Live data from Hacker News

Building a Music Recommender with Deep Learning

mattmurray.net

1–10 of 74 posts

Re: Building a Music Recommender with Deep Learning

#5
This is interesting, but fairly easy to confuse. Esp. would be interesting to see what results come up when you use modified "artistic" spectographs like that of Windowlicker by Aphex Twin [1]. One thing I've learned from years of having worked with audio and images is that image representations of audio are horrible representations of it (other than for temporal changes).

The results are good though! Good work! :D

[1] http://twistedsifter.com/2013/01/hidden-images-embedded-into...

Re: Building a Music Recommender with Deep Learning

#7
This is interesting.

My first thought was to wonder how a LSTM would do. Once might think it would be a better representation for music? There's some models which use convolutional layers along with a LSTM for video representation (eg [1]) and it would be interesting to see if convolutions are useful for capturing similar themes of music.

I wonder if one could build a music embedding (word2vec style) and use similarities in the embedding space as recommendations? The obvious objective function would be skip-gram, but there might be more interesting objectives there too.

[1] https://github.com/loliverhennigh/Convolutional-LSTM-in-Tens...

Re: Building a Music Recommender with Deep Learning

#9
> It did a really good job classifying trance music while at the other end of the scale was hip hop / R&B with 61%, which is still almost 6 times better than randomly assigning a genre to the image. I suspect that there’s some crossover between hip hop, breakbeat and dancehall and that might have resulted in a lower classification accuracy.

The first step to analyze this is to make a confusion matrix, [1]. It would be nice if the article included it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confusion_matrix

Post reply on HN