Live data from Hacker News

Identify Plants with an App

plantsnap.net

61–70 of 117 posts

Re: Identify Plants with an App

#61

I use the flowerchecker app http://www.flowerchecker.com/ where you have to pay a small fee per plant identification. It actually uses real human biologists to identify the plant.

You mean college students?

Even if they're college students, they'll know way more than I do about plants

Re: Identify Plants with an App

#62
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know if the mention was intentional or not, but Goggles is actually dead as a product. They removed it from the iOS app, and the android app is not supported, while staying in the store. In this respect, as the GP says, image search is currently the best option

Goggles (the concept) isn't dead. They moved the functionality into Google Assistant so you didn't​ need the app. Just hold down the home button so it takes a picture of the camera view.

Sadly to use the Assistant still requires disabling almost all privacy controls on your Google account.

Re: Identify Plants with an App

#63
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know if the mention was intentional or not, but Goggles is actually dead as a product. They removed it from the iOS app, and the android app is not supported, while staying in the store. In this respect, as the GP says, image search is currently the best option

Goggles (the concept) isn't dead. They moved the functionality into Google Assistant so you didn't​ need the app. Just hold down the home button so it takes a picture of the camera view.

Huh, I had no idea. An Easter egg, almost, as I've never seen this mentioned by Google.

It works ok, send pretty beta right now. I pointed my camera at a business card and pressed the home button. Google Assistant appeared and I asked it to tell me about what was on my screen. It noticed one piece of the address, and brought up a listing for that general area, but there was no way to further inquire into any of the rest of the card.

Re: Identify Plants with an App

#64
post #55
post #31

I did this for common plant diseases using Tensorflow on Android when learning how to use TF last year. Found the accuracy to be not that great with real world images that are not in the dataset (with a dataset of 50,000 images from PlantVillage). I think there are just too many visual similarities between various plants (especially when taken from various angles) that the network doesn't focus on the right things. D…

Not an expert -- would this be a result of training data doing a much better job isolating the subject vs a real world photo that may have other plants in the scene? Not that this is a solution in all cases, but is it possible your results would have improved with better real world pictures?

Likely but the whole point of 'AI' is that it should be able to identify flowers that don't look like what it's seen before. If not, it's just a huge lookup table that's like a memory repository.

This is, of course, a critical challenge in data science and is definitely not a trivial one to solve.

Re: Identify Plants with an App

#65

I use the flowerchecker app http://www.flowerchecker.com/ where you have to pay a small fee per plant identification. It actually uses real human biologists to identify the plant.

You mean college students?

Oxford gives this definition of biologist:

"An expert in or student of the branch of science concerning living organisms."

Re: Identify Plants with an App

#69

I use the flowerchecker app http://www.flowerchecker.com/ where you have to pay a small fee per plant identification. It actually uses real human biologists to identify the plant.

You mean college students?

College students are in fact real humans....

Re: Identify Plants with an App

#70

I use the flowerchecker app http://www.flowerchecker.com/ where you have to pay a small fee per plant identification. It actually uses real human biologists to identify the plant.

I've been using it a lot this spring to identify all the wild things growing in my yard. Love it.
Post reply on HN