Live data from Hacker News

Richard Stallman Explains [video]

youtube.com

11–20 of 207 posts

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#11

I was amazed to see that Stallman doesn't install his OS himself - hasn't for years. He seemed diminished in my eyes after I learnt this.

This is just a practical thing afaik. fsf sysadmins are more knowledgeable about it and they do it for the rest of fsf computers already, so why not let them do it?

What does diminished mean? I mean, like as a person he's not impressive? When I remember I'm reading a comment that's hiding behind a pseudonym, they are also diminished in my eyes.

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What does this have to do with what he is talking about in the linked video? Does it make him a bad guy or ruin his credibility or something?

Occasionally people in the FLOSS community have been known to crack jokes and 'have fun'. Even tho most of the jokes are not very funny and the fun that is had is rather autistic by most peoples standards I see no reason why we should stop. Many of us have been listening to Stallman for close to 20 years and have been part of free software movement for that long. Having a good chuckle at Comrade Stallman expense is r…

I'm aware of that, but this is just bullying the guy, how would you like it if that was a video of you?

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#13
post #5
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His programming and social acheivements in my opinion vastly outclass installing an OS by himself, though I wonder why he doesn't do it; I assume he knows how partitioning etc. works. And to be honest, how often do most people need to reinstall their OS? I would be surprised if he has reinstalled more than 3 times in 5 years.

Probably because the process is at best dull and at worst, a massive PITA; either way it has little to no relevance to his actual work. If I had the chance, I'd avoid any kind of software installation/maintainence as well...

Doesn't it speak rather poorly for free software if installing it is a "massive PITA"?

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Occasionally people in the FLOSS community have been known to crack jokes and 'have fun'. Even tho most of the jokes are not very funny and the fun that is had is rather autistic by most peoples standards I see no reason why we should stop. Many of us have been listening to Stallman for close to 20 years and have been part of free software movement for that long. Having a good chuckle at Comrade Stallman expense is r…

I'm aware of that, but this is just bullying the guy, how would you like it if that was a video of you?

Richard S has a great appreciation of self deprecating humor. Which is why he does silly things.

Being able to criticize each other and crack jokes about each other is essential to open source and it helps to build community. We can criticize and crack jokes at each others expense because we learn to trust each other. That's how you build real community.

When people are two afraid to criticize each other or crack jokes about each other then you really can not have a healthy community where people have a true respect and admiration for one another. And you certainly can not build a community that has to have critique about code quality, architecture and so forth to sustain itself.

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#15
post #13
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Probably because the process is at best dull and at worst, a massive PITA; either way it has little to no relevance to his actual work. If I had the chance, I'd avoid any kind of software installation/maintainence as well...

Doesn't it speak rather poorly for free software if installing it is a "massive PITA"?

Non free software is too. Especially when you start dealing with licensing. Where I work we have people assigned to licensing & other people assigned to actual install. Of course the licensing goes through a third party provider... for which we're a third party provider to our clients

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#17
Hats off to the interviewer, I thought he did a good job of curbing Stallman and keeping him on topic. He does have this fantastic meandering style that would undermine his agenda if his audience has a short attention span. Like so many of us these days.

I first read about RMS in 1999 in an Australian PC Authority magazine, it also featured an interview with Linux Torvalds. The distinction between the two personalities was felt keenly at the time as well. RMS really hasn't changed in those 18 years.

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#19
post #18

Ok, 2 seconds in and I'm shocked. All my life I pronounced gnu as new, like Nutella.

Do you pronounce Nutella "Nu-tella" or "Nut-ella" ? FWIW, I pronounce 'GNU' as 'nu'.

The only reason as to why I pronounce "GNU" with a 'g' sound is because of Richard Stallman. Otherwise, I use the silent 'g'.

Re: Richard Stallman Explains [video]

#20
post #9

I was amazed to see that Stallman doesn't install his OS himself - hasn't for years. He seemed diminished in my eyes after I learnt this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umQL37AC_YM A video where he talks about never installing his own OS.

"A beginner shouldn't be installing operating systems"?

If a moderately-intelligent, moderately-literate beginner can't install your operating system, then your operating system (or at least, its user interface) is crap.

Edit: Just to be clear, I'm responding to the quote, not calling Linux crap. I run a combination of Linux and Windows machines and VMs and they're both very straightforward to install, a complete beginner can just click next / next / next and still get it working.

Post reply on HN