Live data from Hacker News

The .feedback scam

everythingsysadmin.com

11–20 of 171 posts

Re: The .feedback scam

#11

Wow, the author is not exaggerating when saying it is a scam. Looking at the .feedback page for Stack Overflow, it says at the top, in fairly large letters "We make Stack Overflow, where the world's developers get answers, share knowledge & find jobs they love. Also proud builders of the @stackexchange Q&A network." Then at the absolute bottom, in small, washed out print it says "Disclaimer: This site is provided to…

Consumers will eventually learn, as they always do. Try to educate anyone you meet that brings up .feedback. If anyone on social media talks about it, link them this article.

If that were really true, the BBB might have gone under years ago, and the Nigerians might stop asking for help in transferring great wealth.

There is no shortage of suckers in the world - as the old saying goes, there's one born every minute.

Re: The .feedback scam

#12
An unethical and shamefully pathetic extortion scheme. This is really a disappointing and completely uninnovative, destructive direction to take the internet in

Re: The .feedback scam

#13
Reminds me of GetSatisfaction back in the day. It was never as much of an outright scam as this, but they definitely had that protection racket vibe about it.

Re: The .feedback scam

#14
How is this a scam? The result is obviously just a ratings site which never purports to be the sites referenced in their URL...why does it matter if you type in google.feedback or feedback.com/google or google.feedback.com into your browser? No reasonable person could be misled to believe that google.feedback/ was at all related to Google.

edit: Okay, I guess it is a pretty messed up website. If you go to reply to something, it gives you the ability to "officially" reply (as, say Google) for a mere $29 per message. This doesn't seem like extortion, but it is a pretty horrible business idea.

Re: The .feedback scam

#15

Wow, the author is not exaggerating when saying it is a scam. Looking at the .feedback page for Stack Overflow, it says at the top, in fairly large letters "We make Stack Overflow, where the world's developers get answers, share knowledge & find jobs they love. Also proud builders of the @stackexchange Q&A network." Then at the absolute bottom, in small, washed out print it says "Disclaimer: This site is provided to…

Well, the reviews on stackoverflow.feedback are quite informative!

Dan Manny says:

Stack over flow made me loose money!!! Bad code with security wholes in it crashed my clients site!! Warning warning for scammers

and Antonio B. of Indonesia says:

Best site for solving programming issue!!!11!one! The most user and newbie friendly site!

11/10 would recommend

You know you can trust reviews like this!

Re: The .feedback scam

#18
post #14

How is this a scam? The result is obviously just a ratings site which never purports to be the sites referenced in their URL...why does it matter if you type in google.feedback or feedback.com/google or google.feedback.com into your browser? No reasonable person could be misled to believe that google.feedback/ was at all related to Google. edit: Okay, I guess it is a pretty messed up website. If you go to reply to so…

Seriously?

Re: The .feedback scam

#19
post #14

How is this a scam? The result is obviously just a ratings site which never purports to be the sites referenced in their URL...why does it matter if you type in google.feedback or feedback.com/google or google.feedback.com into your browser? No reasonable person could be misled to believe that google.feedback/ was at all related to Google. edit: Okay, I guess it is a pretty messed up website. If you go to reply to so…

> No reasonable person could be misled to believe that google.feedback/ was at all related to Google.

Mate, that is 100% confusing to anyone on the internet.

Especially more so now that google uses their own TLD for some of their blogs/services. So `blog.google` is google. `google.com` is google, but `google.feedback` isn't. Please explain...

Post reply on HN