Live data from Hacker News

Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

devuan.org

61–70 of 71 posts

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#61
post #10
post #4

Great to see they are making headway. Wonder about the long term sustainability though, as more and more software such as GNOME3 DE lists it as a dependency

There's also Linux life without Gnome. I hope this means more people will try out alternative window managers.

Could always use the Window manager that is included in the X-Server source code package: TWM. It's dependencies is basically the X-server.

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#62

The website needs some work. I could gather they were a fork of Debian, but I couldn't find​ the benefits. I had to come to the HN comments to learn about the systemd controversy. Less important, the mobile experience was not good on Android Chrome. When scrolling, the logo visibility toggles and the page content jumps.

at the very bottom of the page it addresses it: > Devuan is about choice. We think people should be able > to choose whether to use a GNU+Linux system with or > without systemd. > Devuan decided to fork not only the base distribution, > but also its governance, because Debian has made it > difficult to avoid systemd as init, entangling the system > with unnecessary dependencies and did so despite... but you're right…

thanks; I missed that

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#63

Some things that need work: - The logo. Logos are very affordable. I would consider revisiting this logo, buying a new one or organizing a contest. Believe it or not, many people use t-shirts with the Debian logo and I assume that's some source of revenue stream. I do not see myself wearing a Devuan t-shirt with this logo. Right not it looks like a logo for a UFO cult or some cheap Internet cafe. - The information on…

Any recommendation on logo designers?

A friend commissioned a logo through a website where you get proposals from multiple artists. He had the chance to buy a fantastic logo for a very affordable price. I don't know the name of this website but my HN family here surely knows. Someone?

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#64
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Systemd is a lot more than just init. It also manages user auth, udev, time, syslog, and a few other things.

That is the main complaint.

My point is more that systemd makes less sense if you think of it as just init. "Why does init need to manage -foo-?" is a valid question. But "Why does a general 'system daemon' need to manage -foo-?" tends to be self-answering.

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#65

It's likely that I missed it, but I can't find anywhere that talks about how many packages deviate from Debian. I love what they are offering but I also want to make sure that the ease of use I get with Debian continues with Devuan. Can we assume that any packages that are not Gnome related from the Debian repos are in the Devuan repos?

This video[0] (dated Nov 29, 2016) says 381 forked packages. That's not nearly as bad as it sounds because many individual software projects are divided up into multiple packages.

For example, libvirt[1] produces 9 packages consisting of: libvirt-bin, libvirt-clients, libvirt-daemon, libvirt-daemon-system, libvirt0, libvirt0-dbg, libvirt-doc, libvirt-dev, libvirt-sanlock.

The video is rather interesting for learning about how the project came about and how it works in general.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMvyOGawNwo

[1]: https://git.devuan.org/devuan-packages/libvirt/blob/master/d...

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#66
post #21
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For most users, it wouldn't matter anyway, and I'd argue that that's true even for a lot of the sysadmins. But the argument had a few layers more. Quite a few people agreed that the current init system wasn't exactly the bee's knees, but disagreed on what to use to replace it (systemd, upstart, heck, even Apple's launchd). There was a rather vocal group that didn't actually care that much about the specific implement…

As a dev/sysadmin, systemd is barely noticeable when you think if it as an init system. When you look at the cool tricks it can do, it's more like its part of the OS than something living on top of it, providing services you'd expect a kernel to provide (albeit not a very Unix-like one, which is what makes people so mad about it). It's a large and complex beast, doing a lot of different things that make sense in a mo…

Ask my users if Apache failing to start on openSuSE because of systemd and lack of ServerName resolution is "barely noticeable".

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#67
post #61
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's also Linux life without Gnome. I hope this means more people will try out alternative window managers.

Could always use the Window manager that is included in the X-Server source code package: TWM. It's dependencies is basically the X-server.

If you have ever used TWM, then you would know that the 'T' stands for Terrible. Fortunately, there are lots of lightweight WMs that are far better. Personally, I use tiling WMs (namely XMonad at the moment), so I could really care less what GNOME, KDE, et al are up to. However, I realize most people are accustomed to stacking WMs and expect something similar to what is provided by proprietary OSes with a similar amount of eye candy as well.

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#68
post #21
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For most users, it wouldn't matter anyway, and I'd argue that that's true even for a lot of the sysadmins. But the argument had a few layers more. Quite a few people agreed that the current init system wasn't exactly the bee's knees, but disagreed on what to use to replace it (systemd, upstart, heck, even Apple's launchd). There was a rather vocal group that didn't actually care that much about the specific implement…

As a dev/sysadmin, systemd is barely noticeable when you think if it as an init system. When you look at the cool tricks it can do, it's more like its part of the OS than something living on top of it, providing services you'd expect a kernel to provide (albeit not a very Unix-like one, which is what makes people so mad about it). It's a large and complex beast, doing a lot of different things that make sense in a mo…

Perhaps you could give some examples of "cool tricks"?

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#69
post #66
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a dev/sysadmin, systemd is barely noticeable when you think if it as an init system. When you look at the cool tricks it can do, it's more like its part of the OS than something living on top of it, providing services you'd expect a kernel to provide (albeit not a very Unix-like one, which is what makes people so mad about it). It's a large and complex beast, doing a lot of different things that make sense in a mo…

Ask my users if Apache failing to start on openSuSE because of systemd and lack of ServerName resolution is "barely noticeable".

What did systemd do wrong to cause that? Mess up DNS?
Post reply on HN