Live data from Hacker News

Git and GitHub Integration Comes to Atom

blog.atom.io

51–60 of 112 posts

Re: Git and GitHub Integration Comes to Atom

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think a lot of us have moved from Atom/Sublime over to VS Code these days. Seems like lots more momentum and gobs of useful plugins that let me do my work.

I guess this is the IDE crowd? Us vim guys are still raising eyebrows when people say "best free option" :)

I've been a vim user for a long time. I switched to Atom despite its slowness because I finally get linter and autocomplete integrations that just work. Those have always been a pain to set up for me in vim, and when you are switching between machines all the time, that quickly becomes tiring.

I don't see a reason to stick with traditional vim for the majority of my work, since most other editors have plugins with a very good coverage of the core vim features/keybindings.

EDIT: Oh yeah, and multicurors. I just remembered that they were also a big part of reason for switching. At least at the time, every implementation of multicursors in vim was broken in a very major way for me.

Re: Git and GitHub Integration Comes to Atom

#52
post #42

I can't get into Atom, the load time vs something like sublime is just too slow. Am I doing something wrong in the settings?

Load time of what? opening a file? It is instantaneous other than really large files.

Yes once the program is already open it's pretty snappy. But I like to keep my desktop clean so I close / open it fairly often and it's startup time if just not on par I've found.

Re: Git and GitHub Integration Comes to Atom

#53
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find bundling Git support with Atom is a requirement, VSCode does it.

Of course, VSCode also supports TFS, Perforce, and Mercurial via extensions: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/search?target=VSCode&ca... Providers

There are community-provided atom packages for all/most of the providers you listed. The point isn't one editor versus another. The point is that Atom should remain plausibly neutral about Github (which is separate from Git or Mercurial or whatever).

An analogy would be if VSCode shipped with a fancy CodePlex dashboard by default (I know CodePlex is dead). There's an obvious incentive for them to pick sides but it's not in the best interest of the people using the editor nor the editor itself.

Re: Git and GitHub Integration Comes to Atom

#58

As a long time (happy) user of the Git-Plus add on for Atom, I am not sure how I feel about this. Mainly because I use BitBucket for 95% of my projects. I only use GitHub very rarely for public projects that I blog about. I hope that this won't break existing Git plugins, and won't limit Git functionality for non-Github based repos.

Even though it comes bundled by default, like everything in Atom, you can just disable it as a default package in the settings.

Re: Git and GitHub Integration Comes to Atom

#59
I'm not sure if a stronger focus on git/GitHub is a step into the right direction for Atom users. I'd strongly recommend to provide a choice. Why not other VCSs, why not other platforms?

We get it, Atom is GitHub's pet toy. But never assume it will be forever. Remember Sourceforge and CVS?

Post reply on HN