Live data from Hacker News

Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

buzzfeed.com

71–80 of 195 posts

Re: Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

#72
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm curious as to which "Chinese example" do you have in mind that doesn't work? Edit to reply to your wifi issue: you need to use that one website to login to access the "full" internet.

The Chinese example where they have tens of thousands of people monitoring internet content and spend millions per year on filtering and blocking technology - and it can all be circumvented with a VPN.

The Chinese 'Golden Shield' project should not be confused for this one; they have different goals. The primary goal in the Chinese case is economic protectionism and it's succeeding beyond their wildest dreams. Google, Facebook et al might dominate the rest of the world but they are solidly locked out of the Chinese market.

Re: Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

#74
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting. So on one side people are bashing the the level of censorship by the government and how people are unable to exercise certain rights. On the other side the same people are laughing at its ineffectiveness and how trivial it is to circumvent them and access information freely. One of them must surely be wrong? Btw, censoring of keywords and blocking of websites are two different issues. VPN solves the latt…

The problem is that it suppresses the majority of ordinary people but the people who actually want to do the stuff the government is trying to stop can still keep doing it anyway. > Btw, censoring of keywords and blocking of websites are two different issues. VPN solves the latter, not the former. So in China, they block access to foreign apps like Twitter, Facebook and so on, and so people gravitate towards the home…

I agree with everything you said but I failed to see how that is a problem (from the perspective of the GFW). Again what you said is exactly the intended effect of GFW.

Re: Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

#75

Virtually all the parties in the UK have stupid big brother policies like this, and the ones which don't are complete jokes in most general policies.

The liberal democrats, the SNP and the Green parties (in England & Wales, and in Scotland) do not support policy such as this.

Re: Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

#76
post #16

Every day there are news coming out of the U.K. that just makes me even happier that I left it. This is no exception.

I want out but I'm not sure my partner will leave. Every day living here makes me more depressed and anxious. And I worry that we'll leave it too long and stand no chance of moving to an EU country.

Re: Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

#77

As a British citizen, this makes me sick to my stomach. However, I'm probably in the minority. A few years ago I went to a debate about the Internet and how it affects families, and it was interesting and rather scary to hear people's attitudes. It seemed that a lot of people didn't fully understand what the Internet was, asking why it didn't have a watershed [1] like TV does. Despite good arguments being put forward…

I think this is a similar problem to that of net neutrality: a majority of people don't understand how the internet works (in any way, shape or form), and therefore are easily swayed by the loudest parties - often the ones trying to make a profit, not protect the internet.

Re: Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

#79

As much as I expect nanny-state behaviour from the Tory's this has blown me away. I thought the author may be exaggerating so I went and actually read the manifesto. It's only about one page near the end but it reads like something you'd expect from a dictatorial regime. It seems like after cutting us off from Europe via Brexit the government now wants to cut us off from the rest of the world. I just hope internet co…

> I just hope internet companies stand up the UK and refuse to do business here

Honestly, as a techie my impulse is to go "fine, have your shitty internet" to legislators who repay the advances the tech revolution has given them this way, but -

The reality is that tech companies are all still businesses hungry for bigger marketshare and willing to follow the money. The "internet giants" have all bent over backwards for China (or just been supplanted by chinese alternatives); I wouldn't be surprised if they did the same here.

After all, not doing so means you're leaving money and mindshare on the table for your competitors. It sucks, but that's what'll ultimately drive corporate decisions. The "ethical choice" is usually just a deferral of the eventually "more profitable" choice.

Re: Theresa May Wants To Regulate The Internet

#80
a) Tor/VPN b) A fake ID c) Bitcoin d) Mesh networks/Torrents Some tech. that aid in privacy/anonymity yet to be invented etc.

It's impossible to regulate the internet. The common people will be at disadvantage.

Running awareness campaigns are the best tool the govt. got which will be much more positive & effective than these non-nonsensical unethical monitoring and controls.

Post reply on HN