Live data from Hacker News

A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

washingtonpost.com

21–30 of 549 posts

Re: A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

#21
They messed up and overbooked the flight, sure. But why on earth would they forcefully drag people out of the plane, while they could just find volunteers?

They could offer cash/miles to whoever volunteered, increasing the offer until someone accepted. I've seen other airlines do this on several occasions. They couldn't have handled it worse than they did.

Re: A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

#25
post #8

The outrage mob is pushing this pretty hard. Booting people off a plane is pretty shitty behavior for an airline. It's bad customer service and they should dealt with it earlier than after boarding. But if they have to do it, the passenger shouldn't be allowed to just refuse. This guy did. And he had to get dragged off the plane. I don't really see an alternative other than just letting anyone willing to scream to st…

I'm not one to get outraged easily, but seriously this story is shameful.

They needed the seats, fine. They asked for people to volunteer and no one did? Did they even offer maybe a 1st class on a flight taking off a few hours later? I can't imagine that out of more than 100 people they wouldn't find at least 4 interested in waiting in the airport to travel 1st class.

They handled that like bozos and I can absolutely see how a passenger chosen "at random" would make a fuss.

Re: A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

#26
post #6

Someone on a different message board put this situation very well: By the letter of the law, United was correct - morally, they were not. Their 'contract of carriage' allows them to IDB (Involuntary Deny Boarding) to passengers due to overselling, and bump people off at-will. Depending on how delayed the passenger would be to their final destination, they would owe compensation (up to a max of $1350) for the trouble.…

Legally - is this considered assault?

Or trespassing? Law is fun right?

Re: A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

#27
post #14
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like it wasn't the normal overbooking procedure - it was overfull because of united employees.

United employees taking passenger's seats? That's not overbooked. That's robbery.

Not like united employees going on vacation or to a meeting. But a flight crew going to where they need to be. It's part and parcel of an airline service. If they can't get to where they need to be a flight will have to be delayed or canceled.

Re: A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

#28
post #8

The outrage mob is pushing this pretty hard. Booting people off a plane is pretty shitty behavior for an airline. It's bad customer service and they should dealt with it earlier than after boarding. But if they have to do it, the passenger shouldn't be allowed to just refuse. This guy did. And he had to get dragged off the plane. I don't really see an alternative other than just letting anyone willing to scream to st…

Maybe they should just keep offering money until someone accepts. Surely someone would accept $1200 and a replacement ticket. It would have cost much less than what this PR fiasco has cost.

Re: A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

#29
post #12

Buried at the bottom: > "The airline eventually cleared everyone from the plane, Bridges said, and did not let them back on until the man was removed a second time — in a stretcher." My reading is they beat him so badly they had to put him in a stretcher. Is that right?

I would imagine it was a form of restraining him.

Re: A man wouldn’t leave an overbooked United flight, so he was dragged off

#30
post #8

The outrage mob is pushing this pretty hard. Booting people off a plane is pretty shitty behavior for an airline. It's bad customer service and they should dealt with it earlier than after boarding. But if they have to do it, the passenger shouldn't be allowed to just refuse. This guy did. And he had to get dragged off the plane. I don't really see an alternative other than just letting anyone willing to scream to st…

The responsible action, is for the business to accept the overbooking as their fault, and arrange alternative traveling plans for their employees. Forcibly removing a customer due to overbooking should never happen, and a customer should be able to refuse. His actions while extreme to some, were reasonable IMHO.
Post reply on HN