Live data from Hacker News

IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

reynoldsftw.com

11–20 of 36 posts

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#11
post #8

My 3G (w/ the 4 GM) routinely freezes to the point where it just stops responding to input. I'll probably attempt to downgrade it to 3 soon. Which, I honestly don't mind. I mean, I would rather Apple not even support the 3G with iOS 4 rather than have to deal with this user experience. It's not like it can even deal with background tasks anyway...

Same problem here; iPod frequently doesn't respond to headphone controls, and apps slow to a crawl and become unusable ( >1 minute to respond to clicks).

Do you test/debug apps on your phone? Is it possible that this is triggered by using debugging tools? It seems like everyone else is not seeing what we're seeing.

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#12
post #8

My 3G (w/ the 4 GM) routinely freezes to the point where it just stops responding to input. I'll probably attempt to downgrade it to 3 soon. Which, I honestly don't mind. I mean, I would rather Apple not even support the 3G with iOS 4 rather than have to deal with this user experience. It's not like it can even deal with background tasks anyway...

You can downgrade? Because I'd sure like to, until I get around to ordering the iPhone 4.

There are guides or official ways of downgrading?

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#13
I've seen claims in both directions. To play it safe, I'll keep my 3G on 3.x. There was only 1 new feature in iOS 4 (that also worked on 3G models) that attracted me anyway: the unified mailbox view thing.

Actually I have a short list of desired improvements that might make it worth it, despite a speed drop:

* photo synching to my desktop (so not limited to the lame select-up-to-4-then-email-them thing, which is way too time-consuming if you have many photos and/or add new ones frequently)

* in Safari, when hit Add Bookmark, and goes into the Bookmarks view, it should start in the top-level collapsed state, that way I can quickly navigate to the right folder to select. Divide and conquer would speed it up in the case where there are many nested folder categories.

* making the Back button in Safari take you back to a cached, post-rendered view of the previous page -- rather than having to re-fetch/parse/render all over again, wasting my time, battery and the network (groan)

* cached application state restoration in general, consistently -- i realize the critical ingredient here is partly having enough memory and flash, so just beefing up the hardware with each new model refresh should get us to an ideal state eventually. Right now, lots of frustration and wasted effort when I go back in Mail and Safari and it's forgotten where I was last at and has to redo everything, sometimes reseting to some default state (such as scrolled to the extreme top rather than down in the middle where I was)

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#15
post #12
post #8

My 3G (w/ the 4 GM) routinely freezes to the point where it just stops responding to input. I'll probably attempt to downgrade it to 3 soon. Which, I honestly don't mind. I mean, I would rather Apple not even support the 3G with iOS 4 rather than have to deal with this user experience. It's not like it can even deal with background tasks anyway...

You can downgrade? Because I'd sure like to, until I get around to ordering the iPhone 4. There are guides or official ways of downgrading?

Yeah, just download your firmware from this page, then option-click Restore in iTunes and select the IPSW.

http://www.felixbruns.de/iPod/firmware/

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#16
post #15
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can downgrade? Because I'd sure like to, until I get around to ordering the iPhone 4. There are guides or official ways of downgrading?

Yeah, just download your firmware from this page, then option-click Restore in iTunes and select the IPSW. http://www.felixbruns.de/iPod/firmware/

Then why do people pay more money for phones that haven't been upgraded? I figured it was because you can't go backwards and the newest versions can't be unlocked.

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#17
post #16
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, just download your firmware from this page, then option-click Restore in iTunes and select the IPSW. http://www.felixbruns.de/iPod/firmware/

Then why do people pay more money for phones that haven't been upgraded? I figured it was because you can't go backwards and the newest versions can't be unlocked.

The newer 3GS is harder to downgrade and you also can't downgrade the baseband (modem firmware) version, but you should be able to downgrade the actual operating system without any trouble.

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#18
post #8

My 3G (w/ the 4 GM) routinely freezes to the point where it just stops responding to input. I'll probably attempt to downgrade it to 3 soon. Which, I honestly don't mind. I mean, I would rather Apple not even support the 3G with iOS 4 rather than have to deal with this user experience. It's not like it can even deal with background tasks anyway...

Interesting, my 3G had the exact same problems as you (just froze and didn't respond to anything for like minutes at a time) with OS 3. But the problems have gotten a lot less frequent with OS 4 for me.

Re: IPhone 3G Performance with iOS 4.0 is terrible

#19
post #16
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, just download your firmware from this page, then option-click Restore in iTunes and select the IPSW. http://www.felixbruns.de/iPod/firmware/

Then why do people pay more money for phones that haven't been upgraded? I figured it was because you can't go backwards and the newest versions can't be unlocked.

When you try to install a firmware on your device (whether it's iOS 4.0 or iPhone OS 2.0), Apple signs the firmware using some combination of a unique identifier and other things to make sure you should be able to install it. When they release a new firmware, they typically stop signing the old firmware days or weeks afterwards, meaning you can't downgrade to it anymore. Also, there are checks on the device so even if you do manage to install it, you'll need to run certain commands to get it to boot up the first time.
Post reply on HN