Live data from Hacker News

Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

blogs.gnome.org

51–60 of 155 posts

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#51
post #41

Gnome3 devs never asked for feedback. Gnome3 devs never cared. But they sure do like to write blog posts about hip stuff.

I never liked Gnome3, I don't know why, it might be because it uses way too much chrome space at the top, lot of wasted space.

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#52

The biggest grouse I have with most linux desktops I have is the font rendering. I understand that it is to do with the patents on cleartype etc, but its been so many years with this problem

So install freetype-freeworld and enjoy the nicer fonts.

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#53
Forum feedback, like HN feedback, is too extreme, and unless your product is exclusively marketed at the HN crowd, such feedback will be close to useless. You might have a big problem, for example, non-hackers can not write e-mails in Ubuntu, while HN-crowd are worried about battery life. So instead of taking one hour to fix the e-mail problem for thousands of users, you spend thousands of man-hours to marginally improve battery life to please a handful of users.

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#54

The biggest grouse I have with most linux desktops I have is the font rendering. I understand that it is to do with the patents on cleartype etc, but its been so many years with this problem

With the latest freetype (https://www.freetype.org/freetype2/docs/subpixel-hinting.htm...), and hinting off, there's not a lot to complain about.

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#55
My advice: Instead of supporting a bunch of hardware poorly make one laptop like the macbook pro with:

* 2 ram slots

* 2 M.2 SSD slots

* a decent kb

* a decent touchpad

* a decent screen

* discrete graphics

* good battery management (you can do this because it's only one)

* thunderbolt 3

* at least 3 usb ports

* no dvd

* ONE TRRS audio port

* ethernet

* HDMI for legacy reasons

forget about

* thinnest

* lightest

* or any other 'best' quality - it just has to be good

* touchscreen - no one uses this after day 2 or wants fingerprints on their screen

You will sell a lot of these.

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#56
post #48

If anyone's interested in trying Fedora I'd suggest checking out Korora, it bundles the Fedora base with nice themes and some essential packages/repositories that Fedora refuses to bundle based on their free software guidelines (like VLC) and some more sensible defaults (like Firefox as default browser instead of Epiphany). https://kororaproject.org/

Nice. I see it has Cinnamon, Mate, XFCE, Gnome and KDE flavours just like *ubuntu.

Fedora has those, too: https://spins.fedoraproject.org/

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#57

My advice: Instead of supporting a bunch of hardware poorly make one laptop like the macbook pro with: * 2 ram slots * 2 M.2 SSD slots * a decent kb * a decent touchpad * a decent screen * discrete graphics * good battery management (you can do this because it's only one) * thunderbolt 3 * at least 3 usb ports * no dvd * ONE TRRS audio port * ethernet * HDMI for legacy reasons forget about * thinnest * lightest * or…

https://minifree.org/product/libreboot-x220/

Upd: this is a 12" laptop. However, they offered Libreboot X400 before, which is 14". You can still get one via https://minifree.org/product/libreboot-installation-service/

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#58
I'm using Fedora again as my desktop after some years on OS X. Things that I'd like to see:

* A better email app. Currently none can be said to work very well. I'm actually considering mutt at this point

* A better Gnome Calendar. I think this is coming in the next release.

* A PDF viewer that supports highlighting.

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#59

My advice: Instead of supporting a bunch of hardware poorly make one laptop like the macbook pro with: * 2 ram slots * 2 M.2 SSD slots * a decent kb * a decent touchpad * a decent screen * discrete graphics * good battery management (you can do this because it's only one) * thunderbolt 3 * at least 3 usb ports * no dvd * ONE TRRS audio port * ethernet * HDMI for legacy reasons forget about * thinnest * lightest * or…

> touchscreen - no one uses this after day 2 or wants fingerprints on their screen

As a counterpoint: I've turned off the touchpad on my Surface pro 4 - and constantly touch non-touch screens when I'm helping others...

I rarely use a pointing device though - for example I use vimperator/vimium for web browsing and vi for editing (or vi keybindingings in vs code).

But I guess I agree that I don't want a touch screen without a great pen with at least some pressure sensitivity - drawing really is so much more fun and easy - both diagrams, notes and doodles.

Re: Fedora dev: “HN feedback on what they want from their Desktop – We got it”

#60

My advice: Instead of supporting a bunch of hardware poorly make one laptop like the macbook pro with: * 2 ram slots * 2 M.2 SSD slots * a decent kb * a decent touchpad * a decent screen * discrete graphics * good battery management (you can do this because it's only one) * thunderbolt 3 * at least 3 usb ports * no dvd * ONE TRRS audio port * ethernet * HDMI for legacy reasons forget about * thinnest * lightest * or…

Where did you get these specs from? A survey?
Post reply on HN