Live data from Hacker News

Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

devuan.org

41–50 of 71 posts

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#41
It's likely that I missed it, but I can't find anywhere that talks about how many packages deviate from Debian. I love what they are offering but I also want to make sure that the ease of use I get with Debian continues with Devuan.

Can we assume that any packages that are not Gnome related from the Debian repos are in the Devuan repos?

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#42

Some things that need work: - The logo. Logos are very affordable. I would consider revisiting this logo, buying a new one or organizing a contest. Believe it or not, many people use t-shirts with the Debian logo and I assume that's some source of revenue stream. I do not see myself wearing a Devuan t-shirt with this logo. Right not it looks like a logo for a UFO cult or some cheap Internet cafe. - The information on…

Any recommendation on logo designers?

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#44
post #4

Great to see they are making headway. Wonder about the long term sustainability though, as more and more software such as GNOME3 DE lists it as a dependency

Simply do not use gnome 3 and problem solved.

It's a mystery to me that people still associate linux desktop with gnome. The gnome project has a long history of not caring about users or developers and prioritizing their view and their brand.

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#45
It's great that they have released and it's important there are options so users are not locked-in to a single init.

We need to do more to ensure projects do not create lock-ins especially gratuitous ones from single companies that make it difficult for people to use for instance Gnome without systemd.

This kind of lock-in can only lead to bad outcomes and make developing future alternatives and improvements more difficult.

Also its time Systemd defines a scope and decouple and brand any additional functionality beyond an init differently so it makes it easier to inter-operate and pick and choose both for users or distributions. Or you have distributions like Debian for instance voting for an init system but getting all the externalities that were not voted for ending up becoming defacto choices.

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#46
post #19
post #4

Great to see they are making headway. Wonder about the long term sustainability though, as more and more software such as GNOME3 DE lists it as a dependency

Under Debian you can run GNOME under other init systems thanks to Debian+Canonical creating systemd-shim (alternative to logind). Under Devuan you cannot use GNOME (they don't offer it). This as Devuan claims that it is impossible (despite being possible within Debian) (!)

  This task package is used to install the Devuan desktop, 
  featuring the GNOME desktop environment, and with other 
  packages that Devuan users expect to have available on the 
  desktop.
https://devuan.org/os/packages/task-gnome-desktop

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They were told to by debian. They argued for as long as they could while debian was still 'their' distribution to change the direction systemd would take it. It was clean that wasn't going to happen. Final response; "If you don't like it you can always fork. But you'll never release anything." So now they have forked and they have released. So now their splitters. Cake and eat it types, what can you do?

> They were told to by debian. I don't follow. Are you saying that representatives of the Debian project refused to collaborate with the Devuan developers with regards to improving init system interoperability?

[deleted]

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#48
post #19
post #4

Great to see they are making headway. Wonder about the long term sustainability though, as more and more software such as GNOME3 DE lists it as a dependency

Under Debian you can run GNOME under other init systems thanks to Debian+Canonical creating systemd-shim (alternative to logind). Under Devuan you cannot use GNOME (they don't offer it). This as Devuan claims that it is impossible (despite being possible within Debian) (!)

For as long as said shim and logind are compatible, and logind is a moving target.

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#49
post #12

I am not Linux admin, but I've been using Linux managed by others on servers for many, many years and I have a question: Is that 'systemd' thing is so crucial and important to devote so much effort to create brand new Linux distribution. I have only vague picture what systemd is doing, I can imagine that there could be something better (as always in IT), but is this really that important?

Systemd is very Windows-like.... big central kernel-like thing that provides services, logging, authentication... but what I don't understand is why they anyone would rather have init.d

Re: Devuan Jessie 1.0.0 stable release

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They were told to by debian. They argued for as long as they could while debian was still 'their' distribution to change the direction systemd would take it. It was clean that wasn't going to happen. Final response; "If you don't like it you can always fork. But you'll never release anything." So now they have forked and they have released. So now their splitters. Cake and eat it types, what can you do?

> They were told to by debian. I don't follow. Are you saying that representatives of the Debian project refused to collaborate with the Devuan developers with regards to improving init system interoperability?

I mean, I think the comment was pretty clear, and that sounds like exactly what they said.
Post reply on HN