Live data from Hacker News

Brexit Britain Could Replace Migrants with Robots

bloomberg.com

11–20 of 88 posts

Re: Brexit Britain Could Replace Migrants with Robots

#11
post #7

Considering many people who design and develop the tech for robots in the UK are migrants, i don't think this strategy will fare particularly well

If I understand UK visa rules correctly, getting a work permit as someone who designs or develops tech for robots is as easy as getting a job offer from a company that wants you to design or develop tech for robots for them.

Re: Brexit Britain Could Replace Migrants with Robots

#13
post #11
post #7

Considering many people who design and develop the tech for robots in the UK are migrants, i don't think this strategy will fare particularly well

If I understand UK visa rules correctly, getting a work permit as someone who designs or develops tech for robots is as easy as getting a job offer from a company that wants you to design or develop tech for robots for them.

Yes, but getting a work permit from one EU member state to another is even easier. And you can put down roots there.

Re: Brexit Britain Could Replace Migrants with Robots

#17
post #5

The problem with having robots do this kind of work is that the majority don't integrate well: they don't learn English, they don't drink in pubs and they have their own schools.

I am sure if we try enough we can integrate robot society into our society. Little William can go to school with little Robby and they can be best friends, until one day when Robby tries to give William a hug inadvertently killing him. Then I believe there will be a real backlash against robot society.

Or when little Robby drives through 50 people at Westminster bridge. Hmm, makes me rethink self driving cars...

Re: Brexit Britain Could Replace Migrants with Robots

#19
post #12

Clickbait title keyed to feed our current robot fears. Should at least have the qualifier " for low skilled jobs in the manufacturing sector"

> qualifier " for low skilled jobs in the manufacturing sector"

For most of the people whose main reason for voting for Brexit was immigration's effects on jobs, these are the jobs that they seem the immigrants as competition for.

The theory is that the immigrants were willing to work for less so "stole" the menial, mind-numbing, often physical, & sometimes seasonal jobs. Having a number of such complainers in my family and otherwise in ear-shot I'd say the issue for many employers is not "being willing to work for less" but more "being willing to work to much of a standard at any price", but I digress... If the robots work out cheaper over a short enough amount of time (allowing for the large up-front investment in both the robots directly and any changes needed to make the environment one that can be efficient in) then it is logical that businesses will let them "steal" the jobs instead of accepting that they'll have to pay local workers more.

> keyed to feed our current robot fears

This isn't the first article to cover the possibility. I've been reading the headlines, particularly those in the UK press, as more a poke at the people who voted for leaving mainly due to the jobs issue - a message of "not what you wanted, eh?, don't say we didn't tell you...".

Re: Brexit Britain Could Replace Migrants with Robots

#20

The problem with having robots do this kind of work is that the majority don't integrate well: they don't learn English, they don't drink in pubs and they have their own schools.

Most of them even come into the country hidden in the back of lorrys and don't have passports. They don't even live in private accommodation, instead occupying the commercial property in which they work. How come we don't read about this in the Daily Mail?
Post reply on HN