Live data from Hacker News

Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

bbc.com

11–20 of 320 posts

Re: Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

#12
post #7

There should be a law against bringing in and leaving nylon ropes in the cave. If this continues, all the caves are going to be filled with nylons ropes left by previous divers. Do we want these caves, too, to eventually become a garbage dumping ground?

There are conventions in the cave-diving community on how lines are left/maintained/removed, which prevent caves from being strewn with abandoned lines.

Much like the IT community adopt coding-standards for a project, the cave-diving community has line-placement standards. Whilst the standards vary from location to location (and are in general localised to the requirements of the location's environment), they are generally well "policed" and exceptions are addressed.

Re: Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

#13
post #7

There should be a law against bringing in and leaving nylon ropes in the cave. If this continues, all the caves are going to be filled with nylons ropes left by previous divers. Do we want these caves, too, to eventually become a garbage dumping ground?

The nylon lines are only a safety system - there's typically a mainline and then only branches off of it. The only time multiple lines are used are at the entrance (the mainline is usually placed 50-100m back to prevent untrained divers from finding it accidentally) or where there are jumps, and in both cases the temporary connections are retrieved when the team of divers exits.

In some higher traffic caves these lines are replaced regularly, however with most caves it's an every couple of year type situation and done by volunteer teams.

As a cave is explored & mapped, line is tied on to the end from the explorer's reels - adding multiple knots and failure points. Once there's sufficient traffic or need usually caretakers will go through and attach more resilient line (usually a spectra or dyneema line) and take out the original line, only leaving the exploration markers (name, date, expedition, etc). These teams also find more permanent attachment points or add them (using silt anchors and sometimes bolts) so that the lines aren't secured to cave features wherever possible.

Adding & removing lines on each dive would actually cause more damage to cave features than keeping a permanent or semi-permanent line in place, and there'd be a much higher risk of line movement and entrapment as the connections would be fewer and further between.

Re: Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

#14

I wonder - did they take steps to replenish the cave's oxygen? If not, it's useless for the next person... I guess this is kind of silly and naive, but it's what I would do.

I'm a little surprised there aren't caches of emergency supplies for situations like these.

Cave-divers are expected (and taught) to carry reserve gas supplies with them. From the description, they had reserve supplies - enough reserves to search for an hour - but failed to recover their guideline within that time.

The issue was that they lost their guide-line leading to the exit, rather than running out of gas. In such a scenario, no amount of reserve caches could really solve that problem.

Re: Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

#15

I wonder - did they take steps to replenish the cave's oxygen? If not, it's useless for the next person... I guess this is kind of silly and naive, but it's what I would do.

I'm a little surprised there aren't caches of emergency supplies for situations like these.

Some divers carry a few odds and ends in their buttpacks for longer duration dives, but you never factor this sort of stay into a plan, and don't want to take unnecessary equipment or kit in with you. Where there's been a lot of sump diving (submerged passages between larger air-filled chambers), there are a number of kits like these in some areas, but they're usually left by the expedition and taken back out with them.

Re: Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

#17
post #6

Cave diving is one of those things that I am happy to only experience vicariously through the stories of others.

Or you can watch Youtube vids like this :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WtlwoX1YEmg

This has got to be the scariest video on Youtube in which no harm comes to anyone.

Re: Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

#18
When you're learning to cave dive, one of the first things that you learn is that you may very well die in there.

Most of the training focuses on systems, skills repetition, and understanding and using redundant systems - folks getting into cave diving typically are already extremely experienced divers who if anything need only some minor skill tweaks - most cave instructors will not take on students who don't already have significant open water technical diving experience (multiple tanks, mixed gas, rebreathers, decompression, wreck, etc).

A running joke is that the lost line drill (where you're placed intentionally off of the guide line and have to find it without a mask/light/visibility) is the most punctual cave task you'll ever do - you have the rest of your life to get it right.

Here's a few good books on it (non-affiliate links):

Caverns Measureless to Man by Sheck Exley (the father of cave diving): https://www.amazon.com/Caverns-Measureless-Man-Sheck-Exley/d...

The Darkness Beckons by Martyn Farr: https://www.amazon.com/Darkness-Beckons-History-Development-...

Beyond the Deep by Bill Stone (the Tony Stark of cave diving): https://www.amazon.com/Beyond-Deep-Deadly-Descent-Treacherou...

The Cenotes of the Riviera Maya by Steve Gerrard (patron saint / mapper of Yucatan caves): https://www.amazon.com/Cenotes-Riviera-Maya-2016/dp/16821340... This is more of a map and explanatory notes but gives great insight into the complexity of it. Currently there are 2 systems that almost all cenotes are part of in the Yucatan, and there's some really interesting work going on trying to link the two. Current work is going on at about 180m depth through a number of rooms at the back of "The Pit", and there are multi-day expeditions going on trying to find the linkage.

Re: Two days in an underwater cave running out of oxygen

#20
post #19

> He realised the water at the surface of the lake was drinkable Can someone explain this phenomena? How can the water in a sea-cave become potable?

pretty sure it was inland cave, so not sure why the water should not be drinkable and how is it surprising

they mention the caves where flooded 60000 years ago, which is long time ago to replace all the original sea water with fresh water from other sources

or maybe it's condensated water from walls of cave creating layer on top, though not sure how would that work

Post reply on HN