Live data from Hacker News

The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

qz.com

11–20 of 348 posts

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#11
post #7
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exercise fixed all of my back pain issues. I do heavy deadlifts. I can't tell you how many people told me that it would hurt my back. But it turns out having a muscular back to support my spine was exactly what I needed.

Seems like this advice could hurt a lot of people if they have a different issue with identical systems.

I'm not going to say deadlifts are recommended in every case, and I have no medical qualifications.

I have done a bunch of research and have tons of anecdotes which indicate that with proper form deadlifts are far safer and more effective for a wide range of people than is commonly imagined. And the form is rather easy to get right.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#12
post #9

Here's some free advice. When your back bothers you, try some jogging. If you can't jog, walk. Taking it "easy" by laying around is not the cure. I'm pretty sure the vast number of back problems are caused by too much sitting and lying down.

That advice could leave people paralyzed. Slight modification: when it hurts, give it rest. When it gets better, don't forget to keep healing it.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#13
post #9

Here's some free advice. When your back bothers you, try some jogging. If you can't jog, walk. Taking it "easy" by laying around is not the cure. I'm pretty sure the vast number of back problems are caused by too much sitting and lying down.

Your experiences don't necessarily generalize to the population. Lots of people have back problems despite regular exercise.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#14

> The author is often asked for her thoughts on certain forms of exercise, such as yoga or pilates, which she also covers on her website. What she tells people, repeatedly, is that “movement is essential.” The exercise economy is the real back pain industry.

Perhaps, but exercise has so many other contingent benefits with so few comparable risks, not to mention it can be low cost of free that it's not really fair to compare the two.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#15
Anyone suffering from back pain who really wants to recover should read Dr. John Sarno's work. Here's a link to his book: https://www.amazon.com/Healing-Back-Pain-Mind-Body-Connectio...

I was skeptical at first, but just reading his book and thinking through what he presented healed my lower back pain.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#16
I can personally vouch for the effectiveness of a morning routine of 15 minutes of exercise at home, targeting the pelvic muscles. The only equipment required is a floor mat, if the floor is hard. I started gently and naturally progressed to a higher level, taking the attitude that there is no hurry, because I'm going to be doing this for the rest of my life, so there is plenty of time to progress. My initial routine was just lying on my back trying to tighten my pelvic muscles without hurting. Three years later I'm up to front/back/left/right planks interleaved with stretching.

I don't mean to be smug, as back pain really is an individual thing. There's an element of searching for what works, and I was lucky in that I was pointed directly towards an effective treatment.

This result was science based, in that I was treated by a general practitioner who specialised in back pain and insisted on an evidence based approach. (This doctor also wrote the manual for NSW's worker's compensation scheme and lectures at a major university on the topic.)

Edit: My doctor's rule was "pain free exercise". Go as far as you can, but stop if hurts. A test of whether you've really overdone it is whether the new pain goes away overnight. He also reckoned that it would be difficult to do a further injury whilst doing exercises, as the pain would make me self limiting.

Further edit: My initial physio, and a cortisone injection, at the time of injury, weren't aimed at a long term fix, but at providing enough temporary pain relief to begin exercising.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#17

Anyone suffering from back pain who really wants to recover should read Dr. John Sarno's work. Here's a link to his book: https://www.amazon.com/Healing-Back-Pain-Mind-Body-Connectio... I was skeptical at first, but just reading his book and thinking through what he presented healed my lower back pain.

Wait, the process of thinking through the book's contents itself healed the pain?

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#18

Anyone suffering from back pain who really wants to recover should read Dr. John Sarno's work. Here's a link to his book: https://www.amazon.com/Healing-Back-Pain-Mind-Body-Connectio... I was skeptical at first, but just reading his book and thinking through what he presented healed my lower back pain.

Just curious: What did you learn from that book? I read through it halfways and gave up because I couldn't make sense of it.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#19
post #9

Here's some free advice. When your back bothers you, try some jogging. If you can't jog, walk. Taking it "easy" by laying around is not the cure. I'm pretty sure the vast number of back problems are caused by too much sitting and lying down.

I've found that my lower back aches after I've walked very long distances, actually. Long being 4-5 miles.

Re: The $100B per year back pain industry is mostly a hoax

#20
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exercise fixed all of my back pain issues. I do heavy deadlifts. I can't tell you how many people told me that it would hurt my back. But it turns out having a muscular back to support my spine was exactly what I needed.

I've fixed my bouts of lower back muscle spasms by strengthening my abs.

The core is so important. Core + breathing exercises will improve any other activity.
Post reply on HN