Live data from Hacker News

Posterous takes on Tumblr

blog.posterous.com

31–40 of 100 posts

Re: Posterous takes on Tumblr

#32
I moved from posterous to tumblr because the administrative control panel UI/UX was so bad. The default posterous skin is hideous. Tumblr is much easier to use and looks better out of the box. I couldn't care less about the features in the checklist.

Re: Posterous takes on Tumblr

#34
post #5

This is a really low blow. This is what companies do when they are clutching at straws - they spread misinformation. Considering: * Most tumblr themes have Disqus integration, and the "tumblr way" to comment is via reblog. * Multiple people can contribute to Tumblr blogs, I can also submit posts even if I'm not a user, and ask the authors questions (formspring style) * I can also password protect my Tumblr. They also…

It's not misinformation, but it is marketing/PR (and I bet it's working). Competing is not a low blow and it's not stabbing anyone in the back. They aren't saying "Tumblr SUCKS", they are saying "We're different, here's how, come give us a shot".

The proof will be in the numbers, but I doubt it will work with Tumblr. They're pretty spot on about Tumblr being like a collection of high-school cliques -- but what do you think happens when you take an "us vs. them" attitude against a clique? They just become defensive & tighter.

Re: Posterous takes on Tumblr

#37
post #12

Maybe they should add "Adds hidden affiliate codes to your links. Posterous: YES. Tumblr: NO." ( http://techcrunch.com/2010/04/30/posterous-starts-automatica... )

Do you KNOW that Tumblr doesn't do this? Dig a little and I think you'll be surprised how many other services (including Tumblr) do this too...

Re: Posterous takes on Tumblr

#38
post #37
post #12

Maybe they should add "Adds hidden affiliate codes to your links. Posterous: YES. Tumblr: NO." ( http://techcrunch.com/2010/04/30/posterous-starts-automatica... )

Do you KNOW that Tumblr doesn't do this? Dig a little and I think you'll be surprised how many other services (including Tumblr) do this too...

Tumblr absolutely does not do this.

Re: Posterous takes on Tumblr

#39
This is good for the market and the internet as a whole. Competition creates better products and innovation, which means my mother will eventually get to the world of easy posting of content. End of story.

Re: Posterous takes on Tumblr

#40
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't attack the feature, I said they bootstrapped their theme launch with the tumblr themes. That isn't attacking. I simply meant they lent on the pre existing tumblr community to boost their own offerings - which was genius. I do think to do that, and for Tumblr to nod or whatever, and then to do this, seems, IMHO a mis-step.

Actually on day one every single theme that we launched, I designed. We gradually added the best themes that we liked the most, some of them were Tumblr themes, and others were created by Posterous users, e.g. http://corywatilo.com

I wouldn't even call them "Tumblr themes." These were just blog themes, owned by a third party, who licensed them to us for use on Posterous. They just happened to be on Tumblr first, but don't have any other affiliation to that service.
Post reply on HN