Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How has Satoshi Nakamoto been so good at opsec all this time?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 25 posts

Re: Ask HN: How has Satoshi Nakamoto been so good at opsec all this time?

#13
> Edward Snowden? Got identified by the government.

No, he chose to identify himself. The government had no idea.

> Private Manning?

Got snitched by a betrayer. This should not happen. He was very naive to trust an anonymous figure head.

> Dread Pirate Roberts?

A php guy. Enough said.

> The truecrypt drug king from Rhodesia?

Good opsec, but lured to Africa. He was way too big.

Lots of good hackers have good opsec. Almost nobody got caught.

Re: Ask HN: How has Satoshi Nakamoto been so good at opsec all this time?

#14
He hasn't, law enforcement almost certainly know who he is. and there is significant evidence it's Nick Szabo and/or Hal Finney.

Most people in the community believe it's probably one or both of them. Hal Finney died in 2014. Also, it's better for Bitcoin if he is never found as the bitcoin holdings of Satoshi is so large if they were to become active it would crash the price of Bitcoin.

Re: Ask HN: How has Satoshi Nakamoto been so good at opsec all this time?

#15
post #7

One of the most fun theories I've heard came from a friend of mine. He believes Satoshi hasn't been found because there isn't a Satoshi, but rather that it was a code name for a major research project. Creating, designing and building the first version of Bitcoin is complicated and spans a number of fields of expertise. Most of these fields of expertise only have a few truly exceptional practitioners who would be cap…

The problem that I see with your theory is that it would be very difficult for so many people to keep this a secret.

Re: Ask HN: How has Satoshi Nakamoto been so good at opsec all this time?

#17
post #7

One of the most fun theories I've heard came from a friend of mine. He believes Satoshi hasn't been found because there isn't a Satoshi, but rather that it was a code name for a major research project. Creating, designing and building the first version of Bitcoin is complicated and spans a number of fields of expertise. Most of these fields of expertise only have a few truly exceptional practitioners who would be cap…

The problem that I see with your theory is that it would be very difficult for so many people to keep this a secret.

Yeah, it falls into the problem conspiracy theories do. It's incredibly hard to keep a secret when it goes beyond one or two people, especially when what's being hidden is a major controversy or something a lot of people are interested in reading about. If it was a government project, it'd only take one leaker wanting some quick cash from the media to blow the whole thing.

Re: Ask HN: How has Satoshi Nakamoto been so good at opsec all this time?

#19
post #7

One of the most fun theories I've heard came from a friend of mine. He believes Satoshi hasn't been found because there isn't a Satoshi, but rather that it was a code name for a major research project. Creating, designing and building the first version of Bitcoin is complicated and spans a number of fields of expertise. Most of these fields of expertise only have a few truly exceptional practitioners who would be cap…

If I was to bet I'd bet on it being a single exceptional individual who managed to keep it secret than a group of people keeping it secret.

Anything beyond a single person massively increases the probability of a leak.

Post reply on HN