Live data from Hacker News

“Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

linkedin.com

21–30 of 38 posts

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#21
"I graduated from Cornell in 2004."

That pretty much puts him in the the same millennial bucket. lol

In all seriousness, the applicant's writing was fine, and his correction was superficial at best.

Does he not realize how bad this article makes him look?

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#23
I have never seen anything on Glassdoor or LinkedIn worth caring about, ever.

I spend almost all of my time avoiding both places and giving zero fucks about the people that get sucked into those whirlpools of desperate flailing for attention.

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it should be. Lead by example.

It seems to me that having to polish all feedback to a publishable level of quality would (greatly?) reduce the amount of feedback someone could give. I've appreciated informal feedback that I've received in the past and if that was the bar that needed to met I would have likely never received anything back.

Agree. I was surprised by the length of some of the comments. Most of the editorial notes and critique I've seen are very terse.

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#25
post #21

"I graduated from Cornell in 2004." That pretty much puts him in the the same millennial bucket. lol In all seriousness, the applicant's writing was fine, and his correction was superficial at best. Does he not realize how bad this article makes him look?

The writing was pretty bad, actually. But his isn't a lot better.

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#26
post #7

It sounds like Pollard was trying to emulate his writing professors (forgetting he is supposed to be a businessman now). I've met people like that. Trying to teach "life lessons" (in which they don't succeed) instead of sticking to the prime objective. And Pollard's writing professors sound like blowhards who don't have much else going on in life but pompous critiques. Pretty much like a number of university soft sci…

My high school English teacher regularly "ripped to shreds" papers like that in the early 1980s. It was very difficult to write to his satisfaction. But he was a great teacher.

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#27

Lost me at "millennial". How can people jump on the millennial-hating train and not see it as the "kids these days" "get off my lawn" horseshit that it really is? The author could use a good editor.

It's a matter of numbers that take generalities to extremes. Thirty years ago, some of the things I read about in all seriousness with serious tone would have been laughed at as having no basis for debate or serious consideration. Yes, people should generally feel relatively safe at school. But the idea that we should regress back to segregated living and social quarters because some people can't handle being in a situation with someone that disagrees with them, or perhaps has a better argument?

As a libertarian and a deist, I'm on the outs with almost anyone who tends towards most extremes (even people in my own party, "taxation is theft" mantra for example). There were pacifists in WWI, WWII, Korea, Vietnam, etc... They've always been there. But today as long as it's your guy being the agressor it seems to be okay, but as soon as it's the other guy, it's all bad.

It's like all reason and accountability went out the window at some point. Yes, some of what gets reported is sensational examples far from the norm... but it's at a rate that astounds me. There are a lot of people who have had a very sheltered existence and assume that what's fair is always what's right and that their sheltered view is what is real. It usually isn't.

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#28
post #7

It sounds like Pollard was trying to emulate his writing professors (forgetting he is supposed to be a businessman now). I've met people like that. Trying to teach "life lessons" (in which they don't succeed) instead of sticking to the prime objective. And Pollard's writing professors sound like blowhards who don't have much else going on in life but pompous critiques. Pretty much like a number of university soft sci…

Then again... the applicant could have taken the criticism, adjust, and resubmit, thanking them for the prior critique. I see a LOT of very simple mistakes in articles today, published in print or online. It constantly makes me question as to what happened to actual editors and those that proof content.

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#29
post #7

It sounds like Pollard was trying to emulate his writing professors (forgetting he is supposed to be a businessman now). I've met people like that. Trying to teach "life lessons" (in which they don't succeed) instead of sticking to the prime objective. And Pollard's writing professors sound like blowhards who don't have much else going on in life but pompous critiques. Pretty much like a number of university soft sci…

Then again... the applicant could have taken the criticism, adjust, and resubmit, thanking them for the prior critique. I see a LOT of very simple mistakes in articles today, published in print or online. It constantly makes me question as to what happened to actual editors and those that proof content.

Editors cost money.

Re: “Millennial savages me on Glassdoor for giving constructive feedback”

#30

Lost me at "millennial". How can people jump on the millennial-hating train and not see it as the "kids these days" "get off my lawn" horseshit that it really is? The author could use a good editor.

It's a matter of numbers that take generalities to extremes. Thirty years ago, some of the things I read about in all seriousness with serious tone would have been laughed at as having no basis for debate or serious consideration. Yes, people should generally feel relatively safe at school. But the idea that we should regress back to segregated living and social quarters because some people can't handle being in a si…

I honestly can't tell if you're taking a position on the use of the word millennial here.
Post reply on HN