Live data from Hacker News

An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

techcrunch.com

51–60 of 283 posts

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#51

Startup ideas inspired by Always Sunny in Philadelphia? http://itsalwayssunny.wikia.com/wiki/The_Gang_Recycles_Their... What's next? An Uber-like service that will deliver gasoline directly to your car that is parked in your driveway? Hmm... Come to think of it, that would actually be pretty sweet. I would never have to stop and fill up my gas tank! It would just always be full! A gas delivery truck would come in the…

http://www.filld.com/

www.tesla.com

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#52
post #5

This is great but what if, hold on, we paid taxes.

It's a shame government services are normally junk (pun unintended). That's my experience.

Off the top of my head: I would pay twice for x. Given how bad gov services are.

Edit: Cool downvotes Marxist bros. Our national health service can't be super inefficient (I'm just about to go on a waiting list for a year) & my rubbish collection can't have just halved the amount of trash they take every two weeks. You're right!

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#53
I'm rooting for these guys - it looks like their COO has been in waste management since 1999 (and, from the article, his family's been in it for decades). As a casual observer of "non-sexy" startups, I've noticed that these kinds of founding teams do well.

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#54
post #5

This is great but what if, hold on, we paid taxes.

Many towns in New Hampshire with spread out population do not want to pay for garbage pickup. Everyone brings everything to the dump themselves. These people "self-uber for garbage" as they say.

Some rich folks pay companies like Waste Management to do it for them.

What's wrong with that model?

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#55
post #5

This is great but what if, hold on, we paid taxes.

Wouldn't it be better if we were allowed to interact voluntarily? Pay for what we wanted and used, and support people and causes through charity instead of under duress?

In theory perhaps, but every explanation I've heard for how such a society would work has so many holes that they only work for a small subset of real-life cases, and wouldn't scale at all.

I'm sure it would work great for a small community of up to a couple of hundred carefully selected individuals, but I think anyone who thinks it would work for general society is a bit blinded by their ideology.

In the end, the only forms of Government that have worked at scale have centralised governance, and democratic Governments seem to be the least-worst workable systems.

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Filld customers pay the lowest price of the three gas stations closest to their location plus a small delivery fee. For example, if the three gas stations closest to you charge $2.62, $2.55 and $2.67 per gallon, you will pay $2.55. We purchase this pricing data from the Oil Price Indexing Service (OPIS), and we update it regularly. How do they make money? I wonder how high the delivery fee is.

They're not paying the gas station price. They're likely paying bulk prices then just using the local prices as your price. Edit: $3 for delivery generally and they're using F250 trucks. Call it 1.5t in the bed or about 400 gallons plus tank. They probably have a contract with the local bulk terminal so if you're paying 2.55, they might be paying 30% (no idea what this margin is) less or so. @400 us-gal if they make…

Gas is actually a loss leader at many/most gas stations. My parents owned a gas station about 10 years ago and one of the reasons they sold it and got out of that business was because competition was so fierce that they had to sell gas at or below the bulk price they paid for it. In other words, they effectively lost a few pennies every time someone bought gas. All profit came from in-store sales of other items.

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're not paying the gas station price. They're likely paying bulk prices then just using the local prices as your price. Edit: $3 for delivery generally and they're using F250 trucks. Call it 1.5t in the bed or about 400 gallons plus tank. They probably have a contract with the local bulk terminal so if you're paying 2.55, they might be paying 30% (no idea what this margin is) less or so. @400 us-gal if they make…

Could anyone run the numbers on whether this model is profitable, or whether it's another "use VC money to acquire users" type deal? EDIT: Looks like they pay anywhere from $18/hr to $22/hr for their delivery people: https://www.comeet.co/jobs/filld/42.00E Also health, dental, and vision benefits + PTO, FSA, and free lunches. Wow.

Just did, check my comment above

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#58
post #5

This is great but what if, hold on, we paid taxes.

In spite of having tax funded garbage collection I often have trouble getting rid of certain things. Large items are collected infrequently and I might not want that sitting in my yard for a week or more awaiting pickup. Similarly, car batteries or other things that have special disposal rules can be difficult to find that information easily when it's something you deal with very infrequently. A service like this cou…

I have zero pickups apart from household trash, so broken tv's, those bushes I cut down, or huge boxes etc I have to drive to the recycling place (15 min drive).

I'd happily pay for a service to take it there but there is a catch 22: as an individual I already paid (through taxes) to leave stuff. Companies have not - so if I pay a company to take my things there, I'd also pay twice to leave the stuff there as they can't leave my stuff "for me". If I could somehow give a transport company the right to use my free (tax paid) recycling/dumping right then this would work here. Without that, can't work for individuals. Would work perfectly for businesses though.

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#59
post #5

This is great but what if, hold on, we paid taxes.

Wouldn't it be better if we were allowed to interact voluntarily? Pay for what we wanted and used, and support people and causes through charity instead of under duress?

Not really, no. These things work at scale, and it would be incredibly difficult to find a price that works for everyone without it also taking into account their income, or similar. So... a tax.

Re: An ‘Uber for garbage’ picks up steam, and $11.7M in Series A funding

#60

I want this for residential. Instead of having a "trash day" I wait until my garbage can is full, click a button on my app, and tomorrow morning someone comes and picks up my trash.

No need for a button -- add pressure sensors inside the trash can and it can signal the garbage person for you.

There are companies doing exactly that already
Post reply on HN