Live data from Hacker News

How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

slatestarcodex.com

21–30 of 41 posts

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#21
post #4
post #3

I don't know if it was around in 2014, but https://promethease.com/ can do this analysis for you, including from AncestryDNA and 23andme. I plan on using it once my AncestryDNA results finally come back.

also -- https://dna.land/ seems to give extremely similar (possibly identical?) results, for free

dna.land is very nice, they do trait surveys and compare it to their predictions so you can actively help improve their data.

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#23
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Neat! Might as well do both and see how they compare :)

I just plugged my 23andme data into both. Waiting for results. I was thinking of sharing the results, is anyone interested? Is there really any good reason not to? I know people get all uptight about it but I'm not sure why.

Results I dont think anyone gets uptight about, the actual DNA data absolutely.

People get uptight because in the future someone like an employment agency or life insurance company might buy one of these services and use the data to discriminate.

There's also social consequences that may come of this, like if you had a one night stand, public publishing your DNA might create a bread crumb for your child to find you which could be a good or bad thing depending on if you had a spouse at the time for example.

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#24
post #3

I don't know if it was around in 2014, but https://promethease.com/ can do this analysis for you, including from AncestryDNA and 23andme. I plan on using it once my AncestryDNA results finally come back.

I used promethease and learned I'm CCR5-Δ32 and likely HIV immune

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CCR5

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#25
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just plugged my 23andme data into both. Waiting for results. I was thinking of sharing the results, is anyone interested? Is there really any good reason not to? I know people get all uptight about it but I'm not sure why.

Results I dont think anyone gets uptight about, the actual DNA data absolutely. People get uptight because in the future someone like an employment agency or life insurance company might buy one of these services and use the data to discriminate. There's also social consequences that may come of this, like if you had a one night stand, public publishing your DNA might create a bread crumb for your child to find you w…

I found out I have a surprise half-sister through 23andme. It also turns out that my Dad may not actually be my biological father.

It affects you more than you might think.

I personally want the truth, no matter what, so after a few weeks of thinking about things, I was ok with what I learned. The hard part is dealing with family members than may not feel the same. People need to be aware of just how messy this can get.

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#26
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Results I dont think anyone gets uptight about, the actual DNA data absolutely. People get uptight because in the future someone like an employment agency or life insurance company might buy one of these services and use the data to discriminate. There's also social consequences that may come of this, like if you had a one night stand, public publishing your DNA might create a bread crumb for your child to find you w…

I found out I have a surprise half-sister through 23andme. It also turns out that my Dad may not actually be my biological father. It affects you more than you might think. I personally want the truth, no matter what, so after a few weeks of thinking about things, I was ok with what I learned. The hard part is dealing with family members than may not feel the same. People need to be aware of just how messy this can g…

How did you find out about your half sister? I thought 23&me only gives you information about yourself and nobody else?!

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#27
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Results I dont think anyone gets uptight about, the actual DNA data absolutely. People get uptight because in the future someone like an employment agency or life insurance company might buy one of these services and use the data to discriminate. There's also social consequences that may come of this, like if you had a one night stand, public publishing your DNA might create a bread crumb for your child to find you w…

I found out I have a surprise half-sister through 23andme. It also turns out that my Dad may not actually be my biological father. It affects you more than you might think. I personally want the truth, no matter what, so after a few weeks of thinking about things, I was ok with what I learned. The hard part is dealing with family members than may not feel the same. People need to be aware of just how messy this can g…

> surprise half-sister

> Dad may not actually be my biological father

Wow, what a pair of bombshells!

Was this stuff known to both your parents or did it blow someone's cover?

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I found out I have a surprise half-sister through 23andme. It also turns out that my Dad may not actually be my biological father. It affects you more than you might think. I personally want the truth, no matter what, so after a few weeks of thinking about things, I was ok with what I learned. The hard part is dealing with family members than may not feel the same. People need to be aware of just how messy this can g…

How did you find out about your half sister? I thought 23&me only gives you information about yourself and nobody else?!

She contacted me via 23andMe. I could have left it at that, they don't give out details. And I had to chose to participate in the 'find your relatives' feature. It's as open or closed as you want it to be.

Re: How To Use 23andMe Irresponsibly (2014)

#29
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I found out I have a surprise half-sister through 23andme. It also turns out that my Dad may not actually be my biological father. It affects you more than you might think. I personally want the truth, no matter what, so after a few weeks of thinking about things, I was ok with what I learned. The hard part is dealing with family members than may not feel the same. People need to be aware of just how messy this can g…

> surprise half-sister > Dad may not actually be my biological father Wow, what a pair of bombshells! Was this stuff known to both your parents or did it blow someone's cover?

Unfortunately, I can't ask them, as my mother has passed away, and my father will not talk about it. The fact that my Dad wasn't interested in genetic testing was my first hint, as that is very unlike him. But it makes sense in the larger pattern- I am the youngest of the family by 15(!) years, and all of my siblings were adopted. It seems pretty clear in retrospect that my parents likely had to use a sperm bank. I've had my suspicions for a while, so this wasn't the complete shock it could have been.

Still threw me for a loop at first, though.

Post reply on HN