Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Automating the light in my living room

raspberryautomation.blogspot.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#11

Post by bsder »

Nanite wrote: post #8

For everyone wanting to do something similar, please consider not using a raspberry pi for something a simple as controlling a light/garage door and take a look at ESP8266 or ESP32 boards (which have wifi onboard), there's tons of tutorials online, and the price tag can be as low as $3.

And I would argue that if you ever want to productize something like this in volume, you might want to go with a BeagleBone Black/Green instead.

You cannot but the RaspberryPi chips, while you can very much buy all the BeagleBone Black chips and make it yourself, if necessary.

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#12

Post by alewinkler »

Nanite wrote: post #8

For everyone wanting to do something similar, please consider not using a raspberry pi for something a simple as controlling a light/garage door and take a look at ESP8266 or ESP32 boards (which have wifi onboard), there's tons of tutorials online, and the price tag can be as low as $3.

Something simple? You approach seems to be simple, not mine. Can you use that system as a security alarm and send push notifications to your phone? My system can. There are different approaches, don't underestimate others different than yours.

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#13

Post by alewinkler »

NicoJuicy wrote: post #10
alewinkler wrote: post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not by now, but I can share it, I'm going to check if I have to change something to make it public.

Why didn't you use one of the open source code freely available?

Because I'm a software developer, and I like to build my own systems and make them work to fit my needs. I also like to learn new things.

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#14

Post by ddaniels12 »

alewinkler wrote: post #12
Nanite wrote: post #8

For everyone wanting to do something similar, please consider not using a raspberry pi for something a simple as controlling a light/garage door and take a look at ESP8266 or ESP32 boards (which have wifi onboard), there's tons of tutorials online, and the price tag can be as low as $3.

Something simple? You approach seems to be simple, not mine. Can you use that system as a security alarm and send push notifications to your phone? My system can. There are different approaches, don't underestimate others different than yours.

The comment was pointing out that the Raspberry Pi is the wrong tool for the job.

Someone can do everything you mentioned on a cheaper, smaller device; one that’s not running an entire OS that has to be maintained.

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#15

Post by nickelbackfan »

alewinkler wrote: post #12
Nanite wrote: post #8

For everyone wanting to do something similar, please consider not using a raspberry pi for something a simple as controlling a light/garage door and take a look at ESP8266 or ESP32 boards (which have wifi onboard), there's tons of tutorials online, and the price tag can be as low as $3.

Something simple? You approach seems to be simple, not mine. Can you use that system as a security alarm and send push notifications to your phone? My system can. There are different approaches, don't underestimate others different than yours.

>Can you use that system as a security alarm and send push notifications to your phone?

Yes, you can. https://github.com/witnessmenow/push-notifications-arduino-e...

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#16

Post by Insanity »

alewinkler wrote: post #13
NicoJuicy wrote: post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why didn't you use one of the open source code freely available?

Because I'm a software developer, and I like to build my own systems and make them work to fit my needs. I also like to learn new things.

Perfect answer to that. I am in a similar boat as you, many of the things I create are already done but I do it for the experience nontheless. Plus you can tweak things to your liking and don't end up installing an app that does the thing you want + 99 other things you did not want :D

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#17

Post by mattbrewsbytes »

I just moved into a house with a pre-existing alarm system that hasn't been used in years. Motion sensor, door switches, window switches (I think) and maybe the smoke detectors are wired in.

I think a Pi would be a good central unit to control all of them and to then take a couple of defunct iPad/iPod's and make smart control panels out of them.

Anyone have any pointers on how to identify what sensors are what at the control panel? It's just a jumble of what I assume are low voltage wires going into the proprietary box.

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#18

Post by jackiejj22 »

Insanity wrote: post #16
alewinkler wrote: post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because I'm a software developer, and I like to build my own systems and make them work to fit my needs. I also like to learn new things.

Perfect answer to that. I am in a similar boat as you, many of the things I create are already done but I do it for the experience nontheless. Plus you can tweak things to your liking and don't end up installing an app that does the thing you want + 99 other things you did not want :D

Perfect answer to that. I am in a similar boat. I like to waste resources reimplementing everything. I don’t want home automation that actually works, but a home automation building hobby.

Re: Automating the light in my living room

#19

Post by alewinkler »

This is not about the easiest solution, as the easiest solution is just buying any automation system out there in the market. My main objective was learning. Absolutely always that I've learned something it helped me to get business opportunities or jobs. Regarding to the project, it works great for me. It works exactly as I need, it's flexible and extensible as no other approach, with the easyness that I have of been a software developer. I'm adding an alarm system to the project with push notifications, and I already can control my Pioneer AV receiver with the raspberry (through TC/IP), there are a lot of possibilites! :)
Post reply on HN