Earlier quoted context omitted.
Politics is the answer with regards to communications. I suspect that may also be the case for other technology in Australia. The only reason Australia needed a NBN was because of the sale of Telstra as a vertically integrated monopoly. It should have been split from the start into wholesale and retail as happened in New Zealand. Apparently they were starting to roll out fibre when the sale was announced. It was poli…
This issue seems to occur all over the world where you have fixed terms in politics and politicians who lack the guts to do what is right because they only need to do enough to get re-elected and long term plans are off the table I thought Australia doesn't have fixed terms federally?
How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
151–160 of 188 posts
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#152I have a personal perspective on this. Around 2014 or so, I + some of Australia's top physicists designed and quickly prototyped some tech to lower the cost of the NBN rollout bigtime. Our approach revolved around self install fibre + a far greater use of wireless. I contacted 15+ people in senior leadership at NBNco, all of whom are still on my LinkedIn. No matter how hard I tried, we couldn't get a meeting with NBN…
I feel your pain. It is extremely difficult in Australia to get interest in anything related to innovation. I have had surreal experiences when dealing with companies and particularly Government. They will do anything to boycott something that resembles change, particularly if it affects the the way they work, or of course that might expose their incompetency. Australia is not a place to live unless you work in healt…
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#153So they promoted the guy who screwed up the project, Malcolm Turnbull, to be Prime Minister.
The lead singer in Midnight Oil sung "How do we sleep / While our beds are burning" in 1987... and in 2009 the same person (Peter Garret), in his position as Minister for Environment Protection (among other things), was the driving force behind a home-insulation scheme that was found to be the cause of 224 house fires. You basically have to have a humorectomy to be able to follow Australian politics. Otherwise you go…
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#154Earlier quoted context omitted.
I read it as a statement that the problems faced by remote aboriginal communities are structural and obey institutional inertia; that they are hard problems. We have a history of well-intentioned reformers coming in and making everything much worse: the stolen generation, the NTER, laws against alcohol consumption that cause even more destructive patterns of behaviour, etc. I've known men and women who trained as pol…
Thanks, what an intriguing level of detail to draw from the cartoon, I have to admit I never read even the slightest amount of that from it. To me the cartoon is staggeringly racist. Clearly, deliberately, outrageously racist. And I am deliberate in my use of the words "deliberate" and "outrageous" because personally I believe in Australia that the proprietor of this particular newspaper makes his money by manufactur…
It's hard to draw a line between pointing out uncomfortable truths in an effort to help, which I consider the role of a political cartoonist, and just slandering the Aboriginal people, which I consider racism. I give Bill Leak the benefit of the doubt because the policeman is Aboriginal. If the policeman was white, I would see the cartoon as blatantly racist, but I believe Leak deliberately made the policeman Aboriginal to contrast the two men: the successful policeman futilely trying to pull a kid out of a downwards spiral, the alcoholic absentee father unable to help, and the son who's already begun to inherit the problems of his father and might one day be in his father's position.
Even if I've read the cartoon correctly, I don't think it was very good, since it clearly failed to communicate its message. What I think of when I see it, though, is one of the Koori kids I went to primary school with, who we'll call Eli. Eli's father was jailed for drug trafficking when we were young, and didn't come back to Eli's mother when he got out. Eli himself grew up to be jailed when he was in his early twenties, after an assault related to drug trafficking, and Eli has a kid on the outside just like his dad did. Racist or not, effective or not, the cartoon accurately shows the process by which Eli ended up in jail.
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#155Earlier quoted context omitted.
>Seriously it is time for a citizens revolution. We need to take the country back from these idiots. Nothing can be done until Australians demand Constitution reform. This is the crux of the problems with Australian politics - its Constitution is absolutely atrocious.
The fact we don't have a Bill of Rights (or even an equivalent to the First Amendment) is ridiculous. But on the plus side we stopped with the ridiculous gun-toting crap 20 years ago, so some parts of our constitution are more reasonable than other countries. One of the more worrying issues is that the Governor-General (and thus by proxy the Queen of fucking England) has vito power over our laws.
Also, its veto, not vito and the Governor General's reserve powers are a check on the Government. In the history of the Commonwealth of Australia these powers have been used twice: 1) On 13 May 1932, when the Governor of New South Wales Sir Philip Game dismissed the Government of New South Wales. 2) On 11 November 1975, when the Governor-General of Australia Sir John Kerr dismissed the Commonwealth Government.
In both cases an election was held very soon afterwards and, again in both cases, the dismissed government was massively defeated by popular vote.
I really wish they would teach better civics in schools.
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#156Earlier quoted context omitted.
Yeah very strange how they have done the rollout. Surely they would have been better off rolling out to densely populated inner suburbs first. Cover the most people and get those most likely to take up the service initially.
It was part of the deal Julia Gillard made to form a minority government. The NBN had to prioritise regional areas first.
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#157Earlier quoted context omitted.
> a) live close to the city b) have telephone poles c) live near a telephone exchange and were chosen by Telstra to get FTTN before the change of government you can get 100Mb+ access. I check all those points but no NBN for me :(
I feel your pain, the rollout was interesting. Wonder if the NBN rollout in Melbourne related to electorates?
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#158So they promoted the guy who screwed up the project, Malcolm Turnbull, to be Prime Minister.
The lead singer in Midnight Oil sung "How do we sleep / While our beds are burning" in 1987... and in 2009 the same person (Peter Garret), in his position as Minister for Environment Protection (among other things), was the driving force behind a home-insulation scheme that was found to be the cause of 224 house fires. You basically have to have a humorectomy to be able to follow Australian politics. Otherwise you go…
Peter Garret basically covered for Rudd
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#159Earlier quoted context omitted.
> was the driving force behind a home-insulation scheme that was found to be the cause of 224 house fires. House fires went down statistically. The absolute number of fires was higher because more homes were getting insulation, but fires per insulated home went down. The real cause is business efficiency, hiring cheaper workers and not training them properly. You can't hold the government responsible for every grunt…
>> was the driving force behind a home-insulation scheme that was found to be the cause of 224 house fires. > House fires went down statistically. The absolute number of fires was higher because more homes were getting insulation, but fires per insulated home went down. Oh. I didn't know that. So you mean this occurred after the installation...? > The real cause is business efficiency, hiring cheaper workers and not…
Re: How Australia Bungled Its $36B High-Speed Internet Rollout
#160Earlier quoted context omitted.
Thanks, what an intriguing level of detail to draw from the cartoon, I have to admit I never read even the slightest amount of that from it. To me the cartoon is staggeringly racist. Clearly, deliberately, outrageously racist. And I am deliberate in my use of the words "deliberate" and "outrageous" because personally I believe in Australia that the proprietor of this particular newspaper makes his money by manufactur…
The reality of life in Australia is that, if you are Aboriginal, you are vastly more likely to be abused as a child, you will die on average a decade earlier than the rest of the country, and as far as anyone can tell, much the same will be true for your children - life could be a little better for them, because the gaps seem to be narrowing, but they aren't narrowing fast enough to reach parity before those children…
I have no idea how we can help Aboriginal Australians break out of this spiral. I truly hope we can find a way.