Live data from Hacker News

Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

livetrucking.com

11–20 of 91 posts

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#11
post #4

I feel like truckers should tell Walmart to shove it. This is getting abusive

In the short term, this could benefit the truckers. Rates may go up as each of the larger customers raises rates to attract them.

In the long term, truckers are best served by having competition in the marketplace. If there is only one big customer on the market then they have little chance of getting fair rates.

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#12
If this is true (keeping in mind the source is an analyst who is relating conversation between other parties for which they were not involved), it might not necessarily be a negative for the freight market. If the contractors become territorial about which freight companies they will hire it will effectively reduce the supply available for both (once a freight company commits to one or the other) meaning Walmart/Amazon will each have to pay more essentially for "exclusivity".

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#13
The comments on the original story are fascinating. Hundreds of truckers sharing personal stories. Their spelling is dodgy but many bring detailed personal data. From my read, it sounds as if Amazon has two business issues to fix (staggered scheduling and last-minute cancellations). Walmart seems to have infuriated truckers for more reasons than I can count. Not sure Walmart is going to like the outcome of this war.

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#14

First AWS, now this. At what point does the DOJ step in? Isn't this anticompetitive behavior? I've heard that Reagan-era deregulation changed a lot of the relevant law, but I'm not clear on how. Is Walmart doing this with the expectation of impunity because there's no longer a crime to charge them with, or because they see themselves as immune to prosecution?

Hard to make the case that walmart is a monopoly. For what its worth amazon has pulled similar stunts like not selling the chromecast.

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#15
post #4

I feel like truckers should tell Walmart to shove it. This is getting abusive

In the short term, this could benefit the truckers. Rates may go up as each of the larger customers raises rates to attract them. In the long term, truckers are best served by having competition in the marketplace. If there is only one big customer on the market then they have little chance of getting fair rates.

In the long run, there are no truckers.

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#16

"Amazon offers $0.10 more per mile, leaving Walmart with no truckers" But really, Wal-mart needs to get over themselves and do what they need to do to adapt, rather than being the bully they've always been. It isn't like they refuse technology, they have a pretty decent technology team as far as I can tell.

Where did you read this quote?

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#18
fuck Walmart. You don't hear anything about Amazon workers being on public assistance because they are payed enough and get enough hours to survive on their own. Around the holidays Walmart takes food and toy donations for their workers inside their break rooms. It's a bad company and I hope it gets killed off.

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#19
post #14

First AWS, now this. At what point does the DOJ step in? Isn't this anticompetitive behavior? I've heard that Reagan-era deregulation changed a lot of the relevant law, but I'm not clear on how. Is Walmart doing this with the expectation of impunity because there's no longer a crime to charge them with, or because they see themselves as immune to prosecution?

Hard to make the case that walmart is a monopoly. For what its worth amazon has pulled similar stunts like not selling the chromecast.

I can see the argument* to say "we can't invest the work to support chromecast". Whereas it's harder to say "we won't talk to these other truckers who work with our competitor".

*A argument, not one that would hold in court. IANAL.

EDIT: It seems I misunderstood Amazon's lack of Chromecast support. I hadn't thought of trying to buy Chromecast through Amazon before. I own three of them and bought all through the Google store.

Re: Walmart threatens to cut ties with truckers that also haul for Amazon

#20

fuck Walmart. You don't hear anything about Amazon workers being on public assistance because they are payed enough and get enough hours to survive on their own. Around the holidays Walmart takes food and toy donations for their workers inside their break rooms. It's a bad company and I hope it gets killed off.

Hate to break it to you, but Amazon does not treat their warehouse staff much better.
Post reply on HN