Live data from Hacker News

The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

minimaxir.com

271–280 of 282 posts

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#271

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've used imgur in the past because it is upload->url, no further messing around required.

If you're sharing with a limited option all you have to do is right click the file in your Dropbox folder and click "get public link" -- others are suggesting there's bandwidth caps so this isn't ideal for a Reddit post or something that might receive large amounts of traffic.

That link does not go to the image. You have to manually edit it.

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#272

Imgur copied Reddit's functionality first, to be fair. Maybe because they identified how easy it would be for them to get nuked by Reddit?

What Reddit specific functionality did they copy?

Comments on images, voting on images and comment, stuff like that. Imager went from a simple image host to being it's own image sharing community.

example: http://imgur.com/gallery/SkAns

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#273
post #50

To me, Reddits new image handling is a pain in the ass. I liked that I could either look at the image/video or read the commments. Now I have no choice but to receive them both at the same time. Videos even start to autoplay. Also: Is it new that Reddit allows animated ads? I always had the feeling Reddit was a place where I could peacfully interact with others. Lately I am afraid it turns into a page full of animate…

Can you clarify on the animated ads you're seeing?

Mobile App iOS has autoplay video ads. Twitch prime or whatever its called was the first one I saw yesterday.

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#274

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But that was back in a time when reddit really was a news-sharing site. Huff huff get off my lawn and all, but back in the day it was more akin to hackernews, and so the "problem" of hosting images wasn't a problem at all - you'd be linking to articles that had their own image hosting solution. Nowadays it's a heavy picture, meme, whatever browser. Makes sense that imgur is trying to take over that niche.

Was it ever a news sharing site? I think you might be mis-remembering history.

Honestly before RES came out the proportion of images on reddit was very low. Going back further before subreddits I remember it as largely just news articles and discussions, much like HN.

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#275
post #228

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it was created by /u/mrgrim as a programming side project because all the other img hosts were shitty, and as it was born of reddit, essentially for reddit, it blew up. I cant stand the new i.reddit img service, but that could be me just being an off-my-lawn-er... but I am wary of reddits motivations, as I dont trust the admins all that much given the fact that they are a huge social manipulation tool - and if you do…

For me it's quite the opposite. I like browsing the web in the evening on a 5 year old tablet. Ever since imgur started redirecting mobile clients to the full site for all direct image links the experience gets worse and worse. They keep adding more scripts and shit over time so currently when opening an imgur link the tablet freezes for about 4 seconds until it starts showing the loading spinner and then it takes an…

Me too. That awful gifv has never worked on my older Samsung tablet. I don't understand why not and I gave up trying to diagnose the problem.

Other imaging hosts that serve up .mp4's as substitutes for .gif like giphy work just fine. It's just Imgur that couldn't figure out how to make this work properly.

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#276
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I upload stuff to imgur just for the nice, short URLs. genuinely curious, why is that important? is it common to memorize the URLs instead of copying and pasting?

When I want to share an image over chat with a friend, the long, odd looking reddit image urls disrupt the natural flow. It's like virtually slapping someone on the face. A nice, short and sweet URL is much nicer in text conversations. Also, being a developer and security conscious, I inspect URLs before I click on them. The longer they are, the more frustrated I get examining them.

> being a developer and security conscious, I inspect URLs before I click on them. The longer they are, the more frustrated I get examining them.

it doens't really matter if a url is long or short, right? as long as the domain looks good then there's no reason to check every character in the url? not sure why it's more secure to have a shorter url if the domain is safe

*not a security expert

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#277

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Eh, people regularly get around this by splitting their comments in much the same way as on Twitter, dividing them into multiple 1/2

comments as a nested chain of replies, which is also often abused for humorous effect. 2/2

Which I find obnoxious enough to avoid reading entirely :P

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#278

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Eh, people regularly get around this by splitting their comments in much the same way as on Twitter, dividing them into multiple 1/2

comments as a nested chain of replies, which is also often abused for humorous effect. 2/2

[deleted]

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#279
post #228

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For me it's quite the opposite. I like browsing the web in the evening on a 5 year old tablet. Ever since imgur started redirecting mobile clients to the full site for all direct image links the experience gets worse and worse. They keep adding more scripts and shit over time so currently when opening an imgur link the tablet freezes for about 4 seconds until it starts showing the loading spinner and then it takes an…

Me too. That awful gifv has never worked on my older Samsung tablet. I don't understand why not and I gave up trying to diagnose the problem. Other imaging hosts that serve up .mp4's as substitutes for .gif like giphy work just fine. It's just Imgur that couldn't figure out how to make this work properly.

It's very likely the terrible redirect shenanigans they do on gifv. And have just expanded to all files on all platforms, oh boy.

Re: The Decline of Imgur on Reddit and the Rise of Reddit's Native Image Hosting

#280

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Was it ever a news sharing site? I think you might be mis-remembering history.

Honestly before RES came out the proportion of images on reddit was very low. Going back further before subreddits I remember it as largely just news articles and discussions, much like HN.

Before subreddits, yes, it was mostly links to articles. But pics was one of the first subreddits, and images made an increasingly large fraction of posts over time. I think RES was as much a response to that as it was a driver of it. If anything, I think the rise of smartphones was the big push. It's simply easier to consume imagery than text on a small screen like that.
Post reply on HN