Live data from Hacker News

A document to help you start a tech cooperative

feeltrain.com

51–60 of 91 posts

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#51

If someone is interested in doing this in India, here's our LLP agreement: - https://github.com/nilenso/cooperative-agreement . We've also written and talked about it a bit: - https://blog.nilenso.com/blog/2014/11/19/huh-a-software-coop... - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7K3E1Q_MBk

Nice!

Added as a reference to our incorporation documents: https://github.com/astralship/astralship.github.io/issues/47

Our rules: 1 page max.

If something more complicated - create a separate 1 page document.

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#52

If someone is interested in doing this in India, here's our LLP agreement: - https://github.com/nilenso/cooperative-agreement . We've also written and talked about it a bit: - https://blog.nilenso.com/blog/2014/11/19/huh-a-software-coop... - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7K3E1Q_MBk

I checked out your website and I really like what you are doing. I'm a student in India and would love to work with you. I mainly write Haskell and other functional languages like Scheme/Racket and some Clojure.

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#53

This is so awesome: https://feeltrain.com/blog/hello-feel-train/ I've had the same ideas over the last few years, even the hard limit on the number of people. It sounds like they are just doing some paid consulting work and sharing profits. But what I would like to do, is that everyone only works around 10 hours per week on consulting work, and we spend the rest of the time working on our own app or website ideas. Th…

They're a consulting shop, so it would be natural to say that people who leave don't share in the future profits. For your idea where considerable income is expected to come from past work, I'd say it makes more sense to have ownership of the app assigned to an ad-hoc company that owns just the app, owned by the people there at the time the app was written. The coöp might take a hand in marketing the app and performi…

Interesting ideas. One challenge is when App 1 needs an update, F and G doing some of the work. Or when App 1 becomes a building block of App 3.

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#54
I met some guys from a Spanish software coop called Igalia and as I understood it they have a kind of apprenticeship/ probation period after which you get voted on as a partner - or in some cases NOT.

It was quite a long process but I got the impression that people knew after a reasonable time if things were going in the right direction.

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#55
post #9
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn't this effect be much stronger in a worker-owned cooperative? Having an equal 20% stake seems much more motivating to me than the 0.4% that you might get as an early employee of a traditional tech startup, even if the shares diminish after you leave.

By this logic, worker-owned cooperatives can and should be expected to out-perform traditionally structured businesses. Do I interpret correctly? If that's true, then why do you think traditionally structured businesses generally out-perform cooperatives? People have tried.

Outperform by what metric?

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#56

Back in 19th century USA, during industrialization, the idea of working for someone came across to many as a form of wage-slavery. Going from farming or trade-skills to factories working, one gave up any control in their own worker rights and planning of their business. It seems fundamentally unfair that in most industries you don't have any real share of the company, or any say in the direction of it. People who con…

A huge proportion of the workforce are employed by listed, publicly traded companies. Those workers can use their salary to buy as many shares as they want on the open market, and also sell those shares whenever they want.

The fact that people tend not to do this very often tells you that people don't actually want to have any "real share of the company, or say in the direction of it".

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#57

Back in 19th century USA, during industrialization, the idea of working for someone came across to many as a form of wage-slavery. Going from farming or trade-skills to factories working, one gave up any control in their own worker rights and planning of their business. It seems fundamentally unfair that in most industries you don't have any real share of the company, or any say in the direction of it. People who con…

A huge proportion of the workforce are employed by listed, publicly traded companies. Those workers can use their salary to buy as many shares as they want on the open market, and also sell those shares whenever they want. The fact that people tend not to do this very often tells you that people don't actually want to have any "real share of the company, or say in the direction of it".

With an average salary, from whatever is left at the end of the month, these workers:

1. Can't​ buy "as many shares as they want".

2. Whatever they buy, considering the market cap and required volume for voting, will be statistical noise.

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#58

Back in 19th century USA, during industrialization, the idea of working for someone came across to many as a form of wage-slavery. Going from farming or trade-skills to factories working, one gave up any control in their own worker rights and planning of their business. It seems fundamentally unfair that in most industries you don't have any real share of the company, or any say in the direction of it. People who con…

More tech co-ops are great. The gig economy needs a unionization proxy to fight the ever worse contracts people are offering. But > "People who control those companies are solely executives or wall street share holders, not the people who spend countless hours making the company run and function" You imply that you think workers should all own equity in their employer. That sounds cruel and arbitrary to me. How is it…

>Who would want to work in that kind of environment?

People who want to help build an awesome company, and like being a part of the team, and not just an accessory to it.

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#59
post #52

If someone is interested in doing this in India, here's our LLP agreement: - https://github.com/nilenso/cooperative-agreement . We've also written and talked about it a bit: - https://blog.nilenso.com/blog/2014/11/19/huh-a-software-coop... - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7K3E1Q_MBk

I checked out your website and I really like what you are doing. I'm a student in India and would love to work with you. I mainly write Haskell and other functional languages like Scheme/Racket and some Clojure.

Super cool. We're primarily looking for senior folks at the moment, but it never hurts to start a conversation. We do contribute to open source projects commercially as well and sometimes we staff newer members of the team on these projects. Give us a shout at careers@nilenso.com

Re: A document to help you start a tech cooperative

#60

If someone is interested in doing this in India, here's our LLP agreement: - https://github.com/nilenso/cooperative-agreement . We've also written and talked about it a bit: - https://blog.nilenso.com/blog/2014/11/19/huh-a-software-coop... - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7K3E1Q_MBk

Nice! Added as a reference to our incorporation documents: https://github.com/astralship/astralship.github.io/issues/47 Our rules: 1 page max. If something more complicated - create a separate 1 page document.

We would love a rule like that. Unfortunately, Indian LLP (Limited Liability Partnerships -- the only way of creating a technology co-op in India at the moment) Partnership Agreements are easily 6 pages at a bare legal minimum. :)
Post reply on HN