Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

UK plans age verification for porn websites from 2018

bbc.co.uk

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

31–40 of 162 posts

Re: UK plans age verification for porn websites from 2018

#31

Post by DropbearRob »

Won't someone please think of the children!!

How about this for how to enforce parental controls... Encourage parents to supervise their childrens internet usage and educate the parents how to set up pfsense to control their own home.

I know its not for everyone, however we also have to ask the question, just how big is the problem of internet porn for society when viewed by minors? I don't have kids and haven't seen any studies, so honestly I just don't know.

Surely there are ways that you can educate, inform your kids, and maybe prepare them for what access to an unregulated stream of all of humanities information could contain.

Re: UK plans age verification for porn websites from 2018

#34

Post by dalbasal »

I would like to present to the court exhibit 1: The EU/ or UK "Cookie Laws" AKA "ePrivacy directive."

In the months before and after its implementation there was a lot of discussion around the (vast) grey areas in the laws. After some months, the internet has coalesced on answers. All sites need to implement a nag screen for unknown users, in order to get "informed consent". This consent will be stored as a cookie and users should not delete cookies, or we will have to nag you next time you visit. We will also create a cottage industry of "compliance" specialists that will help you with the language of your nag screens and TCs.

Websites got slightly more annoying. Two-bit consultants made some money. User privacy was not improved in any way.Legislation regulating the internet is tricky business.

Re: UK plans age verification for porn websites from 2018

#35

Post by avh02 »

>Mr Hancock said: "All this means that while we can enjoy the freedom of the web, the UK will have the most robust internet child protection measures of any country in the world."

This had me chuckling - I grew up in the Gulf region - they have the "nobody gets access" policy - way more robust.

Re: UK plans age verification for porn websites from 2018

#36

Post by westmeal »

lb1lf wrote: post #22

This, if enacted, will do more than any effort by the EFF or others to enhance online privacy. VPN usage, TOR and bitcoin/ethereum acceptance online will skyrocket. After all, what the UK government is proposing is basically to learn its citizens from an early age how to evade censorship by giving them a proper incentive to figure out how to go under the radar.

The funniest part is you're probably right. After all to most people it's what the Internet is for.

Re: UK plans age verification for porn websites from 2018

#37

Post by raesene6 »

jaclaz wrote: post #7
Nursie wrote: post #2

Which will definitely, once and for all, stop teenagers looking at porn. Definitely.

Well, that will depend on how exactly the way the customers "will have to prove they are 18", as an example we know how no teenager under 18 would ever tick a box near "Yes, I am 18 or older". On the other hand needing to provide a photo or scanned image of your driving license or passport AND give access to the web camera to the site to verify your identity, while reasonably effective might somehow produce as a side…

No matter how they do verification, the scheme won't have the intended effect as there are massive numbers of non-commercial sites which make porn available, including pretty much any site that allows user generated content.

And on the other side we have a load of personal information given to a load more sites on the Internet, with all the potential for problems if/when they get hacked (e.g. Ashley Madison)

Re: UK plans age verification for porn websites from 2018

#38

Post by RobertoG »

Is this really addressed to minors? Because making identification mandatory is going to affect everybody behaviour.

It also makes a perfect excuse to control what is accessible and that could be expanded to other kinds content.

Also, it's frequently the case (I can't think of exceptions) that the people in power always try to control the sexual behaviour of others. I would like to know the reason for politic and religious authorities to be so obsessed with sex.

In other gregarious species, who can reproduce is decided by the high status individuals. Maybe is related to that.

Post reply on HN