Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

nescat.gcubed.co

21–30 of 89 posts

Re: Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

#21
Given the list of mirrors, it appears the author knows what they're doing is illegal.

You don't have to agree with copyright law (and by all means, please try to change it!), but please don't take other people's work and build products out of it without their permission.

Re: Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

#23

Why doesn't Nintendo port old NES/SNES/GameBoy games to smartphones and sell them for $1-$2 each? They're so much more fun than all these compulsive microtransaction games.

Because it would reduce demand for them if they were to try to get them onto the Switch with a much higher markup.

Re: Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

#24
post #21

Given the list of mirrors, it appears the author knows what they're doing is illegal. You don't have to agree with copyright law (and by all means, please try to change it!), but please don't take other people's work and build products out of it without their permission.

If I bought the game in 1989 I can still legally play it in digital form, yes? I'm not sure why copyright now means a company can charge me 100 times for the same product in different forms. It didn't used to and I'm not sure how this changed mindset in any way helps creators or society.

Re: Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

#25
post #21

Given the list of mirrors, it appears the author knows what they're doing is illegal. You don't have to agree with copyright law (and by all means, please try to change it!), but please don't take other people's work and build products out of it without their permission.

If I bought the game in 1989 I can still legally play it in digital form, yes? I'm not sure why copyright now means a company can charge me 100 times for the same product in different forms. It didn't used to and I'm not sure how this changed mindset in any way helps creators or society.

> If I bought the game in 1989 I can still legally play it in digital form, yes?

No, that's not how copyright works. That's a myth. In some cases you can make a backup of the game if you do it yourself. But you still can't download someone else's copy.

> I'm not sure why copyright now means a company can charge me 100 times for the same product in different forms.

Because copyright means the company that sold you the product retains the right to copy it. That's not a right you bought when you paid for the game.

> It didn't used to and I'm not sure how this changed mindset in any way helps creators or society.

I'm not sure it's been a help either. Someone should change the laws to align them with modern society. But this isn't the way to do it.

Re: Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

#26
post #12
post #6

You shouldn't have posted this :) EDIT: I remember playing a copycat of konami's contra at childhood, and had wondered what the name of that game was. Now I know the original, thanks!

I would have thought the Nintendo Lawyers would have sent out their Scud Missile on that server within 5 minutes.

I have an idea: make it so that you have to supply your own rom files that the site will only store locally, and you then can get matched with anyone else who has roms with the same md5s. No legal problem because nothing copyrighted will be on the server, and it'll support much more roms than the small selection supplied.

Re: Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

#27
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I bought the game in 1989 I can still legally play it in digital form, yes? I'm not sure why copyright now means a company can charge me 100 times for the same product in different forms. It didn't used to and I'm not sure how this changed mindset in any way helps creators or society.

> If I bought the game in 1989 I can still legally play it in digital form, yes? No, that's not how copyright works. That's a myth. In some cases you can make a backup of the game if you do it yourself. But you still can't download someone else's copy. > I'm not sure why copyright now means a company can charge me 100 times for the same product in different forms. Because copyright means the company that sold you the…

Your first point is not so clear cut. A ROM is a ROM is a ROM. Do you have any citations where you own a physical copy and use an identical digital copy from a different physical source a breach of copyright?

Re: Show HN: Play multiplayer and singleplayer NES games online

#28
post #6

You shouldn't have posted this :) EDIT: I remember playing a copycat of konami's contra at childhood, and had wondered what the name of that game was. Now I know the original, thanks!

It was released as Probotector in Europe and the men were replaced with gun-wielding robots.
Post reply on HN