Live data from Hacker News

It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

beta.theglobeandmail.com

51–60 of 116 posts

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#51
post #7

With the prospect of Calexit, I would definitely consider having California join Canada. Preexisting trade deals, membership in NATO and NAFTA, and a country used to bilingual culture would all be a great fit for us.

Democrats fought for 100 years for confederacy in order to keep the slaves... and lost. Now, they are fighting to keep low wage illegal immigrants. When will they learn?

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#52
post #38
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Calexit will of course never happen. Any secession attempt would automatically lead to yet another civil war. California would be crushed.

> California would be crushed. If California gets crushed, the rest of the country will starve . And you really think that a military that couldn't pacify a city with a bunch of camel jockeys carrying AK-47's could pacify Compton let alone something the size of Los Angeles or San Francisco? Good luck with that. Calexit won't happen because Californians really don't want it. We're a pretty level-headed bunch even when…

>If California gets crushed, the rest of the country will starve.

Yeah, because California is the one producing all the food. Haha, how out of touch are you really?

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#53
post #6

There are some places in Canada even speak Scottish. We have lots of Scottish people and Irish too but quite far removed, distant relatives typically of at least 100 years. It would be interesting and I can certainly see how we Canadians and Scottish people are similar especially here on the east coast. But there are also big differences I'd say Scotland is more left of center politically than Canada usually is. But…

> There are some places in Canada even speak Scottish

Nit to be pedantic... but do you mean they speak with a sort of Scottish accent, or do you mean they are actually using words from Scots, Doric or some other Scottish dialect?

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#54
post #53
post #6

There are some places in Canada even speak Scottish. We have lots of Scottish people and Irish too but quite far removed, distant relatives typically of at least 100 years. It would be interesting and I can certainly see how we Canadians and Scottish people are similar especially here on the east coast. But there are also big differences I'd say Scotland is more left of center politically than Canada usually is. But…

> There are some places in Canada even speak Scottish Nit to be pedantic... but do you mean they speak with a sort of Scottish accent , or do you mean they are actually using words from Scots, Doric or some other Scottish dialect?

Scots is a language, historically equivalent to English - very similar but different.

Many modern english speakers derive from a Scots root rather than a purely English one.

E.g. Scots has a plural form of you, 'yous' and other differences.

Scotland has many other dialects like Doric and accents and other languages like the Gaelic of the Highlands.

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#55
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Polling models predicted that a majority of the UK population didn't want to leave the EU, so...

We don't need to rely on polling though. We already had a actual referendum on the matter not less than three years ago.

Then we went through a major political upheaval where the result on something that many Scottish people who voted No find quite important was something directly contrary to what the Scottish people wanted.

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#56
post #38
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Calexit will of course never happen. Any secession attempt would automatically lead to yet another civil war. California would be crushed.

> California would be crushed. If California gets crushed, the rest of the country will starve . And you really think that a military that couldn't pacify a city with a bunch of camel jockeys carrying AK-47's could pacify Compton let alone something the size of Los Angeles or San Francisco? Good luck with that. Calexit won't happen because Californians really don't want it. We're a pretty level-headed bunch even when…

> If California gets crushed, the rest of the country will starve.

See? That's why Calexit will never happen.

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#57
post #30
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Calexit will of course never happen. Any secession attempt would automatically lead to yet another civil war. California would be crushed.

So Americans will never amend the US constitution to allow a state to secede?

Votes don't add up so no, it won't happen.

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#58
post #3

It might be a nice thought experiment but it makes no sense in practice

Why not? There was a heavy amount of Scottish immigration canada, and they have similar governmental policies

The historical context is true, but this would be a net loss for Scotland

The "geography is moot" argument certainly isn't. They will have a border with the UK and will want some leeway there (as Northern Ireland wants to have with Ireland post-brexit)

Besides I'm sure the Scottish people will be delighted into start paying the extortionate mobile fees the rest of Canada pays.

I'm also sure they will find it lovely to leave SEPA back to settling payments with Cheques (LOL) or something that couldn't even pass for a school project today: ACH

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#59
post #39
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Last time some states tried to do that it didn't work out so well.

Those states didn't have the majority of the economic power when they tried it. The South needed to win ; the North simply needed to outlast.

Apps and search engines don't win wars

Re: It’s time for Scotland to find a new home in Canada

#60
> anti-egalitarian

anti-egalitarian when it comes to outcomes, pro-egalitarian when it comes to opportunity

> avowedly Christian

This ... is a bad thing ? It is not a bad thing to be unashamed of being a Christian.

> pro-Big Business

Pro-business. Small and Big. Pro-jobs.

> pro-military

Pro-self-defense.

> neo-liberal

Classical liberal

Post reply on HN