guitar-heavy popular music ever written without going any farther. Then start working on barre and (relatedly) power chords and you'll get that number up to 90%. Wait to do that because barre chords require different hand muscles than open chords, so you'll hit trouble again when you start on them and no sense in tackling all that difficulty at the same time.

Take heart: once you get over the initial how-the-hell-can-my-fingers-even-do-that hump, learning enough guitar that it's pleasant to listen to is quick. You can hit that mark with casual practice inside 3 months, easily. By contrast, I spent years playing Alto Sax and got way (way) better at it than I ever was at guitar, but that was never pleasant to listen to solo—most instruments you've got to be really really good at them before they're tolerable solo, but guitar's about as far the other direction as you can get.

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#39
post #13
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Edit: ignore this, it's false. Proof: https://www.reddit.com/r/Guitar/comments/1cgrdq/ama_this_is_... I don't know how this stuck with me for so long, I've practically known it to be true for as long as I've been playing. Huh. --- Interesting bit of trivia I learned long after I stopped using his resources: Tommy Emmanuel is his father.

I can find no reference to this; it appears he may have three daughters but they all share his surname. Source?

You're right, thanks for catching this. See my edit.

Re: It's Never Too Late to Learn Guitar

#40

If I ever win the lottery, I'd love to learn to play the guitar, learn a few foreign languages, contribute to open source software, make a bonsai tree, read all the books I have in my apartment that are collecting dust, [a long list of other stuff I'd like to do]. I don't want a big house or an expensive car or "bling". I just wish I had the money to buy time.

You don't need to win a lottery to have the time to learn to play guitar (multiple foreign languages - yes you do). It is actually quite difficult to practice more than 15 minutes every day because of sore fingers and frustration. Lottery or no lottery - if you really want to do it you will be able to find 15 minutes in a day.

>because of sore fingers

Maybe in the beginning, but after having developed calluses you can basically practice for an undefinite period of time.

Post reply on HN