Live data from Hacker News

Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

slackhq.com

41–50 of 177 posts

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are correct that Screen Hero still works and all, but it is technically "dead." No one new can sign up for the service. You can only use it if you already had it setup. I would personally consider that "dead" if it's now closed off for anyone to signup with. It's not like you can recommend this as alternative to what Slack is doing with their screen sharing. On https://screenhero.com/login they even say "New sign…

I typed /hero in slack It gave a link to "add the Screenhero Integration" I clicked that link and it took me to a Slack prompted me to create a "free account", which it did using my Slack information. Then I was able to download screenhero. So, anyone new can sign up for the service via Slack.

No, when I try I get

You do not have a Screenhero account for your Slack email

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#42

As someone else mentioned, they are finally doing some more with their purchase of Screen Hero most likely. However, one major feature that Screen Hero had that I don't _THINK_ this new screen sharing built in Slack has, is the ability for the other person to control the mouse/keyboard on your screen. I could be wrong, but if that is the case it's a huge feature missing. That was one of my favorite things that Screen…

If anyone from screenhero is reading:

I love screenhero and use it all the time but the one feature I need the team to add is the ability to disable another people's control of my screen. I think this feature is useful, but sometimes I'm giving a demo and just dont need it (or want it). I have fucked up multiple demos because someone accidentally clicked off my browser tab while I was controlling the screen.

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#43
We're a Microsoft shop so we use Skype for Business, which seems to work well for talk/IM/screen sharing. Now we're getting "Teams" to be slacker.

I'd be curious to hear how the Slack video/screen sharing compares to Skype Business, after a rocky start it's working pretty smoothly for us now.

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#44

I see mentions of Screen Hero in a way that makes it sound like it's dead, but my team still uses SH daily (via Slack's `/hero` command). It's easily the best _remote pairing_ tool that I've found. This new Slack feature seems like something different, for presenting content to everyone on a call, not for collaborating on code.

ScreenHero is being mentioned because they were acquired by Slack a few years ago. So, this feature is literally just ScreenHero.

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What do you mean you miss it? It still is around. I use it all the time.

You have to have been a customer at the time it shut down to use it, which means I can use it and invite other people, but it's pretty limited

It's also included with all Slack paid accounts, existing and new.

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#47

We're a Microsoft shop so we use Skype for Business, which seems to work well for talk/IM/screen sharing. Now we're getting "Teams" to be slacker. I'd be curious to hear how the Slack video/screen sharing compares to Skype Business, after a rocky start it's working pretty smoothly for us now.

We're doing the same thing. I want to use Slack but we're going with Teams for cost reasons (included in o365). I've never had any problems with screen sharing with skype for business.

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#48

I'm really surprised this took so long. Hipchat has had this available for a couple of years now. If they aren't adding the pairing features that made Screenhero so good (dual mouse pointers, dual control, resolution adjustment and scrollaround windowing) then what's the value add?

I'm more surprised about the fact that the masses didn't switch to a more capable chat service in the meantime.

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#49

As someone else mentioned, they are finally doing some more with their purchase of Screen Hero most likely. However, one major feature that Screen Hero had that I don't _THINK_ this new screen sharing built in Slack has, is the ability for the other person to control the mouse/keyboard on your screen. I could be wrong, but if that is the case it's a huge feature missing. That was one of my favorite things that Screen…

If anyone from screenhero is reading: I love screenhero and use it all the time but the one feature I need the team to add is the ability to disable another people's control of my screen. I think this feature is useful, but sometimes I'm giving a demo and just dont need it (or want it). I have fucked up multiple demos because someone accidentally clicked off my browser tab while I was controlling the screen.

They aren't working on Screenhero anymore.

Re: Screen sharing comes to Slack video calls

#50
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lack of Linux support is the only thing preventing our organization from ditching hangouts.

What's wrong with Google Hangouts? (I don't have any perspective, just asking)

No keyboard & mouse sharing. And to a lesser extent, not everyone wants a Google account.

My employer also blocks some Google services. For example, I can't access Gmail. Trying to use Hangouts without Gmail is swimming upstream a bit.

Post reply on HN