Live data from Hacker News

Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

jeffreymartens.com

31–40 of 181 posts

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#31

I wonder how much of that has to do with their providing "xfinity" wifi to anyone nearby who wants to share your cable line? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xfinity#Xfinity_WiFi

FWIW Comcast claims this will not affect the speed [0]. At the low speeds in the OP's article, this is likely the case.

[0] https://www.xfinity.com/support/internet/xfinity-wifi-hotspo...

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#32

The best thing anyone can do is swap out the junky cable modem + WiFi router combos they rent to you. They're horrible under standard usage, bad when lots of clients are connected, bad wifi range, low memory, require frequent reboots, etc. For about $70 (about 5mos of rental charges) you can get a Surfboard barebones Docsis 3 modem that will vastly outperform whatever junk they rent out. After that you could get a TP…

This is a thing I would kind of want to do, but I've never bothered to figure out how. Like how will I know if it's a compatible modem, or better than what's there? How do you configure it?

So those are my reasons.

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#33
Umm, they ship a crappy radio in their wifi device. They know this, the technician "installing" it even told me not to use it.

I had nearly the exact same results after disabling wifi and patching in an Apple Airport Express that I could connect to using 5GHz spectrum.. Speeds jumped from 25Mbps down to ~95Mbps down and latency dropped from 20ms to 9ms.

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#34
Don't use Speedtest.net. The major providers all prioritize their traffic and it gives unrealistic results.

I built a graphical console-based speed tester (client+server) that you can run yourself to get a more accurate picture and test between your home and servers you actually use:

https://github.com/chrissnell/sparkyfish

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#35

Comcast's business practices aren't great, but I will give them credit. I get every Mbps that they claim I am supposed to get. This is plugged into my router (Turris Omnia) and my cable modem (self-owned Arris SB6190). http://www.dslreports.com/speedtest/13090043

Of course, there's always the suspicion that ISPs, including Comcast, give priority to the various speed-test sites...

http://www.dslreports.com/forum/r28685577-Speed-comcast-spee...

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#36
Is it possible your wireless channel was overused? Most of my neighbors have comcast, as do we. I've had poor coverage and connection also, couldnt even get our wireless printer to work anymore. I used a program called WifiInfoView and viewed how many nearby wireless networks there were, their signal strengths, and set my router to a channel that wasn't being used.

Cleared up all of our problems instantly. I would check this, perhaps his google modem was preset to another channel.

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#37

Comcast's business practices aren't great, but I will give them credit. I get every Mbps that they claim I am supposed to get. This is plugged into my router (Turris Omnia) and my cable modem (self-owned Arris SB6190). http://www.dslreports.com/speedtest/13090043

You are using your own equipment, right? Thats the point of this post....their equipment doesn't support their service speeds, you have to use your own.

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#38
This is interesting. I had the same experience in Mountain View - paid for 100mbps+ service, and only got 30 - and even that was haphazard.

I went through a series of support requests. I eventually complained to the FCC and cancelled service. Once I involved the FCC, I had a rep call me, say they absolutely understood why I would cancel given my experience and wish me well. They provided me a partial refund for service levels that they never provided me with, and for days which I received no service.

I'm on Sonic now and I've been happy with them. The few times I've had problems they have been very responsive, and you definitely get the sense that their techs know what they are doing. They scoffed at the idea that they would ever sell their customer's data after the recent bill passed, and pointed out that although they resell AT&T service, their contract prevents AT&T from selling it either. It's the only ISP that has made a statement about their intentions publicly. I get a lower service level than what comcast promised, but I actually get that speed, and sometimes burst higher than promised.

Re: Comcast internet speed improved with non-Comcast hardware

#39
That seems to be common practice, also in Europe, across providers. And a single look at the GPL source code for your cable modem usually offers the reason (ancient kernels, slow CPUs, more security nightmares than you ever wanted to see)... replace your provider-supplied modem by an AVM FritzBox Cable and boom, gone are the wifi and cable speed problems.

Not to mention that AVM has quite a good track record when it comes to security fixes... way better than every other SOHO router vendor I have encountered.

Downside: newer FritzBoxes are way less open than they used to be (no Telnet, no selfbuilt firmware support), and they can't do VLAN.

(Not employed or business related with AVM, just an extremely happy customer)

Post reply on HN